Edward Snowden Jeremy Scahill Jürgen Todenhöfer Paul Jay Richard Wolff Srecko Horvat
Our Topics:
Privacy, civil rights and mass surveillance Western foreign policy and Germany’s role US foreign policy and the military industrial complex Freedom and democracy in the current economic system Function and role of independent and mainstream media Development, possibilities and urgency of political activism and grassroots movements
Listened to Horvat at Elevate Festival last year. Good guy.
Joshua Morales
they need to hurry up and put papa Wolff on
Carter Watson
um no The fuck is wrong with you
Jaxson Barnes
Holy shit what if Papa Wolff shouts us out again, and we get noticed by other leftist academics
Robert Thomas
are you calling me out
Joseph Howard
You just have to remember that freedom aint free the tree of liberty and freedom got to be litter'd with the blood of patriots. Barack HUSEIN obama is not my president he is an islamic gommunist and proballly kenyan as well :—DD Adam and EVE not Adam and STEVE ok? Praise jesus.
Wyatt Scott
the croat dude said some good things about refugees
Matthew Thompson
Yeah I'm enjoying listening to his opinions on it
John Turner
Did I miss Scahill?
Jason James
Nah. Only Horvat has spoken so far.
Ian Smith
No it's only been Horvat.
David Gomez
this just got extremely awkward…
Jace Johnson
Lol how has he never heard of 789 joke
James Rogers
Did he say Paul Jay isn't gonna be able to make it?
Alexander White
Never mind. He's coming
Anthony Watson
...
Leo Sanders
Schillinger really turned his life around.
Ethan Johnson
So we have embraced the LARPing and are dressing up as pirates now?
Josiah Richardson
I'm from Munich and didn't hear about this.
Could someone kindly kill me?
Aaron Jackson
Dont trust anything that Todenhöfer says, hes a clueless liar.
William Perez
Sure
Jonathan Wood
Why am I not surprised that the fucking tankie is a Bavarian from Munich
Ian Martin
...
Anthony Cook
I CAN HEAR THE HOST BREATHING THROUGH HIS NOSTRILS AND I HATE IT
Jace Richardson
there's nothing wrong with a little dress up
Zachary Diaz
LOL thought it was me breathing too loud. Knew I wasn't crazy
Adrian Powell
oh God
Charles Price
What a mess. This is why we can't have socialism.
Cooper Garcia
I'm not born Bavarian. and Munich became an absolute shithole due to gentrification but at least we got this grassroot activism channel apparently
Landon Roberts
RDW starts in about 25 mins for the ones wondering
Zachary Perez
did they really just use some shitty wifi for their connection? aren't there better ways to do that?
Jonathan Walker
At least he has the balls to actually go somewhere where none of these fair weather "journalists" would ever dare to go.
I'm not sure if you can call somebody clueless who actually went into the heart of the IS to interview them. He probably has more authentic information about some stuff compared to what you get anywhere else.
Dylan Moore
Germany and Munich in particular is known for having Somali tier Internet.
Gavin Watson
Why?
John Young
Paul Jay did a really good documentary about wrestling call Wrestling with Shadows which is mostly about Bret Hart. 10/10 would recommend.
Scum should get a day in prison for every civillian that died in the conflict
Charles Nguyen
he's still fucking doing it
Isaiah Butler
creating an alternative media to combat misinformation is really important here in greece the mainstream media have gone beyond covering up news and propaganda and now they are at the phase of completely making stuff up
When was the last time CNN covered climate change?
Tyler Butler
we need more of this
Cameron Lewis
Well, it's true.
Jacob Ramirez
PAPA WOLFF IS COMING ON BOIS
Aiden Morales
HE'S COMIN BUCKOS
Bentley Hall
PAPA WOLFF
Wyatt Howard
Can I pay my landlord with ecoplasm?
Jaxson Morales
CO-OPS IN T MINUS 5…4…3…2…
Noah Butler
THA WOLFF
Gabriel Taylor
Wolff-senpai!
Brody Rodriguez
wolff has a nice house
Jordan Jackson
...
Jace Nelson
Actually glad I didn't go there, really awkward how they failed to properly set up the Internet.
Evan Rodriguez
...
Jose Wood
He's so adorable
John Evans
ALLAH mentioned
Luis Hall
Holy shit he just compared Karl Marx to Jesus.
Noah Clark
"Are you under the influence of Marx?"
Parker Thompson
Seems accurate.
Angel Stewart
Wolff going in hard af.
Aaron Gonzalez
Dude how many Marx's did you take??!!??
Luke Rogers
FUKUYAMA ON SUICIDE WATCH
Cameron Perez
...
Charles Green
...
Jordan Peterson
...
Wyatt Lee
fukuyama is a joke now
Henry Mitchell
Fuck it's on right now.
Bentley Lopez
fuck I can't believe I missed Fukuyama getting btfo will this recorded?
Christian Cruz
He didn't really specifically fuck up Fukuyama, he just said people who believe capitalism is the optimal society which could ever exist are retarded.
Wyatt Adams
wut did he say?
Jose Cruz
He did say "some people even title their books that" in reference to the end of history meme.
Brandon Martinez
i like his house
Jackson Richardson
...
Aaron Sullivan
HERE COMES CO-OPS
William Ward
...
Jacob Sanders
everything that comes out of this mans mouth makes so much fucking sense
John Walker
...
Benjamin Gray
...
Ryder Sanders
I wish that a famous Marxist in the media would for once actually defend the USSR instead of engaging into this "not real gommunism" defeatism.
But I understand it would take up too much time and lead away from the topic.
Logan Lee
...
Nolan Sanders
It's so fucking sensible and appealing to the natural human mind.
They're definitely gonna assassinate this guy.
Camden James
yeah it's boring and academic as fuck
Juan Parker
It might be the end if they crash this planet with no survivors.
Owen Reyes
Yeah, tankies definitely need to be executed
Hudson Wood
Although I have a lot of problems with the USSR, I feel compelled to defend it whenever it's brought up because its successes are so little discussed. The whole discussion surrounding the USSR is so dishonest. I think that's why most people avoid the discussion, even if they're well aware of its successes.
Ethan Young
Fucking smug cunt was probably right then fml
Lincoln Barnes
Exactly. You don't have to be a tankie to intellectually honest discuss the USSR to counter all this stupid shit that's flying arround.
James Hill
Why not just have elected directors who answer to and can be deposed by the other workers? Rotation seems silly when some people are substantially more skilled at a particular job than others.
Bentley Gutierrez
Goodbye Papa
Hunter Bell
Welp
Chase Hernandez
Cause you just please enough people to get you reelected. Or use propaganda.
You know… Like "democracy" works now.
Samuel Reed
Wolff has talked about the success of the USSR before when addressing that no other country has ever been able to match its astonishing speed of industrialization. Michael Parenti has done plenty of USSR apologism as well.
Leo Fisher
It's exhausting. Every conversation forces you to wade through decades of bias while genuflecting at all the right altars before you can even start discussing it in an honest way.
Thomas Barnes
Fug, I only came in at the end of Wolff's part. What did he talk about?
Ian Moore
Wolff even did some mild Stalin apologia in one of his lectures where he defended Stalin's decision to lie to the population by stating that the USSR had achieved true Socialism.
Luis Hill
Nothing new or particularly advanced. If you've watched a lot of his stuff you've heard it before.
Alexander Cruz
th-thanks
Brayden Collins
Wolff has made the term "state capitalism" popular even though it was originally coined by Lenin to describe the NEP. Plus it is simply incorrect, an authoritarian bureaucracy is not capitalism because you don't have a capitalist ruling class extracting the surplus value for themselves. Again, you don't have to be a ML to understand this.
That's why I always take him with a huge grain of salt.
Dominic Gutierrez
actually the only thing I wasn't on board with was the question about directors. While I agree with sortition and rotation. He failed to mention that the group democracy would never be a constant decision making process, but a constant organisation of the system for decision making.
Take the hospital example, almost everything in a hospital happens by procedure and protocol. There is no real reason why these protocols could not be brought about by a democratic process.
Although I can see where there could some instances of needing a split second decision, I don't honestly think they are all that often in a well managed hospital. They are after all buildings designed specifically to cater for as many of the common ailments as possible. Where there is an anomaly is an exception to the rule and, usually, as he says, these will not be emergency situations. Although in the true emergency I do recognise the need to devolve to an instant decision maker.
This is how decisions were often made on pirate ships according to David Graeber who was talking about someone elses work, so this is third hand information, but basically every decision on a pirate ship was taken by show of hands, they all voted in the sharing of loot and, critically, the captain only assumed full control in the event of a storm or a battle, his control was immediately terminated after this. Not uniform, but this was supposedly the most common way to organise a pirate ship. Basically most pirates were ex navy so they were all heavily opposed to military hierarchy
This is the book he references. Its in 'The Democracy Project'
Mason Reyes
Thanks
Hunter Baker
IT'S BACK
James Jackson
this guy…
Grayson Lee
Scahill is on.
Wyatt Lopez
Was the first half like this?
Samuel Barnes
and some of you doubted the validity of Debt: The First 5000 Years.
I fucking love this event
Brandon Sanchez
Great speakers, but so many damn technical issues
Luis Richardson
Yeh I hope Snowden is still alive
Liam Clark
...
Julian Sullivan
...
Samuel Gomez
What's the joke? Will seems like a pretty bourgie guy
Camden Wilson
...
Luis Scott
Scahill looks a lot like Sargon…
Evan Mitchell
ANTI-ESTABLISHMENT N T I - E S T A B L I S H M E N T
It always confuses me how Snowden and Assange are both lolberts but they mostly seem to associate with leftists.
Are they just Low Key left market anarchists pretending to be lolberts for upboats or something?
Jonathan Hughes
yeah, i always though the viking looking guy was furthest left
Levi Carter
I want to be a pirate too
Cameron Gonzalez
The 30 million propaganda has worked too well
Luis Bell
Is Wolff on?
Jordan Moore
agreed
Cameron Sanchez
Kek insert that screncap of the news headlines about Trump
Snowden is a lolbert…? Do you mean civil libertarian or economic libertarian?
Gavin Brooks
He already came on. Sorry. Pretty sure you can watch the whole thing after, though.
Dylan Davis
I could be just imagining it but I think he supported Ron Paul.
Assange has said 'in terms of markets I believe in free markets'. On Wikipedia it just says hes 'Libertarian', wikileaks states that it is to make capitalism ethical
The fact that he is so cryptic about it leads me to believe he believes some wild shit though and his work on networks and network theory is extremely ancom
Noah Price
Is Jeremy Scahill a closet anarchist?
Nathaniel Powell
I've always liked pirates, it's nice to see that they are ideologically symphatic as well
Samuel Foster
Hmm maybe. He's in the same circle as Greenwald, so I'm pretty sure he's either lefty or doesn't care about economics.
Christian Martin
then again Im not some millionaire paying for fucking extra podcasts so I might not know anything
Joshua Nelson
I'm confused. Does Michael Flynn love Russia or hate Russia?
Gabriel Stewart
I'm trying now but I can't find anything which is actually kind of weird.
Wiki says he voted third party in 08 and would be in support of universal basic income
Jack Ross
Pirates are cool Swords are cool. Hats an peglegs and parrots and ships and treasure is cool.
Pirates are cool, but they were really horrible rape killers just romanticised by lolliwood
Pirates are cool Direct Democracy is cool
Andrew Hall
Yeah, I expect that
Justin Carter
Space Pirate Socialism is the future
Eli Howard
FULLY AUTOMATED LUXURY PIRATE SHIP
Carson Nelson
So relatable
Ayden Reyes
lol me too, when I was like 9 Jack Sparrow was like the coolest shit there is
Eli Walker
yeah, iktf too DEUTSCH ÜBER ALLES! FRANÇAIS POUR TOUS!
Everything he said is sensible and fine. What do people have against him?
Brayden Sanders
SNOWDEN IS UP
Adam Morris
WE /SNOWDEN/ NOW
Aiden Hernandez
DO YOU FEEL CHILLY
CAUSE THE PLACE JUST GOT SNOWED-IN
Hudson Ross
any1 knows?
Liam Williams
I don't like how they keep pandering to the feminists in the audience. Why are they apologizing for not reading books by women and not having a women on the podium, gender has nothing to do with this.
Camden Diaz
Because it's [CURRENT YEAR].
Brayden Gutierrez
Yeh when Scahill said lets get a woman on the panel I was all, well okay, but who? Which woman has the socialist academic standing that D Wolf Does? Or has done the leaking the Snowden has?
Asher Wright
FULLY PRIMITIVE MANUAL CANOEISM
Robert Phillips
Wait I don't get it. Why did the FBI hate MLK's guts? Because anti-war or what?
Robert Bennett
It's just a damn nod to a group of people that comprises 50% of human beings that wasn't represented, don't be autistic man
Connor Gutierrez
Jodi Dean is the best current female advocate of socialism that I can think of off the top of my head.
He was against the Vietnam War, he was anti-capitalist, and the FBI thought he was a "troublemaker" who was a closet black nationalist (which isn't true).
Ethan Thomas
This It's not that deep. Stop sperging guys. Sound like alt-right losers right now.
Jaxson Morris
Once he started to talk about class.
Wyatt Nguyen
Actual quote from Hoover, director of the FBI, in 1963, after MLK's "I have a dream" speech:
Mason Wood
judith butler, naomi klein would be some popular choices
James Mitchell
Thanks
Gabriel James
So, women are a group, that needs to be represented.
And there I thought humans are not defined by gender and socioeconomic issues are not male or female..
Hmmm…
Kayden Gomez
...
Jack Barnes
Wtf
Andrew Williams
nice b8 m8
Xavier Anderson
No, seriously. What has sex, gender, race, ethnicity, to do with socioeconomics and capitalism? If it was about "the role of group X in society" sure! But what does it matter when the problem is universal?
Jackson Lewis
Shut up CIA, we know you don't us to listen Snowden.
Logan Cox
I really don't care enough to argue with you. As long as we are comrades united against capitalism and hierarchy I don't mind you
Camden Rivera
Ok ok. Lets listen about PRISM and you tell me later.
Nathan Bailey
Nothing and everything. Capitalism, being the base of society, touches everything else. Women being forced into the workplace (partly as a Trojan horse under the banner of "women's liberation") is explicitly wound up with capitalism, for example. And obviously, in the US, race had a lot to do with economics, since there was a system of slavery based on race, and its effects (along with capitalism's) are still a large contributor to black poverty. To be clear, I don't think the whole "diversity for diversity's sake" meme is worth anything, and I don't think having quotas based on sex, race, or anything else is a good idea. But it's all interconnected.
Jackson Hughes
This webcam shit is scary.
Adam Bell
I gotta drop skype and delete my windows and go gnu/linux
Matthew Smith
>>>Holla Forums I already have.
Grayson Powell
He is really quite competent at talking about how the "national security" state functions and deals with dissent. Citizens' Commission to Investigate the FBI is very interesting and I hadn't heard of it.
this pretty much, I don't mind female quotas on corporate boards tho
for myself I sorta think it's too late now :/
If all my stuff is stored then they already have enough to take me down and analyze me precisely, hell someone with my reddit password can already see into my soul
Jacob Ramirez
...
Nathaniel Hill
I'm thinking you could throw them off a bit if you'd change your legal name and use pseudonyms everywhere after dropping everything else, including the accounts you used, your computer, your IP address even…
Nolan Cook
...
Zachary Perry
That's like having an affirmative action program for slavemasters. "Ooh, my bourgeois overlords are so ~diverse~ and ~progressive~"
Pic related.
Jace Williams
Cause if you have women, trans, gay, blacks, native Americans, whatever, on corp boards, they'll suddenly stop exploiting or something.
It's all about Class. Not identity.
Jose Reyes
Agreed. But being in an exploited class has secondary effects based on your sex and race. That said, I think we should explicitly focus on class, since you can be the most special snowflake on Earth and still be bourgie scum.
Ethan Wilson
GNU, although more secure, has its own vulnerabilities. Unless you get something like Void, which is so minimal you have to complete the system, there is always a substantial risk up from the kernel level.
Get a new machine and new accounts. Unless you can physically move to a different country, these are your best options.
Don't be a prick.
Kevin Hughes
This
Kevin Lewis
void uses the same kernel as all the other linux distros…
only alternative would be going BSD. Was OpenBSD good?
Ian Long
If you're that paranoid, use OpenBSD or something.
Too late, ledditor.
Samuel Russell
Judith Butler specifically theorises about Gender. Its not really relevant to these discussions.
I thought about Naomi Klein but she actually sucks at public speaking.
Ayden Perry
GNU isn't absolutely secure by any means, but I do think it is reasonably secure. In comparison, Windows is a consumer rights nightmare.
Gavin Mitchell
I'm a hardliner here: if it's not 100% secure, it's not secure at all. Which is sadly what we'll have to live with for now.
Robert Jenkins
The jankee-doodles and home nation have my fingerprints. Other than that I guess it could work, however I like my name :/ and my reddit account
fucking sectarians
I didn't say that it would ever solve anything by itself. But the closed elitist circles getting invaded by 40% vaginas won't hurt. Mainly I'm thinking that the precedent of having legislation about the make up of corporate boards could inspire social democratic ideas of worker representation on boards. Therefore I'm for quotas here.
Liam Davis
Get a new reddit account then. Get a somewhat similar name then, or a name that sounds alike. Anything to throw them offtrail as far and wide as you can. Otherwise, they're just gonna release our browser histories the moment we'd try anything that seems somewhat threatening to them.
Samuel King
There is literally no such thing, it's mathematically impossible.
It won't help, either. Why do you care what color your bourgeois masters are, or what genitals they have?
Logan Moore
Risk can be assessed and controlled for. It is better to compromise for a decent improvement than to go "fuck it, use your botnets" if we can't have a perfect solution.
And really, no one wants to deal with OpenBSD on a modern work and entertainment machine, it's a neat project but hardly useful to anyone with even remotely normie needs. For Guhnoo/Linux, all you really need to do is avoid Ubuntu.
Justin Adams
I hope Mélenchon will win so Snowden-senpai will be able to be safe in France and baguettes with us 。( ♥︎‿♥︎)。
Parker Hall
MY GOTT! THE IDEOLOGY IS STRONG WITH THIS ONE! *snif*
FUKIN SOCDEMS, REEEEEEEE!
Justin Brown
It is upsetting, nonetheless, that our current systems are fundamentally insecure. But I concur: this is exactly why we should keep experimenting, developing and protesting.
Samuel Perry
Beyond being a hero, Snowden is such a great guy.
Jacob Campbell
I should do something yes, however I'm lazy and doubt I'll ever be a public figure. Also I have nothing that is more than mildly incriminating. The bad stuff is like my personal feeling stuff.
Read the next fucking sentence
the social democrat reform ideas of today is the anarcho-communism of tomorrow
tbh he almost makes me want to be a liberal
Josiah Long
Lol he's not liberal. You can't be liberal and criticize King Obama
Charles Adams
I did, fam. So are you a socdem or just naive?
Ryder Martin
Well, it's been good guys.
Nolan Gomez
I don't think Snowden is a liberal, he is more of a guy who is really concerned by just one idea, liberty. I'm pretty sure he is more left-leaning now, but if he would see your political compass, he would certainly cares way more about your position on the authoritarian/libertarian axis than the right/left axis.
Eli Parker
Libertarian / anarcho-communist, depending on how susceptible the person I'm talking to is to radical thought.
I'm not a social democrat, but I don't hate them. I think it's good to see reform that makes radical ideas seem more attainable. Surely you agree that the idea of workers having 50% of the boards as in Germany is better than 0%
Nathan Richardson
And having more women CEOs does?
Is that why VW fucked up with their emissions and so on?
Joshua Watson
liberal is a really weird word, isn't it :D
anyway I don't think it's relevant trying to place him on some compass as long as he keeps saying smart things
I hate capitalism, women CEOs wont change anything, does this mean that no reform is good? Jesus I said I didn't have the energy for this
Gavin White
YES
Adam Garcia
Ehh, I disagree
Michael Johnson
It's ok. You'll grow up and be a cynical bastard like the rest of us.
Owen Jenkins
It's actually 50% -1. Can't let the filthy proles have too much faux power. :^) But yes, it's better than 0%. However, that was a concession to Die Linke, not part of a diversity-fest. Deliberately or not, diversity quotas are frequently used to make institutions appear more egalitarian than they really are.
Chase Morales
Use Qubes OS and virtualize everything then. Isolation is the most important modern security paradigm.
Noah Butler
Did they ever upload the full video anywhere? I wanted to watch this.
Brody Gray
seconding
Levi Brown
bumping for video
Chase Perez
he might get banned from his party for this.
Kevin Edwards
A-anyone?
Landon Wood
Just go to the link in the OP. It's all there now.