What are your techniques to minimize filesize? I'm trying to fit an hour long album into Holla Forums's 8mb limit, and I've gotten it down to 20mb but I need to go further.
What do you recommend?
This is the command I'm using: ffmpeg -i "file.mp4" -crf 63 -c:v libvpx -b:v 40K -b:a 50K -vf scale=24:24 -r 1 -threads 8 file.webm
You encode the cover image at 1fps for the video stream, dumbfuck. And concat all of the audio together and choose your bitrate there. Ultimately I recommend using a non-shit site or posting the songs one after the other.
Chase Nguyen
...
Benjamin Reyes
Post it on a site where the limit is up to 350MB maybe? What's the point of posting something at ultra-shit-tier quality?
Andrew Sanders
Because I want to
Eli Martinez
then choose libvpx-vp9 for video, use two passes and lower -b:a even further and use opus for audio The result will invariably be misunderstood for a whale song but hey have fun wasting time
Julian Foster
16kbit/s opus sounds fine tbh
David Torres
I'm talking about the fact that he's converting a video stream, and not just -r 1 -loop 1 an image, not from a videostream that has already been encoded. You'd also use concat for all of the audio files. All of this shit is documented in the ffmpeg wiki.
Read man ffmpeg-all and look for libopus. There are 2 options there which might interest you:
1. frame_duration -- maybe you can set this higher and get away with a lower bitrate 2. cutoff -- see how much cutoff you can get away with without making it sound like shit
Zachary Young
For some reason, with the few songs I've picked, I can't tell the difference between an opus encoded with: -cutoff 12000 -b:a 20k -frame_duration 60 And one encoded with: -b:a 30k
But other than that they both don't sound nearly as good as 40k. Acceptable though especially if it's for demonstration purposes.
Ian Thompson
I use lrzip for folders, webp for images I don't really want to use 5 gorillion file types so I take the small hit in file size as a compromise.
ofc change the other parameters as you need and use vpx9
Landon Bailey
The only problem with my method, is that you must load the entire webm before it starts playing.
Asher Morris
You should download Hybrid (encoder GUI) It has a "target size" option.
Use VP9 for video and Opus for audio.
If you only want audio, just exclude the video. Chrome plays it fine.
Cameron Murphy
can it be done? overhead is like 500kb or so. than that leaves 7.5mb for audio. even at 16kb there isnt enough room.
Cameron Robinson
It's not 7.5 millibits, it's 7.5 megabytes. 16kbps comes out to 7.2MB per hour.
Austin Evans
Turn it into a midi hosted elsewhere or give up. As if that's not shit enough, you'll be lucky to have it listenable at all at dialup-age 8kb/s or lower.
How about being smart and JUST MAKE A VIDEO PER SONG
Wasn't shitchan+infinshitty supposed to get MP3 support at some point anyway? Where the fuck is that?
Hudson Nelson
Holy shit, I never realized opus had such good quality for low bitrates. I was going to upload a sample, but it appears I can't upload it here so.... a.pomf.cat/brvvqo.opus
Samuel Price
Sorry to say OP, but it seems like with the math done by everyone else 16kb/s CBR Opus is going to be your limit (which is a.pomf.cat/usgtpv.opus) which may be impressive on paper, but not so much to the ears.
Jonathan Nguyen
ffprobe 'a.pomf.cat/brvvqo.opus'Input #0, ogg, from 'a.pomf.cat/brvvqo.opus': Duration: 00:03:12.80, start: 0.000000, bitrate: 52 kb/s Stream #0:0: Audio: opus, 48000 Hz, stereo, fltp Metadata: ENCODER : OpenMPT 1.26.02.00 SOURCEMEDIA : tracked music file TITLE : Nature Suxx DATE : 2016 BPM : 220.588 How retarded are you? Is this Holla Forums?
Leo Johnson
Not him but stereo makes a huge difference to the quality of a song in my opinion
Elijah Cruz
Don't worry about that format. Let it die. It has no redeeming qualities.
Isaiah Edwards
Pretty neat that at that bitrate it sounds almost like a native tracker file.
Hunter Wood
what's wrong with stereo audio
use CVBR
Eli Phillips
go be fat somewhere else
Matthew Hughes
It takes double of filesize, retard. When you have extreme constraint, you prefer double the bitrate over two channels.
Brandon Howard
Unless you are using Opus the quality will suffer tremendously and even with Opus going below ~64k is critical. Also can't you just upload a .mp3 or in case of Opus a .ogg? Best way to go is just uploaing it somewhere else where you have more space available.
Grayson Sullivan
Another spectacular /lamer/ arguments thread.
If you were worth anything, you would know people already made some attempts with Vorbis (Floggy, lists.xiph.org/pipermail/vorbis/2003-August/023979.html , included in GT3/aoTuV as q-2), and there's probably some way to experiment with Opus to sacrifice its low latency and enable some kind of full length look-ahead to make it behave more like a general purpose compressor with a hundred megabyte window. No one is seriously interested in that because everyone who needs those bitrates only works with speech, and they already have a dedicated speech codec.
Also, people stream videos from floppy on a fucking original Amiga — pouet.net/prod.php?which=64861 — you need to step it up.
Adam Reed
Even with joint stero, the losses are big when you gotta go under 32k.
Samuel Powell
Why do you want your videos to be as shitty as possible?
Bentley Mitchell
Fuck off nigger, it works and is useful.
Now stereo is bad? I knew Holla Forums was full of shit and stupid opinions but this takes the cake.
Take your meds.
Landon Reed
This was from the one I encoded at 48kb/s though. The funny thing is, I reencoded the 16kb/s one in mono, and it didn't sound much different, sooooooo.
Brandon King
...
Noah Cruz
Change your ears, m8. The differences in quality are obvious, even if the loss of stereo is worse for music.
Joseph Hernandez
Here, make the difference yourself.
Justin Smith
I always forget firejail.
Matthew Cruz
Why are you using CRF and bitrate (via -b:v)? CRF is meant to encode a variable bitrate at a constant quality, but you're also setting a constant bitrate, cancelling that out.
Also, what is "file.mp4"? If it's just a still image with the audio, then you're probably wasting masses on video. Just take an image of the album art or whatever and have that as your video input. WebMs work fine that way.
Matthew Green
Please RTFM.
Bentley Hall
Why am I not surprised it's weebshit you're making weebms of?
Alexander Cruz
Supporting .opus files or at least video-less WebMs would be fine
Nathaniel Morgan
That's not going to happen, because Jim is a stupid pigfucker.
Levi Mitchell
Is there a free as in free software program to check weather or not a webm i encode is the same or similar to a webm i already have?
Blake Nelson
pls
Jackson Nguyen
who's the artist of that clip?
Michael Ortiz
That's the only example I had in my $HOME. I have 265GB of flac too. Shit taste, by the way.
This was for the sake of the argument, m8. My source is actually the OST bundled with the BD. Amazing quality with full dynamic range.