What where the leading reasons for failure of German revolution of 1918?
What where the leading reasons for failure of German revolution of 1918?
Connor Bailey
Easton Stewart
Socdems
Aiden Garcia
Partly, but SocDems wouldn't be able to do shit if there wasn't a mass of proto-fascist Freikorps out there. The Freikorps hated the SocDems just as well, since they were seen as responsible for the surrender and the shameful treaty of Versailles.
The true reasons are going back to 1848 and then later to Bismarck. Also the fact that the proletariat wasn't as pushed to the edge as in Russia.
Cooper Nguyen
Considering that the iron front was laid down only by 1919(along with the whole freikorps smash up) I don`t think that is intellectually honest view(specially considering that the independent social democratic party of 1918 was the primary organizatior of the revolution and later the whole communist party of Germany)
Easton Flores
Bernie Sanders
Josiah Rodriguez
Freikorps
about rosa, it was peer pressure. Everyone was shooting communists, we just wanted to be popular.
Chase Green
I would blame the lack of central leadership(fact that high command sent strike leaders into the front didnt really help) and the spontaneous nature that the uprising had.
Nathan Wood
The soldiers not joining the revolution en masse and instead putting it down.
Alexander Thomas
FUCKING SOCDEMS GET OUT OF MY MOTHERLAND REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
also hey Holla Forums
Adam Jones
read this: libcom.org
tankies are retarded.
Chase Mitchell
The fact that armed revolutions cannot create socialism
Aiden Williams
Just ask porky nicely and he'll give up control of the entire world.
Camden Moore
The absence of a communist party.
William Robinson
Your forgetting that the Freikorps had their origins in the Social Democratic party, that's not just a coincidence.
Juan Hill
This.
Jayden Howard
So did the revolution itself.
What is your point?
Jonathan Brooks
No. Just no.
Owen Wilson
This is probably the single most infuriating thing about arguing with both tankies and anarkiddies, most of their ideas look identical when put into practice, anarchists are just a lot better at coming up with bullshit new names for everything so it's "not a state".
Andrew Price
What am I reading?
William Martinez
David Butler
...
John Johnson
What does it have to do with my post?
Blake Williams
A large portion of the Freikorps were turncoats who came out of the Social Democratic party, maybe it's just coincidence, but I think most Marxists don't have a meaningful explanation for why this happened.
Henry Lee
Proves your point wrong,incorrect,non-factual etc. etc.
Julian Campbell
That is still a no.
Robert Rodriguez
The Freikorps were made up of royalist WW1 officers returning from the front.
Ethan Turner
SocDem meant something else then. Up until the russian revolution, every socialist/communist party was social democrats. Read Reform or Revolution by Rosa Luxemburg.
James Fisher
Yeah no shit. See
Brody Murphy
Nvm, I'm retarded
Joshua Mitchell
They were allied(ie organized with) spartacist league.
Lucas Baker
lack of popular support
Juan Reed
Yes, and after the Spartacist Uprising multiple SocDems joined their ranks and gave them direct material support.
Eli Perez
SocDem
Easton Kelly
I misspoke by saying "origins", but the contemporary Freikorps of post-WWI did get direct support from the SocDems, and a large number of their membership came out of the Social Democratic party
Leo Hernandez
So? Parties do not start revolutions genius, even if it's the spartacist league.
Austin Gray
The old Prussian establishment
Nathan Baker
You
Chase Kelly
Socdems did it. They are basically the demorats of Europe and must be purged from that continent.
Benjamin Richardson
It was not something German peoplr wanted but a kike plot by insane Marxists to hand power to Soviets and kill german culture.
Michael Anderson
...
Thomas Scott
...
Owen Turner
Jews don't control the word, mate. It's the Irish. I was surprised to find out myself, but JPEG's don't lie. Swallow the green pill.
Dominic Clark
Anarkiddies fucked it up
Wyatt Evans
The split happened too late