Humanity

None of the things you listed are inherently spooks. In fact, nothing is inherently a spook. Things, concepts, thoughts, etc. become spooks when you relate to them as something sacred; something that impairs your individual impetus (ego). Even I know to properly understand things before I qualify them as useless or retarded, and Stirner and his ethics for me is those things.

not an argument

not an argument

sounds like you guys have some growing up to do.

Class as the left understands it is not a spook because it's a societal and material relation.

Class under capitalism generally falls under two categories, people who primarily receive their income through exchange of labor, and people who primarily receive income through the use of their property rights. In other systems, we have other classes. A feudalist system will include the property-rights ownership of the capitalists (hence the term middle class as a description of the capitalist), but it will also include the nobility who receive tithes under the feudal system from the peasantry working their land.

By including morality and class you provide a measure for spookiness that would entail literally everything being imagined outside of nature i.e history, the light waves beaming into your eyes, the nervous system that feeds information to the brain, gravity, the walls on your house etc etc

You offer too wide a net for spooks that damages the philosophy to the point of being ridiculous and pointless. While yes its ultimately true history does have shifting narratives based on the observers spooks, it did happen, there is a class structure and humanity has existed to create and experience said history.

Stirnerites would point out this system relies upon peoples personal spooks and narriatives to exits but that does not mean the physical system is imagined.

Think of a rollercoaster, the enjoyment gained from riding one, the feelings it brings up are imagined (the idea a class system works and is beneficial) but the rollercoaser itself, the train car, the mechanism to make it move round the track are all real (the class system)

Im not an expert, thats just my basic understanding of the stirnerite viewpoint :/

Maybe. And ? Spooks have a tremendous physical power over the world.

Maybe to you. Millions of people still feel it. Why should your materialistic prison replace their own spiritual one ?

Sorry sorry sorry, i wrote "morality and class" in my first sentence, i ment to say "humanity and class"!

Huurr durrr im a philsosphizer

I am a NEET. I have transcended your pathetic notions of class.

history is indeed, a spook. there is no such thing as an objective history. you are biased, historians are biased, the passing of time has destroyed any posibility of objective understanding of history.


they are spooks in that they are subjective. i am not colorblind, i am not a bug,… thus this causes me to see light waves in a different manner than others.


prove it to me. every notion of morality comes down in the end to metaphysical nonsense.

Then you fall somewhere between the reserve army of labor and the lumpenproletariat. Both are still broadly part of the working class.

doesn't matter, humanity is still a spook, a sacral idol for ideology.

might makes right I see


that is all that matters. to me. you and all the other spooked can wallow in your metaphysical delusion as much as you want.

lmao. next thing you are going to tell me jesus was real.

A demonologist transcended mongolist professor and Geist activist was teaching a class on Hegel, known necromancer.

"Before the class begins, you must get on your knees and worship the end of history and accept that Absolute Idealism is the most highly-evolved sophism to make us feel good about ourselves the continent has ever known, even greater than self-serving petit-bourgeois protestant theology!"

At this moment an uncaring if he was brave because being judged by illusionary social standards was of no importance to him, egoist, unique girl's school teacher who had smoked more than 15000 cigars in Hippel's winebar and understood the spookiness of all ideology and fully supported whatever he felt like stood up and held up "Der Einzige und sein Eigentum".

"I wrote this, innit?"

The arrogant professor smirked quite synthetically and smugly replied "It's not yours at all, fucking egoist, its the stern, reluctant working of reason towards the full realization of itself in perfect freedom."

"Wrong. It's been a few years or something (time is nothing to me) since I, the Unique One, created it. if it was not mine, and idealism, as you say, is not a spook… then Ghost Busters wouldn't have had a happy ending."

The professor was visibly shaken, and dropped his balls and copy of Plato's dialogues. He stormed out of the room crying those ironic thesis and antithesis tears, both coming together on his cheeks into synthesis. There is no doubt that at this point our professor, Hegel (who liked to teach about himself), wished he had pulled himself up by his bootstraps and become more than a spook ridden sad cunt interested in arbitrary justifications. He wished so much that he had some kind of Own to hold on to, and he had but just didn't realise it because he was an involuntary egoist.

The students applauded and all started milk shops that day and accepted their Self-Enjoyment as the end of philosophy. An eagle named "Union of Egoists" flew into the room and perched atop the copy of "Stirner's Critics" and shed a beer on the hardcover. "Ich hab' Mein Sach' auf Nichts gestell" was said several times, and Renzo Novatore himself showed up and demonstrated how hand grenades are nothing but a means of killing police officers.

The professor lost his tenure and was fired the next day. He died of superstition and his "books" were disregarded for all eternity.