I'll try not to make this a blogpost but the temptation to literally make a blog about this ala DeadHomerSociety was high, season by season and everything. Over the past month I accidentally began to marathon the entire series. It was a lot of fun going back to the early seasons I hadn't watched since SPstudios began streaming from their own servers. It was a lot of fun remembering the time when South Park had the feel of a webshow that was somehow on TV. As I got closer to the recent seasons I had a lot of hesitation. I had stopped watching the show before and by Season 16, because I had enough of how bad it had gotten. The show was clearly going downhill before then and it had gone so far down by S16 that I couldn't bother beyond that. But as I got closer to S16 on this extemporaneous marathon, I found myself enjoying some episodes and overall some seasons better than I expected, so I was encouraged to continue. This is a rough outline of my experience.
Simple and honest fun. Occasionally rare, gay, and retarded episode like Jakovasaurs. The "webshow" feel is obviously at its highest in Season 1 but that vibe continues on all the way till at latest Season 3. The movie still holds up.
Probably the peak of the show. As with The Simpsons, the label of immaculate peak quality ends with Season 6. Almost every episode in these seasons still gets rerun constantly on CC to this day. The style of direction from Season 4 and onwards shapes the show for the next several seasons.
Season 7 is very strong as is 8. When we get to Season 9, that's where everything seems to change. The season itself has a lot of good episodes but overall feels tired out. Even by the time it gets to the scientology episode, the problems are already noticeable.
10 and 11 are interesting because this is the last time Matt and Trey overtly try to make fun of their critics in episodes. 10 is very topical, which is all too common in the show now. That's not to say that South Park ever wasn't, but the way it presents the topic and covers a current event has changed and is less about small town problems in an absurd fashion and more about small town characters somehow being directly involved in every nationwide issue and traveling great distances all the time.
1/2