Ok so we are about half way through DC Rebirth, now overall the quality has been pretty mixed to be honest ranging from Superman to Harley Quinn, I don't know if this has something to do with my tistic nature but I feel we should rank them for people who have not read them any rebirth yet or want to read more of it but don't know what to read, what are some of the biggest success and flops? Also will begin posting in about 45 minutes or so.
Also I did not get a chance to post this so here is your daily amount of salt for today :)
Jace Perez
When the smug meets the edge
Joseph Cook
From best to worst of the ones I've read:
Best
Ok
Shit
Chase Long
Superman #12
Blake Phillips
...
Kevin Jenkins
...
Charles Morris
...
Ryan Wilson
...
Jason Powell
...
Ethan Nguyen
...
Justin Morales
Batman #12
Landon Hall
...
Joshua Morris
I hope Spencer and the other cucks in the industry hang themselves soon.
Jason Powell
...
Liam Diaz
...
Oliver Williams
...
Austin Allen
...
Josiah Gomez
Comic day of the rope when?
Ryder Gutierrez
Aquaman #12
Nicholas Jackson
...
Daniel Hill
...
Gabriel Gonzalez
...
Luke Hernandez
...
Nolan Roberts
...
Easton Lewis
...
James Ortiz
Green Arrow #12
Caleb Parker
...
Kayden Morales
...
Jeremiah Nguyen
...
Ayden Martinez
...
Luke Kelly
...
Adam Ross
Soon.
Eli Campbell
Green Lanterns #12
Charles Perry
...
Aiden Rivera
...
Jose King
...
Nicholas Williams
Looking into it a little, DC apparently groups their different titles into four different 'families' internally, based on which types of heroes they're centered around. These four families, with each title listed in order of publication, are:
Batman Family
Superman/Wonder Woman Family
Justice League
Miscellaneous
For me, the best Batman Family title out at the moment would probably have to be either Detective Comics or Nightwing, while Batgirl is definitely the worst.
Superman is the best Superman/Wonder Woman title, while Superwoman is the worst (though still better than Batgirl).
Aquaman, Hal Jordan and Titans are tied for best for me in the Justice League family of titles, while the actual Justice League book and Cyborg tied for worst, JL for the author's inability to do proper pacing and Cyborg for the stilted and unnatural dialogue.
Finally, Red Hood and the Outlaws is hands-down the best Miscellaneous title out at the moment, while Harley Quinn is pure cancer (and yet still somehow more entertaining than Batgirl, in my opinion).
Xavier Evans
Actually, on second thought, RHatO is tied with Deathstroke for best Miscellaneous title for me. Both titles are some of the better Rebirth books out at the moment, though.
Robert Ward
...
Oliver Butler
...
Jayden Peterson
...
Ayden Hughes
Nightwing #10
Levi Wood
...
Carter Bell
...
Asher Sullivan
...
Aiden Kelly
...
Connor Davis
...
Ayden King
...
Angel Thomas
that last panel on the last page
Noah Diaz
Harley Quinn #9
Justin Ortiz
...
Ethan Sanchez
So why didn't superman use his x-ray vision to see if Frankenstein was telling the truth?
Josiah Green
...
Ayden Reed
Obama declaring war on anything? Why do comics have to be so unrealistic? A story has to make sense, or the whole thing comes across as nonsensical.
Ryder Walker
...
Ryan King
...
Adrian Collins
...
Asher Johnson
...
Andrew Cooper
Justice League #10
Oliver Gray
...
Lincoln Price
...
Joshua Mitchell
...
Carson Baker
...
Parker Martin
...
Alexander Taylor
Cyborg #6
Andrew Harris
...
Nicholas Bell
...
Charles Cruz
...
Ayden Ward
...
Tyler Reed
...
Jonathan Lopez
...
Jordan Parker
Death Of Hawkman #3
Jaxson Ross
...
Mason Ross
...
Josiah Lee
...
Nathan Diaz
...
Mason Stewart
...
Colton Allen
...
Elijah Lopez
...
Sebastian Bell
Midnighter And Apollo #3
Jace James
...
Luis Jones
...
Blake Evans
...
Gavin Hughes
...
Jayden Hernandez
...
Jason Martin
...
William Jenkins
Deadman Dark Mansion Of Forbidden Love #2
Ayden Thomas
...
Jeremiah Baker
...
Lincoln Adams
...
Caleb Jones
...
Henry Ramirez
...
Owen Murphy
...
David Kelly
...
Zachary Scott
...
Parker Miller
...
Ryder Garcia
...
Charles Moore
...
Parker Kelly
...
Henry Lee
...
Josiah Young
Shade The Changing Girl #3
Kevin White
...
Luke Russell
...
David Harris
...
Mason Flores
...
Austin Jenkins
...
Jonathan Peterson
...
Sebastian Butler
...
Carter Perez
Okay so that's everything this week and I challenge you mouth breathers to even try to improve my list, pro tip you can't
Superman
Trinity Titans Teen Titans Deathstroke
Hal Jordan & the Green Lantern Corps Blue Beetle Batman Beyond Red Hood and the Outlaws
Action Comics All-Star Batman Wonder Woman The Flash Green Arrow Suicide Sqaud Aquaman New Super-man Green Lanterns
Batman Batgirl Batgirl and the Birds Prey Detective Comics Nightwing Justice League
Harley Quinn HellBlazer
Superwoman Supergirl Cyborg
Doom Patrol
Xavier Johnson
This comic sure is not "on fleek"
William Evans
Holy shit, Cobb's a fucking badass.
I laughed.
I assumed he overlook it because Lois was in danger.
Owen Taylor
Doom Patrol Everything else
Kayden Hernandez
bretty good
Oliver Campbell
For some reason, Superman tapping someone's shoulder before decking them always gets a chuckle out of me.
Brandon Sullivan
Wrong comic, Damien.
John Kelly
Huh…so Skartaris is just a world in TV, huh?
Juan Campbell
Frank's face in the last image's last panel seems like it would make for a good reaction image. All someone would need to do is remove the speech bubbles and maybe crop out the hand with the remote.
I know Ollie's been a liberal since he went on that road trip with Hal, but somebody needs to tell Benjamin Percy that readers can only take so much cancer before they lose interest and move on to check out other titles.
Here's hoping this is a sign of character development to come in the actual Teen Titans series.
Nathan Phillips
...
Luis Collins
I hope so too, Teen Titans is looking like it can be one of my favourites of rebirth.
nice
Brody Brown
Damn that was actually a fucking good comic.
Nathaniel Hall
I liked this weeks Batman, and Nightwing could have potential.
Luke Johnson
This week, on DC Rebirth:
Landon Lopez
Saved
Evan Price
Remove the Nightwing word and it will become another Harambe meme
William Sanders
Or… y'know… the average nigger.
Luke Gray
oh you're so clever
Benjamin Lewis
Better than a fucking forced meme like Harambe.
Zachary Williams
Now, while the user is not wrong that it's a shitty forced meme, and that it's Facebook-tier, even lower than Reddit, I still took 3 minutes out of my life to fix it for you. Obligatory:
Isaac Johnson
Sorry for the delay will star posting soon
Blake Gray
This is great.
Joseph Parker
DC Rebirth Holiday Special #1
Chase Turner
...
Connor Morgan
...
Evan Robinson
...
Mason Brown
...
Brayden Mitchell
...
Carter Myers
...
Colton James
...
Luis Jackson
...
Isaiah Bailey
...
Jace Anderson
...
William Ramirez
...
Caleb Moore
...
Nathan Gray
...
Jace Ward
...
Christian Hernandez
...
Isaiah Peterson
...
Henry Stewart
...
Logan James
...
Jace Cook
...
Thomas Hall
...
Landon White
...
Nathaniel Gray
...
Xavier Scott
Action Comics #969
Jeremiah Bell
...
Michael Hughes
...
Anthony Richardson
...
Oliver Turner
...
Jeremiah Cox
...
Nolan Smith
...
Robert Hill
Detective Comics #946
Juan Evans
...
Gavin Reed
...
Ryan Jackson
...
Angel Rodriguez
...
Isaiah Barnes
The Flash #12
Christian Ward
...
Connor Ward
...
David Garcia
...
Dylan Green
...
Wyatt Long
...
Brayden Long
...
Benjamin Walker
...
Kayden Carter
...
Joseph Bell
...
Levi Walker
...
Josiah Butler
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #10
Nicholas Adams
...
Julian Rivera
...
Dominic Foster
...
Adrian Smith
...
Aiden Anderson
...
Justin Brooks
Deathstroke #8
Andrew Russell
...
Josiah Howard
...
Carter Young
...
William Martin
...
Henry Kelly
...
Elijah Morris
...
Kayden Sanchez
New Super-Man #6
Joseph Rogers
...
Nolan Richardson
...
Jaxon Carter
...
Jonathan Price
...
Kayden Howard
...
Jace Gonzalez
...
Wyatt Moore
Red Hood and the Outlaws #5
Dominic Myers
...
Cameron Richardson
...
Benjamin Perry
...
Sebastian Harris
...
Oliver Wood
...
Nathan Garcia
...
Nolan Perez
Superwoman #5
Easton Lee
...
Tyler Sanders
...
Chase Wood
...
Connor Gutierrez
...
Liam Foster
...
Michael Torres
...
Joshua Morgan
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey #5
Luis Miller
...
Anthony Nelson
...
Brayden Lee
...
Blake Stewart
...
Wyatt White
...
Dominic Cruz
...
Brandon Hernandez
Supergirl #4
Hunter Morales
...
Kayden Campbell
...
Gavin White
...
Landon Sullivan
I really liked Bedlam too
Henry Rogers
...
Sebastian Carter
...
Alexander Gomez
Ok so that's everything for this week
Jaxson Taylor
Can't wait for the next time
Hunter White
eyy glad someone enjoyed it
Owen Reyes
That was a nice little story and series of stories. Glad to see DC doing stuff like this again.
Cooper Reed
Oh, I get it. Damian only gave Jon that Christmas present because he has almost nobody else to play with.
That panel feels like it has reaction image potential.
Shame about most of the rest of the issue.
…Damn, New Super-Man is really getting good.
I stand by my earlier assertion from when we were talking about rankings. Both Batgirl books are worse than the Harley Quinn title out right now. And Harley Quinn is fucking cancer, so that's really saying something.
Anybody else think that the story on Supergirl really picked up when Kara got out into space and away from her immediate supporting cast? The DEO and the Danvers aren't bad, but Cat Grant and Black Kid McSmartypants drag the story down every time it focuses on them.
Jace Sullivan
Why do I get the feeling this comic is a better origin story for Wonder Woman than the movie will be?
Owen Murphy
Glad to see the black mask got his old face back.
Hudson Watson
So, looks like DC leaked some fun-looking cover art for March for fans of the Super-Sons.
John King
cape comics haven't looked awesome for a while… DC seems to be changing that.
Daniel Howard
Still good pic though. Reminds me of Buzz and Woody for some reason.
Bentley White
I just hope DC keeps in mind why they are doing so well now. They said they were going to be more conservative and suddenly their numbers are up.
Really I just hope they don't pull a Korra with these two . It sucks how characters just can't be best friends now without everyone wanting them to fuck.
Jace Walker
The "Korra" ing thing still bother me to this day. It's like this weird urge for writers to enforce some characters to be suddenly gay even when they clearly straight from the beginning.The worst was Dave Willis and one of his character in his webcomic Shortpacked. He even acknowledged that the character never have a thing for the same sex but because the other girl is so in love with her she finally gave up rejecting her and decided to to "try" to be lesbian. Now imagine if a writer did that with a gay character but forced to be straight because the other girl/guy is in love with him/her so much. I bet LGBTQ community gonna cry blood and accuse the writer of being homophobic.
That's why I quit Shortpacked. I saw how his work turn into complete bullshit. I miss the It's Walky era when it's all just about fighting alien threat and not SJW mouthpiece.
Landon Howard
I think the worst thing is how it has really ruined the concept of friendship in all forms of media. You can't have two characters genuinely care about each other without people instantly wanting them to fuck, and now the people producing this shit are actually humoring these disgusting people. Korra definitely started the worst trends in creative mediums.
Connor Nguyen
Humoring? Heh, call me paranoid, but sometimes I wonder if there's a hardline gay activist group who wants to normalize this shit. Since their "mating pool" is pretty small they want to enforce the idea that all people are gay inside.
Andrew Rodriguez
nah, sounds pretty realistic now of days.
Zachary Rivera
Yeah, I take back what I said about it. They've been putting out some good quality stuff with him.
I know it sounds like I'm parroting but… Yeah, Cat Grant and the other kid are definitely the weakest link.
Cooper Reyes
The Batgirl comic should be absorbed into Nightwing. Her book is just terrible, but she makes a better companion than individual.
This story arc of B&BP seems to be mocking the fans of previous non-Feminist Batgirl than anything else.
Jack Lee
My hype for this series is growing exponential at this point
Christian Gutierrez
What with DC and Batgirl anyway? It's like the series is cursed or something. How many Batgirls they already churned out?
Joshua Edwards
Its not cursed they are just retarded with it. It seems that they put the worse people they can on batgirl so they get fucking awful art and dialogue. Batgirl can be good, they just wont let it
John Cruz
Hey, hang on a minute! Rebirth-user, you forgot one!
Suicide Squad #8
Connor Torres
...
Elijah King
...
Anthony Clark
...
Carter Morales
...
Bentley Sanchez
And that's that.
Anybody looking forward to JLvSS? It's by the guy who's writing The Flash, so I don't have high hopes for it but also don't think it will be actively terrible.
Also, with the lower price tag, hopefully it will utterly kill Marvel's IvX event in sales.
Gavin Gutierrez
Fuck this gay earth.
Ryder Phillips
What a time to be alive.
Ryder Young
Damn I was so proud that up until this point I did not even mess up one page but now I miss an entire issue, sad!
I am curious about this series obviously it's only coming bout because the new once is but it is not using the EDGY tm designs which is nice.
Caleb Hernandez
But Flash and Tommy aren't very symmetrical at all :^)
Nolan Fisher
It's to drum up sales of Booms own PR comics, not so much the film.
At least you didn't get the characters wrong :^)
Matthew Baker
Wait…the one with the Emerald Eye, isn't she from the future? How the hell they got her? And the classic Main Man is back and the guy on the middle. I can't tell if he's Max Lord or Rick Flagg Jr.
Nathaniel Torres
According to the trade magazine DC put out last month, Emerald Empress traveled back in time from the future in search of someone or something from her native timeline. Most likely Saturn Girl, who is currently sitting in Arkham Asylum waiting for Superman.
Ayden Martinez
OK, currently reading the Holiday Special. One, they have the Rainbow Monster and two..well, can't spoil that one.
Michael Butler
Also..Ding Dong Daddy.
Logan Scott
That particular take on the character first showed up in Titans Hunt. It was a pretty entertaining New 52 miniseries that was published shortly before Rebirth.
Colton Thomas
This week, on DC Rebirth:
And other titles that may be worth looking into:
Isaiah Hill
==Ok guys I gotta level with you, I might not be able to post for the next weeks after this Wednesday (if that) because of holiday plans so so one of you neets is going to have to take over until I get back, so let me make this really simple so anyone can do it, first I assume you have utorrent or something similar then you go to worldwidetorrents.eu/torrents.php?c50=1 because thats where nem moved too after kat got shoah'd, then you download the comics and in your cbr reader then you just ctrl + s then you save it where ever, I use different folders for each issue, then post its really!== even you can do it =^)
Nathaniel Flores
Wait..All Star Batman? Wasn't that an already running book?
Easton Peterson
March solicits are out, for people who are interested in reading that sort of thing. I kinda like the cover gimmick DC is going for with the Superman Reborn covers. Expand all four images at once to see the effect for yourself.
Apparently, yes, though given the Superman Red/Superman Blue thing going on in that final cover, I suspect he's not going to be back permanently. Also, cover #2 is making me wonder if Superboy Prime is coming back.
It's a crossover event for the month of March, spanning all four issues of Superman and Action Comics coming out that month. And part of the aftermath is going to be played out in Superwoman, as well.
Isaiah Gomez
Anything is better than nothing, thanks man
Cooper Price
Seems interesting.
I wanna see Superdad teach Nu-52 Superman how to beat the shit out of guys. That way Superson will always know that Superdad don't fuck around.
Levi Young
Man, that Christmas special was holy jolly as fuck.
Brandon Hill
Wow that bit with the covers was clever.
Angel Martinez
Oh shit, New 52 Supes returning?
I wonder where they're going with this… A merge?
At the very least if they end up picking one or the other, I hope Superdad stays as the main Superman. I don't mind New 52 Supes as a derivative. He can be A Superman. Just not THE Superman.
Logan Sanchez
Actually, another comment. You mentioned how the covers all link up.
I wonder if that goes for the characters in it. Seems almost sequential in some weird way.
Mason Roberts
Ok anons I think I can post all of this weeks comics but after this I wont be able to for a few weeks =(
Aiden Mitchell
Don't forget to start a new thread, since this one's close to the bump limit.
