It's from Bleeding Cool so take it with a grain of salt but with all the hints that Bendis has been dropping, I wouldn't put it past DC. On one hand, I'd be glad to finally get Tomasi off the damn book (Jesus, when fucking JURGENS writes better shit than you in Action Comics, you know you fucked up) but on the other, Bendis is just jumping out of boiling water and into an acid tank.
I guess this is the part where Rebirth starts failing hard. Didn't even last 2 years…
Michael Nelson
Oh come on, Tomasi and Jurgens aren't that bad.
Colton Ward
I actually managed to like some of Jurgens' stuff if only because he seems to be the only writer who tried to give Jon Kent some kind of proper character instead of writing him as an even whinier Superman Jr. while aping the Batman/Superman dynamic almost verbatim for Damian and Jon rather than trying something new.
Tomasi, despite tossing out all these high-caliber ideas that SHOULD be good, manages to make it all into an utter bore.
Cameron Morales
Of course, me liking Jurgens is a bit of a bias seeing how I really liked both of his Booster Gold runs. Tomasi does have some fun stories (Super-Pets from the Super-Sons annual comes to mind) but hey I really do like he made Damian less annoying (like his "I'm better than Batman" shit now gets smacked down by Jon rolling his eyes. It's nice to have someone other than Dick for Damian to play off on.)
Luis Smith
Eh, Damian mellowed out years ago and gets called out way more often. That's not really on Tomasi.
Isaac Adams
...
Aaron Nelson
The problem with Tomasi's run is that he's putting WAAAY too much focus on Jon, with Superman and Lois coming off as wooden parent figures. It's becoming more and more obvious that what Tomasi really wants to do is write Jon and he couldn't give a flying fuck about writing Superman, which is why DC needs to kick him off Superman and let him just write Super Sons, which is where his writing shines best. Jurgens is pretty OK but nothing exceptional.
Lucas Phillips
Anybody but Bendis..fuck, who's going to bet that Bendis is going to cuck Superman with a Tyrone first chance he gets?
Xavier Hernandez
I'm betting on President Obamaman coming in to kick the asses of General Zod, Mongul, Brainiac, Metallo and Parasite simultaneously and then knocking up Lois Lane with one last night of passion before heading back to his own universe. Fast-forward nine months, Lois gives birth to Jamal Kent, who is bigger, stronger, faster and smarter than Jon in every way.