Was he right, Holla Forums?

...

Due to red army soldiers defecting to the black army, the red army was spread thin in the time of Russian civil war. As you might imagine, that's not very good. The black army later refused to integrate back into the red army and was defeated. What a waste.

And neither are you, because the rebels chose to join the other rebellions against the will of their comrades no less. Civilian casualties pr not, the rebels effectively got them killed by instigating rebellion while bolsheviks had a handful of a civil war already to deal with.

You know you could always ctrl+f that shit.

Which they were right to do
and again

Again it was their choice, who you should be pissed at is Lenin for invading in the first place.
What am I looking for, exactly?

It's typically useful to refer to specific references when you're talking about specific points.

Please stop implying ancom catalonia and ancom ukraine are the only notion of anarchists societies

First book is entirely about the Makhovist non-state and its non-state secret service.

The second link, if you copy it entirely, links to a book with the specific portion I wanted you to see, complete with a ctrl + F onto the key words I wanted you to see.

Kekalonia is even more depressing, so I'd rather only link you to their very anarchic project's exploits only if you ask me to.

They weren't. The act harmed the red army and bolsheviks rying to deal with the civil war and the peasants who refused to till the fields to make sure people got food, hence the peasant rebellions and formation of green armies which also had to be defeated.

And again, under the circumstances, it was detrimental to the bolsheviks. Your 'being in the right' or 'it's their choice' doesn't change the fact that the country was under civil war with numerous other unjustified rebellions already happening.

They received war bonds in return or money with the grain sold at a fixed price. If that is a problem, then sorry, but it was needed.

More on Makhnovia with sources in the description: youtube.com/watch?v=ZiSM8SkE4mo

The act wouldn't have harmed the Red Army if they just fought the Whites together with the Blacks. Considering how the Red Army won regardless and turned out how they did, I'd say those defectors made the right choice. The Red Army could've left the Blacks alone but they were a threat to their hegemony and their power, so they did to them like they did to everyone else who didn't unquestioningly obey them.

no lol.

did that shit eating faggot even read state and revolution

No fucking way.