Did he do anything wrong? I need the truth. Did he only kill reactionaries and nazis? If so I got full tankie maoist asap
Did he do anything wrong? I need the truth. Did he only kill reactionaries and nazis...
Julian Jones
Cooper Moore
Stalin did nothing wrong.
He was a good Christian boy.
Samuel James
Of course there were some innocent people that were killed. I read about it. Some really envious people would denouce people they didn't liked to be sent to the gulag…but you know, it's colateral damage, it happens.
Ryan Wood
He personally killed 57 Anarcho-communists during the civil war in Ukraine…
Caleb Rivera
you've got to crack a few eggs to make a shitty communist omelette
Cameron Baker
Jeremiah Gomez
Making your ideology depended on person X doing Y is a little retarded tbh.
I mean of course he did some things wrong, but considering what he achieved I'd say the good definitely massively outweighs the bad. The only thing I really blame him for is not making preparations for a transition of power after his death, leaving his legacy up for destruction by careerists.
Zachary Ross
Any actual facts?
Austin Hughes
He killed who needed to be killed and it worked. When the revolution comes again you can bet we are going to be rounding up the piggies and subversives once again as it should be. If you're not with us you're against us.
Daniel Thompson
Brandon Gonzalez
links to wikipedia
Oliver Sullivan
this
Thomas Garcia
there is no soviet wikipedia
Logan Nelson
kek.
Angel Gutierrez
Dindu nuffin. Communism is achieved with literal dictatorship.
Austin Walker
He did a lot of terrible things but he wasn't alone on them. This Great Man History shit needs to stop.
Gavin Gray
oh it's this stupid meme again
read Marx
Michael Perez
WEW
Carson Lopez
He did what was necessary.
Justin Anderson
Perhaps then we would get a better picture of who he was that wasn't obscured or skewed by propaganda and time.
Jackson King
I think what Stalin did or didn't do is largely irrelevant at this point and we should hope anything bad he might have done doesn't happen again.
Cameron Sanchez
oh it's this stupid meme again
Liam Nelson
whatever he did, it worked
Russia stayed with Socialism for over 50 years
Isaiah Davis
...
Jayden Hall
not real socialism™
Dominic Sanchez
Sure workers had all the power over means of production and not the party`s central committee.
Bentley Rodriguez
they will have even more power when they pander to corporations with socdems amirite
Oliver Nguyen
Quality argument.
Cameron Thompson
They will have free trade unions where a communist party does not push down their wages or increase their workload like in China and Vietnam. Without freedom to something basic as forming a trade union how can you expect workers to follow you?
Oliver Stewart
...
Eli Smith
Every single revolution that has had any relative success started spontaneously.
Jack Edwards
...
Adrian Bailey
Good way to shit up a crop.
Josiah Harris
and you guys wonder why us "tankies" call you liberals? seriously?
Nathaniel Watson
kek.
Bentley Rivera
Yes he did, because nobody is perfect. Icon worship of any commie leaders would have Marx turning in his grave. Tbh, regardless of whether or not he did anything wrong, trying to "save" his image is bad praxis because the average person has been spoonfed ideology their whole life, so they think you're no better than a nazi trying to save Hitler's image. It's just not really useful for anything. History is history. Focus on the here and now. Focus on what we can provide materially to the cause. Debating which dead person has the moral high ground is utterly pointless.
Jayden Lopez
He indirectly killed hundreds of millions and directly killed about 400.
He was famous for his signature move the Peoples Elbow.
Brody Walker
he certainly did:
besides all of the above, he was a nice man, i guess.
Adrian Cook
oh please
Brandon Campbell
what's your point? is he guilty or not?
Cameron Diaz
directly guilty
David Bailey
Literally had all his friends - the Old Bolsheviks - murdered. Recriminalized homosexuality - came up with the shitty & un-dialectical "theory" of Socialism in One Country to cover his ass for the public - undid much of Lenin's work - was a fucker
Gabriel Diaz
...
Chase Sanchez
Better than Londonistani Corbynism.
Blow it out your ass.
Jack Long
No. He did everything he wanted to do, right.
Lenin did everything wrong. And that's why we need to do the same, but right.
Point is, he was a faggot and he wanted to do faggotry.
Would be best if he stoped at robbing banks for the party.
Parker White
Only the Purge was wrong, though.
Dominic Anderson
Not everyone is a tankie here