How do you respond to this? To me it it's like lambasting an abolitionist for wearing cotton.
Critique capitalism
Other urls found in this thread:
google.com
twitter.com
You laugh at them.
Say that then. Equate it to lambasting an abolitionist for wearing cotton. The classic rebuttle (well, mockery) of this problem is the feudal serfs overthrowing their lords with pitchforks their lords provided for them, pitchforks created under feudalism. But this example works just as well.
Being against capitalism doesn't mean being against smartphones. It just means you believe that workers should have equal and democratic control over the resources used to produce smartphones.
...
do you know how many smartphone brands are there in the market? it's nowhere near as essential as cotton, and iphones basically don't exist outside the u.s.
they apply the argument to everything anyway though
and besides, socialists might be less susceptible to consumerist messages but we're not immune.
Okay….
Capitalism didn't invent iphones. It only Commercialised them and made them available to consumers.
It can apply to any smartphone or product really.
kek iphones exist everywhere, even third world countries
as in, they aren't common.
they are. I live in the third world and very few people don't have an iphone or samsung
congrats, you butchered the english language
It's not even true anyway, west europe has as many and south korea probably has more per person
yup, even the middle east has just as many
What does it matter if its and iphone or an android or any other smart phone. They thing we are talking about is assholes who use the argument that you can't oppose capitalism with a phone that capitalism "produced"
...
Did you know that most abolitionists wanted to ship blacks back to Africa? Because nobody likes niggers. It was pretty well accepted by all non-slaveowners that around blacks, expect attacks.
Well Karl Marx owned a pen so I guess we should just pack it up fellas.
By telling them that real commies use free software, not something as tightly locked down as Apple.
Take your idpol back to Holla Forums, fascist
Einstein was a socialist, necessity is the mother of invention, not profit. Do you pay royalties to the guy who invented the wheel? Was there no such thing as innovation before capitalism? You realise most major military inventions came from facist or communist governments? Even the us ones of today are mostly nazi ideas.
Take your pick comrade
Careful with this, I've heard ancaps claim capitalism always existed before.
For realz?
smartphones are so ubiquitous in the world that only the most backwards regions of the worst countries don't have them.
Well, as long as humans. But I wouldn't be surprised if one of them came up with the idea that the universe is fundamentally capitalist.
Please tell me you have a link to some stupid AnCap saying this
Just talk to one m8
Uhh I'm an uncultured fuck, but porky's arguments often imply that capitalism is some sort of
ultimate evolution that comes from perfecting previous systems.
They like to make analogies that (like marx wrote in capital) characterize other modes of production as proto-capitalist.
Even today these implications seem to lurk under many arguments.
...
Ancaps try to reduce capitalism to trade or "voluntary exchange".
iphones, not smartphones. everyone has an android phone. apple isn't popular everywhere.
lol no
But all smartphone producing companies are capitalist anyway. The point isn't about iPhones in particular, but that we engage in capitalist production and exchange despite claiming to want to fight against it. Apple isn't some huge super-evil greater than any other capitalist enterprise. Don't fetishise certain brands for your hate; there is no ethical consumption under capitalism. Of course the answer is that if we want any form of quality of life at all, we are forced under capitalist to capitulate and engage as a consumer. It is very difficult and not hugely production to just refuse to engage in capitalism. Those people are called hermits and they haven't been known to instigate revolutionary activity in others.
kill yourself
Where isn't it popular?
[citation needed]
You don't because it's not a serious argument. Treat it like someone countering your points by calling you a cuck or Jew or whatever other as hominem they pull out their ass.
It is.
...
fuggin sabed.
I simply don't even.
...
...
nice
Classical fuckery from idiots. Do these people who say, "Capitalism invented iphones" ever take a few steps back and realize the amount of human labor that could get to the point to make the Iphone? I guess Capitalism is responsible for Boolean logic, Turning Machines, Mathematics, Science, and engineering. It's as if people magically started to do mathematics when the world adopted Capitalism, what horse shit.
they would say that, yes, capitalism is responsible because free trade made all those things possible
...
Don't use an iPhone then.
He has a point you know.
Iphone… I .. has become the symbol of a corporate cult.
A post-modern capitalist relegion.
There is realy no reason to have an Iphone. It's like being against the king, while writting poemns in his favor.
Write poems against him. Or for another king. Since you are free to write anything you like, why write for the king everyone else writes for?
...
Seems to me capitalists were stupid to give us the weapons needed to fight them with.
Not saying it will change the world. But, if .. say … Cola X tastes better than Cola Y, and you keep getting Cola Y because everyone else does… you have fallen victim to the consumerist cult of neoliberal religion..
What makes you think people who use iPhones dislike them? By the point you have enough money to buy such shit phones, you could very well save half and buy an Android phone if you prefer.
I kind of agree with what you're saying, but I think the main point you're making is that iPhones are objectively inferior to many Android phones, and are a symbol of the contradictions inherent in capitalism.
So yeah, if you use an iPhone, you're just in general a faggot. You can't even ACCESS THE FUCKING FILESTRUCTURE on iOS for fuck's sake.
...
I always assumed "iphones" was a hyperbolic example about buying stuff, but if it's actually literal, then you should know I'm fairly certain most people here don't use iphones or other apple products and if they do, they're probably second-hand or stolen.
I suppose if computers and iPhones are the products of capitalism, then nukes and zyklon-b must be too :^)
noice.
Yah fam, the atomic bomb was totally a "necessity".
Einstein figured out Relativity in his free time while still working his day time job like a good prole, his wife hated him for it.
Curiosity is the mother of invention.
THANX CAPITALISM!
.. seriously, comrade? You wanna go there?
So, if you "resist Gapitalism" on an iPhone, you are just a bourgie hipster, anarkid at most, that "rebels" but doesn't want any real change.
And gets it.
Is this anarchist stereotype even true? I'm poor as hell and I can only use the computers that were given to me. Why use some fancy device when a regular smartphone could do. I have a flip phone.
it depends on who's definition of Capitalism, if capitalism means centralization of the fruits of distributed labor, where the labor class gains very little of their work while supporting an elite class that manages their lives and they have little choice in that arrangement, then yes, capitalism has existed for tens of thousands of years.
I don't think posting hashtags on twitter is productive, most probably people do it to believe "I'm doing something to change society".
iPhones are faggotry. +1.
Most people want to "fix" the system. That doesn't mean we should "dismiss" the tool of social media, (like KKE does, in Greece).
You deserve it for being retarded
Ad Hominem Tu Quoque.
Explain that Iphone was invented by the government and most of Iphones and pretty much everything is being made in officially communist China which industrialised only thanks to planned economy
upboated m'fam :^)
am i a better person for using a samsung?
it's all the same shit produced by chinese slaves, every form of work under capitalism is based on exploitation due to the extraction of the surplus value
You can be Nathan too, my Nathan.
Be Nathan today and join the great Nathan army!
Stop.
ok
Labor made your iPhone. Capitalism just determined who got paid.
If they talk about convenience and "innovation" just remind them that it took years for the free market to slap together already existing technology and it still was shitty and overpriced.
the production of the bomb was certainly perceived to be a necessity. Scientists knew, in theory, how an atomic bomb may work, so the US rushed to develop it before the Nazis could.
Your playing a game, you gotta play by the rules or lose out.
Is this hypothetical person seriously suggesting that by not having an iPhone the structural and economic problems with capitalism magically disappear?
...
Nigga what
TOP KEK, you say fascist as an insult to a nazi.