What if superman was a bad guy?

Dropped

But he is.

Wasn't pandering the reason DD:I tanked?

...

...

Nigga I aint gay but superman is fucking average looking. Fuck, all of them, men and woman, are average or straight up ugly in this game what the fuck gives? Are sjw's just averse to the idea of universal laws of human attraction?

Yes

They know that was just George Costanza, right?

Superman was originally created by commie Jews (literally) but DC said fuck that and turned him into their own thing. Superman was an anti commie simple for 40 years.

Asking hypothetical questions within the context of comics is somewhat pointless since that's pretty much how creators come up with new stories in the first place.