What's stopping communists from buying land in La Patagonia or some equally unregulated and unknown place and...

What's stopping communists from buying land in La Patagonia or some equally unregulated and unknown place and reenacting their unique communist dream there?

At least you would have proof that communism can work for a community of 100 people. A historical first!

Other urls found in this thread:

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rojava_conflict
vice.com/en_us/article/vive-le-tarnac-nine-407-v17n4
theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/20/marinaleda-spanish-communist-village-utopia
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

You don't know what communism is.

Lack of capital in the large sense

Not really, the whole neolithic era and medieval communities functionned with quite communistic principles.
Capitalism as a dominant mode of production is a recent thing.

You know there are literally millions of people participating in a horizontally organized socialist collective right now in Syria right?

we need the whole world

No, I don't. Proofs?

See

Communism is not about going Amish.


Also, I'm getting flashbacks of Paraguay:

Few years later:

People have been living in primitive communal societies before we even invented fucking agriculture. Moreover, so-called utopian socialists have been also doing that "lel let's move into a shithole and establish a self-sustainable community here" with greater or lesser success long before Marx and Bakunin. However, it has been branded as utopian for a reason, as the communal society consisting of one village a) operates differently than an entire country with thousand or even millions of people b) isn't going to change the world aside from maybe getting coverage in national geographic.

What a fucking retarded hw was by thinking he could start a war against Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay at the same timeā€¦and win! kek

Read this and then go soak your head for being so dumb.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rojava_conflict

...

We did that multiple times. It worked so well in paris back in the 18th century that half the inner city joined and the government killed almost all of them because they we're a thread to their power.

OP Literally blown the fuck out.

Praise commie skelingtons

Read the news bruv.

look up rojava nigger

This is why liberals must be dehumanized and rejected and why socialists must become ruthless and resolute. History repeatedly confirms the truth that liberalism and liberals never stop coveting unitary power and it really is them or us.

That had been done thousands of times, and it worked. See Epicurus. All the communes modeled after his garden, were basically proto-communist, and many turned into monasteries later on.

But we don't want to just "flee from capitalism" ourselves. We aren't just utopians. We know that capitalism has it's shortcomings, it's limits, it's contradiction and it's dangers to the world. We oppose these things, and want to help others recognize these too, to bring about a better society, for all.

Basically

nice propaganda

and yet the last time is some dubious account 200 years ago?

Then do it again, instead of citing something that happened 2900 years ago

Then make your communities popular and slowly take over the world. Create a subreddit and make it famous. Is there even a modern list of such communities and their location?

the robot dream

...

yeah, no wonder literally nobody knows about these "communist societies"

vice.com/en_us/article/vive-le-tarnac-nine-407-v17n4

Because people get persecuted just for being communists even and especially when they withdraw from society.

theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/20/marinaleda-spanish-communist-village-utopia

Don't be a cunt your whole life OP.

Argentina won't persecute you.

There have been a million such experiments in the XIX century, where a group of idealist settlers secure a bit of land in an American country and try to enact their anarchist/socialist utopia. I think a lot of them fell to infighing among the leaders.

They have a very right-wing government right now so i doubt it.

Not an argument you leaking asshole.

I was making a joke; we actually do have a subreddit but its shit.
Leftists honestly do their best to spread propaganda, it's just that the establishment does everything in its power to stomp out these ideas.

lol, they are liberals


If they work, CREATE MORE. Create many many many, until the whole world has joined you.

Because I have a family.
Why don't capitalists just fuck off and John Galt it up on a renovated aircraft carrier somewhere in the Pacific? Oh, that's right, because without their exploitation of labor through monopoly on capital, they would all die since they are a parasite class.

That is kinda what anarcho-syndicalism is tbh.
The only problem is that we need to control the means of production to actually gain any leverage over our standard of living. Starting from scratch and living like primates can work but it does convince people. Reversing thousands of years of progress just to demonstrate that primitive-communism works in a commune is not the same as showing how communism works on a larger industrial scale.

You're a fucking retard. No economic system was brought forth through a network of amish-tier villages. It has always happened through civil unrest combined with some disasters(almost always the economic ones). Feudalism was not dismantled in France peacefully, but after an economic crisis let the city-dwellers overthrow the ancien regime and guillotine the nobles. Slavery in the US has been abolished by force, which also sparked a massive civil war because the slave owners were not just willing to be nice give up their power. The Russian Tsardom was overthrown when the entire country was on the verge of collapse due to German pressure.
Also read Rosa and/or Lenin.

opinion automatically discarded

thread automatically discarded

I'd understand your point if I didn't give you an brief overview why your idea of tiny-ass villages as a way to establishing a new economic system is stupid. Seriously, try to read political theory sometimes.

How long before Rojava goes the way of Catalonia?

HAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA

OKAY, NOW IM 100% SURE THIS IS UNDERAGE POL

GOODBYE LADS

...

how can any kind of special snowflake leftism ever work in real life, when it is so axiomatically and fundamentally fucked from the start? if step 1 is finding excuses all day everyday, what's the fucking point of anything
these guys are legit imperial nazi fascists larping as some weird symbols the party said we should put on hats and belts, they are the only kind of "leftists" that ever did anything about it, and their whole ideology can be summed up as "avoided gulag for today"

remember to sage and report shitty bait threads

Can you explain your post with your fingers on the keyboard and not your anus on the keyboard

It was Brazil who started war: by invading Uruguay. Paraguay and Argentina were supposed to defend Uruguay against Brazil together, but Argentina switched sides, while Uruguay got overrun and Brazil established a puppet regime there.

That's how Paraguay ended up fighting alone against Triple Alliance. Not by declaring war on everyone.