Post a valid critique of left communism that doesn't involve le epic armchair memes

Post a valid critique of left communism that doesn't involve le epic armchair memes.

Other urls found in this thread:

marxists.org/archive/gorter/1920/open-letter/index.htm
marxists.org/archive/gorter/1920/open-letter/
quinterna.org/lingue/english/historical_en/left_wing_communism_00.htm
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

It's non-existent outside some very obscure corners of the internet.

Uhhhhhhhhh, shit

Post a valid leftcom revolutionary strategy that doesn't involve armchairs

...

This

It's a tired meme that debunks itself if you read a book

marxists.org/archive/gorter/1920/open-letter/index.htm

Post a valid ML revolutionary strategy that will actually abolish private property

Can't come up with any, I find myself agreeing 99% of the time with leftcoms

Hard to find. Lenin's LWC is still the best and contemporary communisation and ultra-left currents have all since long digested it. Read Dauvé for more.


There it is. LWC is not bad at all, but principally a theoretical critique and one first aimed at the Dutch-German currents (the founders of the left communist opposition) and their anti-partyism. The biggest critique of Lenin's against them was that the success of the October revolution never translated to Europe at all, with the rise of social democratic paramilitarism against the communists and the rise of fascism being too strong and too surprising of a force.

Consider Gorter's response to LWC: marxists.org/archive/gorter/1920/open-letter/
And Bordiga's: quinterna.org/lingue/english/historical_en/left_wing_communism_00.htm

"Post a criticism of this thing in the torture chamber for this thing that meets my arbitrary standards which I will determine on the fly to show you how great Communism is."

Okay, my valid critique of left communism is that it's always run by fundamentally dishonest people like you, OP. You don't give a single fuck about the little people, you just want to feel oppressed because daddy didn't give you enough attention.