So, I have what I have to admit is a a very selfish, first-world problem, and I realize you guys are unlikely to be experts in this so I'm just going to ask your advice and tell you what my current plan is, and you can tell me what I can change that might make it actually work.
I keep meeting very attractive younger girls, generally online because of the fetish discussed here (they want to be kidnapped, kept as pets, etc.) I'm blessed with a nice voice so I'm able to seduce them essentially, but then I kind of become what Patrice would call "a time hoe" in that these girls want every moment of my time, essentially I think to make sure I'm not screwing around with other girls… which of course I am.
I want to take these girls two or three at a time, but there's little information out there on how women are convinced to take part in polygamy.
I figured I'd just keep them in a cage in complete sensory deprivation for two days to break their old identity, and refer back to putting them into this situation again should they break the rules. Then I'd gradually induce stockholm syndrome by rewarding their good behavior and keeping them isolated. Then as part of their training they would be made to watch video after video on declining birth rates, why men are better suited for polygamy, and forcing them to marathon the entire Big Love series, as well as some videos about what skeevy whores girls tend to be. I'll try to convince them to think of the other girls as their sisterwives, and able to fill in the gaps around the house, give them someone to talk to when I'm not there and take turns dealing with me.
See the thing is, while the girls I meet are gorgeous, they're never really… pure. If I met a girl who was 10/10 and also a total virgin, naturally I'd devote everything to her, but the girls I meet are physically 8/10 sluts who want my time and attention 24/7. As soon as I find out she's done something with another dude, I no longer feel she deserves all of my time. If I'm overlooking her past experiences, she should have to share.
Beyond that it's just greed. Every girl fills a different niche for me. I want a couple skinny petite girls with tight little bodies, I want a couple chubby girls with huge tits, a redhead, an asian, etc. I don't think I could ever truly remain satisfied with just *one* type, you know?