Once and for all, which SMG game did you enjoy the most? Which one was dare I say…objectively better?

Once and for all, which SMG game did you enjoy the most? Which one was dare I say…objectively better?

1

Galaxy 1 was actually new shit, Galaxy 2 is a glorified expansion pack.

1.

To reply to my own thread, SMG2 because Yoshi.

I actually liked 2 better. 1 was solid but was just missing a certain something. In 2 they really nailed it imo.

This isn't like comparing Ocarina to Major's mask those two games have fundamental differences.
Galaxy 1 and 2 are the same shit, I don't think either is better then the other since they are the same thing, save for a few power ups and Yoshi. You can play any level from one game and drop down into the other without missing a beat since so little is different.

Well, the stages on 2 are more enjoyable to me.

Yeah more or less the same, but they tinkered with the levels to get it more right I think.

1. Galaxy 2, even though it have better platforming, it felt really fucking shallow, and they removed the damn nice hub, and even Rosalina.
They should have added the worlds of SMG2 to the first game and call it a day, the story is the same anyway. Fuck the mario head shit too.