Rule of Rose

I feel like this game has no clear target audience.

The best way i can describe it, is that it's a survival horror game made for women (women that can actually play video games).
It deals with a multitude of woman oriented subjects, and specifically with the complex hierarchy of girls social circles while they're still young/in school, and the bullying and drama associated with it.
But, most women haven't played this game, assuming they even give it a try most are going to react like "why isn't this grown ass woman slapping these little shits around?" because they'll never get far enough in the game to realize that the protagonist is reminiscing in a fantasy, twisted version of real events that happened to her in her youth and inside this story she has reverted back to being a little girl.
Most men playing this game will either be unable to relate to it's themes, or unable to even finish it because the gameplay is, quite frankly, atrocious.

It's a horror game with women as it's target audience that will never play it, and men as it's secondary possible audience that will give up on it because it plays like shit and it's 99% atmosphere/character focused.
So who's left?
Basically nobody, just weirdos like me that have an interest in old, niche survival horror games.

This game was made by Punchline.
The only other game they've ever made was Chulip.
Chulip was another game with a similiar problem: it had no main audience.
These days people play Chulip with the only intention of playing some quirky obscure "lol so whacky" japanese comedy game, and don't really sit down and try to take in it's strance and melancholic atmosphere.
Most will never even reach the part of the game where you have tea with a deceased girl and slowly unravel her tragic story that is actually pretty genuinely sad.

What was up with Punchline?
Why did they make such weird and specific games that most people couldn't possibly get into?
What was the point?

You say this like people can't sympathise with the opposite gender.

Maybe the devs are the audience.

I should really get to playing it I've got it on emulator working.

Wish this game was an xbox title as well.

Everybody in Rule of Rose is a horrible person.
Everybody.
The gameplay is also garbage like you said, so that didn't help.

Literally Gone Home: non SJW pozzed version

Great game

it also became rare and expensive.

sometimes prolaspsed bootybutts are also called roses. i find the best way to fix them is to simply wait for them to crawl back up inside of me

It has the same problem as Haunting Ground. I don't want an AI companion as a game mechanic.

Haunting Ground was way better in terms of gameplay, as far as I can understand RoR got the same problem as Deadly Premonition, the "combat" was added as an afterthought because the higher ups didn't believe a game about solving mysteries alone would sell.