Member when It's Always Sunny was Funny Before Mac Pozzed It's Neghole with Female & Nigger Writers

Well yeah, he basically got only "I am a faggot, lol" instead of development and he was a weak character to begin with. Even minor characters got it much better.

Mac was never gay, he was just obsessed with what he perceived at manliness. He loved his dad and tried to emulate him. He was "raised" by his mother while his dad was in prison. Mac picked up his dad's weird and gay prison habits because he tried to emulate his dad who he loved. He did bang the tranny, which is the only hole in my theory.

uh, he got pounded in the ass on the boat trip

Honestly they should have replaced Mac with Cricket.

Yeah, but he is useful idiot for some plot points and its easier to write. Compare difficulty of D.E.N.N.I.S. system to "I am fag, lol".

Everyone else has something that gives them depth, Dee and Dennis have their family situation, Charlie has his brain issues and obsession with the waitress, and even Frank has his underworld esque past, Mac has "my dad was in jail and I swear I'm not gay" which is just so weak compared to the others. The most interesting thing Mac did was get fat.

It's called building mass you skinny twink

What good is it to bulk when you're just going to replace your body with an avatar anyways?

This. The early series surrounded how much Mac loved to fuck the gals, which was the cornerstone of his friendship with Dennis, and had a thing for older women. In the earlier seasons, Mac was not the retarded faggot the show turned him into. I wish they would've kept Dee as the hypocritical snarky do-gooder instead of the obvious psychopath. I wish this show wouldn't have felt the need to constantly ramp things up for le enevelope pushing while putting in less and less work. The last few seasons alone have only been ten episodes each, with barely half of them the same quality. They should've ended the series with the gang either dying on that cruiser. Or maybe, if they were desperate for material, have them go Gilligan's Island for an episode or two or three.

It was never funny.