Is this genuinely a good documentary? My friend keeps telling me to watch it

Is this genuinely a good documentary? My friend keeps telling me to watch it

Other urls found in this thread:

books.google.com/books?id=r6UKrpSjUN0C&pg=PA4#v=onepage&q&f=false
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_News_Service
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bev_Harris
isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic1350019.files/Shermer-how-we-know-holocaust.pdf
thebestschools.org/features/michael-shermer-interview/
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Your "friend" is a braindead Holla Forumstard and should be put up against the wall. Now fuck off back to Holla Forums.

It's poor quality propaganda from start to finish.

Some of the sources are disputed and it is definitely propaganda. Still it is an alternative to most documentaries about Hitler.

At least it's not Zeitgeist, I guess.

...

Pretty much what this guy said.
It deliberately portrays Hitler in a good light, showing his "soft" side and hard youth, while not mentioning the atrocities of his regime.
It's not objective, and whether you're a braindead Holla Forumstard or not you've got to admit that's a pretty bad thing for a documentary.

...

Like what? The holohoax?

...

Fuck off back to le reddit kiddos.

Invading Poland, Denmark, Luxemburg, the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Yugoslavia, Greece and the Soviet Union.

Starving millions of prisoners of war to death in concentration camps.

Starting the first terror bombing campaing in history.

Implementing Aktion T4 which exterminated many disabled people, including fellow veterans from WWI who were amputees or still shellshocked after many years.

In short, destroying Europe and causing the death of approx. 40 million white European people.

Ooops, forgot about Norway!

Oh there's just so much wrong this man did.

Hello Austria

THIS ISN'T Holla Forums

NO ONE CARES ABOUT HITLER

This was good.
Labour camps was just in fashion at the time and the starving part was unintentional.
If it had worked out and demoralized the britbongs it would have been worth it in the long term. Worked for the US against the Japs later on.

Implementing eugenics was a great thing and if they would have won the war that would have made the European peoples greater than ever before. Lastly you can't blame the guy for losing, he gave his best and he failed. That's not an atrocity, that's the spirit we need in Europe today. Everyone has already given up on fighting bloodthirsty islamists for example, that's much worse than fighting and losing.

...

Japs were nearly unaffected by the firebombing of Tokyo despite it possibly killing more people than both atom bombs combined. Nuking those fuckers was the only thing that scared them.

>>>/plebbit/

Meaning what? Has there ever been anything made about Hitler that wasn't? Better question: did it contain lies and if so what were they?


Funny how anons like you are quick to dismiss these things without giving any reasons why. Almost like you just go along with the herd without a clue what you're talking about.


Wew lad


Yids confirmed. You do know the US had concentration camps during that same war and had their supply lines been destroyed those guards would have fed themselves first too, right? Of course not. Also see link related.

First of all, they were labor camps, Internment camps were not labor camps. Second, it only happened on the west coast because commiefornians are subhuman.

reddi/pol/ please. It's one thing to feel shame for your reddit origins but quite another to project them on to actual anons.

I was referring to the nukes, if that wasn't terror I don't know what is. Hitler just attempted it before the tech was there.

But I made that myself, and I don't go to Holla Forums.

I see the first post is always a kike on Holla Forums too

Gee, I wonder who could be behind this post.

newfag detected

...

Almost certainly not.

On a related note the absolute greatest WW2 documentary is The World at War. Watch that if you haven't. The only flaw is it lacking discussion of the Bletchley park codebreakers and some other shit that was either classified or stuck in Soviet records back in the 70s.

I've never understood this term. Regardless of what you think of Holla Forums, or even Reddit, you have to admit that their communities are almost polar opposites. It's like that "commie-nazis" bit from the Simpsons, except that was just a joke the writers knew didn't make any sense.

Oh and it's a little bit harsh on the Germans, in my opinion. Still actually bothering to interview everyone left alive really gives it an edge.

/po/ continues to embarrass themselves on a daily basis. It's hard getting laughed at when you dare poke your heads out of your hugbox, isn't it?

Soviet Storm is also very good, very detailed and unbiased.

I can't say I've seen it user but I'll put it on the list.

You do get that Holla Forums is the largest board on this site with almost 3k posters right? This is Holla Forumschan.

I'm not even that user but by that logic halfchan is Holla Forumschan or, if you wish to discount Holla Forums, Holla Forumschan. Clearly this is untrue.

It's the Holla Forums spammer guy, it's not intended to make any sense.

So much good goy butthurt ITT. If Holla Forums triggers you so much, Leddit and Cuckchan still exist.

Let me guess, y'all voted for Bernie, didn't you?

By your logic cuckchan is Holla Forums.


It isn't?

It is

t. leddit

t. halfchan

Illusions, Mr. Holla Forumstard. Vagaries of perception. Temporary constructs of a feeble naziboo intellect trying desperately to justify shitposting on other boards that is without meaning or purpose. And all of them as retarded as Holla Forums itself.

Ok. You baited me. Theres no way you're this autistic. Good job.

I think you're spamming your Holla Forums crap because you're legitimately butthurt about people finding out the truth about things. You might layer it in obfuscating irony or poor attempts at trolling but deep down I think you whisper "Oy vey!" to yourself every time someone dares to question the post-war propaganda and jewish narrative.

...

Are you new here or something?

not him, but that's accurate

...

It has a lot of problems from a production standpoint but is one of the few sources about Hitler that is remotely honest.

topkek

I too remember being 14, discovering halfchan and pretending to be redpilled by denying the holocaust.

Don't worry, one day you'll grow up and stop believing your own nonsense.

Can't be too hard to remember about a year in the past.

Wow I didn't see that coming [sarcasm].

...

Actually it is 4chon/new/ -> 4chan/new/ -> 4chan/pol/ -> Holla Forums/pol/ my dear Holla Forums spammer.

Also I doubt the Japanese camps were allowed orchestras, theaters and brothels.
It was an executive order issued by FDR, heeb dumbfuck.


$20 says you're also the "cumskin" user. A cringey nigger obsessed with reddit, how novel.


You should.


Not everyone accepts lies based on perceived membership to some "heritage". Nice projection though, rabbi.

Like clockwork, say anything about Hitler and they'll stampede butthurt out of the woodwork and defend their old lies. Every time someone questions the holohoax it brings a smile to my lips because I know that with absolutely certainty there is a rat somewhere out there who just suffered a panic attack and is furiously typing up a post to attack the person who pointed out how ridiculous the "muh six mirrion" lie is.

They were internment camps, think a jail cell but for non-criminals. I knew an Hawaiian man who was in one and while he says the US guards were mean and discriminatory to the Japs it was nothing like the brutallity of the German war machine or the Rape of Nanking.

So in other words no orchestras, theaters or brothels. Got it.

So this Hawaiian guy was in Nanking, the California internment camps AND Nazi Germany?Sounds like some kind of pineapple nigger Forrest Gump. Hope you got his autograph.

Keep trying Toshii

Hitler was a degenerate junkie manlet dog-shagger with a terrible case of inferiority complex.

It's really not a surprise that he was outsmarted, defeated and humiliated by better, superior men (including an alcoholic fatass and a cripple LOL!).

Why does Holla Forums fall for this every time?

Because otherwise they might have to actually discuss movies. Since the majority of faggots here don't watch anything but capeshit and similar garbage they will do anything to avoid that.

it's the cuckchan refugees
8ch/tv/ doesn't give a shit about politics, much less about hitler

What did he mean by this?

>Being this mad
My sides are starting to hurt from laughing too much.

He wasn't in Nazi Internment Camps or Nanking, I'm just saying overall from what I know of the two and what he told me.

I dunno, Hitler seem to trigger at least a couple of posters.

Almost certainly started by the Jews to drum up sympathy once everyone stopped caring about their favorite boogyman.

The jews started with it right after the war, chump. It's a really shitty forced meme that should have died a long time ago. Everyone who has done even a small amount of research knows it never happened.

You've bought their attempt to drum up sympathy hook, line, and sinker.

This is some next level shit. There was no holocaust but the Germans tried to get rid of the cryptojews from their society. That didn't involve shoveling them into ovens or whatever lies the allies cooked up after the war. There were Jewish ghettos, they were "discriminated" against for the good of the German people, there was labour camps where many of them were sent together with other harmful elements such as commies and dissidents. The "holocaust" never took place though, there was no proper extermination of them even if I wish such a thing had taken place.

You're literally agreeing with me retard.

Nope, the word holocaust implies something else.

Watch it because so many people tell you not to watch it. Especially since it's illegal in most of Europe.

I agree. Seeking out censored speech is always good, because censorship usually means that a government wants to protect you from some idea "for your own good". But the step that everyone always forgets is then using your own brain to compile multiple sources of information and look at each with a critical eye. A banned film doesn't necessarily contain the unquestionable truth simply by virtue of its taboo.

If you were in Germany between 1933-1945, the same principle could apply to Anders als die Andern, Mädchen in Uniform, The Great Dictator, The Bohemian Girl, Kuhle Wampe, La Grande Illusion, and others. After 1945, Der Ewige Jude and Jud Süß (a personal favorite) were forbidden, so seeking these out is also in opposition to censorship.

Likewise, Kenyans should watch Stories of Our Lives, Pollacks between 1973-1981 should've watched the various Wojciech Wiszniewski documentaries, Iranians should watch Jafar Panahi's stuff, Tanzanians should watch The Route, and the Congolese should watch The Man Who Mends Women, especially since that last one had literally no reason given when it was banned. A Chinese person should watch Back to the Future or any number of Chinese-produced films that critique communism. Stick it to the Beatles and watch the documentary Let It Be. If it was before 1991, you could've stuck it to the Massachusetts state government by watching Titicut Follies.

Could you give me list of which countries banned it? I know youtube removed it. A problem just as important as government censorship and the slow expansion of the definition of hate speech is the fact that an increasing percentage of communication between average people uses the centralized digital services of corporations who have financial incentive to remove controversial content.

yes


that isn't a voltaire quote.

It's shit.
Poorly made propaganda and delusional babble.

I'd recommend hellstorm if you want looks into the war and what actually happened though. Not really a lie whatsoever. The allies were monsters more-so than the worst of the Germans, or the Soviets.

You fags are the gift that keeps on giving.

the problem is finding out that its even censored; its ot like they go around publicy announcing what is and is not allowed to be seen.

Of course they would ban a propaganda film made by their enemies you dolt.

I doubt everyone you listed is Holla Forums.

hōs epi to polu

Stop with the inferior Jew talk and speak Engrish.

its transliterated greek you plebeian.

A good point, although the film was banned two years before the US entered the war. Censorship can be practical for wartime morale, but that still doesn't make it right when it silences legitimate criticism of government policy. The Nazi government wanted to protect its citizens from the movie because it contained the idea that the persecution of Germany's Jewish minority and the suppression of individual freedom under totalitarianism is morally wrong. There are plenty of films and other media criticizing the US's interventionism during the Cold War and the War on Terror, but none of these have been outright banned by the US government.

The enemy propaganda excuse also doesn't apply to the silencing of German dissension and any non-Nazi values. That was purely to keep the regime in power and allow it to control every facet of culture.

Youtube bans the subject of this thread because it perceives it as a propaganda film made by racist Neo-Nazis. Of course they would do it, as it's a practical PR decision for a corporation that wants to make money, but does that make it right?


You're right. I can imagine the internet would help with that at least a little.

...

...

all me

Then what politics are not normalfag then user?

You lie

it's decent, but i only managed to get through 2 hours of it. shit's just too long
mind as well just read mein kampf instead, it's a lot shorter

Prove it.

Why do you hate real diversity?

All politics are for stupid normalfags. Only normalfag suckers haven't figured out that it's all the same and your votes and opinions don't matter. Don't bring that shit here.

nice try nwo

No, it's full of shit. Just as Hitler wasn't the Devil, he was also not Jesus.

Do you expect people to believe and agree with you without evidence? Unless you can provide evidence of your claim I will just have to assume you're a defeatist.

books.google.com/books?id=r6UKrpSjUN0C&pg=PA4#v=onepage&q&f=false

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_News_Service
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bev_Harris

Now I do consider representative democracy a shit tier form of government but not every nation is the US. Furthermore I don't think national socialism could be described as normalfag, it's not even democratic but a reaction to the failures of democracy.

As for political opinions not mattering I don't think that's necessary true. If you don't act on your beliefs then they mean fuckall but if you actively try to change something they do matter, especially if you're willing to take up arms and potentially die for your cause.

...

I found the PDF!

And I uploaded it here as well:
>>>/pdfs/4146
>>>/pdf/400
>>>/polarchive/1340
>>>/pdfarchive/4

You rock.


I only know about the systemic electoral fraud in my own country, sorry. I assume similar things are done throughout the West, though nations with multiparty systems probably aren't as thoroughly rigged as our two-party system.

America is too big for the plutocracy to allow self governance. Smaller and more socialist nations have more functioning forms of democracy but you still get forced shit like the European Union. If you want a better society you need to fight liberalism with force and replace it with a less exploitable system than democracy that is strong enough to fight corruption and the (((parties))) that act against the good of the people.

I agree. I often think that the North American nations are all too big and should be broken up. Where government is concerned, smaller is better. They bigger they get, the harder they are to hold accountable and change when necessary.

Does whoring the Shoah at every opportunity ever bother you?

I felt like the documentary did a really good job at explaining the historical side of things for the first half, it tells you thing you didn't know, backed by proof and interesting facts.

Then at some point halfway through it goes completely off the rail into poltardedness and talks about conspiracies, things that have absolutely no proof whatsoever and becomes just nazi propaganda.

It's too bad, I was really starting to like it

this thread is like another shoah

its literally the worst documentary ever made.

You mean the part calling bullshit on the "final solution"?

It's just a compilation of clips from other documentaries and videos. It's pretty good though.

Know an objective hitler-centric documentary?

schindler's list.

Any Holla Forumstard can tell me what did Holla Forums do to you fags to make them so fixated on it, turning into their boogeyman on par with jews and other races?


Nice strawman and like your clueless friend above, another non-answer. Holla Forums has never been weaker, many of you can barely argue before backing up to insults, ad hominem and accusations of juden.

Its pretty good. If you like World at War you'd like it.

Besides, every true patrician knows that the root of the modern dilemma falls upon the French Revolution, not WW2.

...

Fucking jacobins ruined the west.

This man knows what he's talking about.

The documentary itself is propaganda. But here's the thing: EVERY and I really do mean every other documentary about WWII I've seen is blatant propaganda for the other side. While they lie completely, this one mostly keeps silent about Hitler's blunders, so it's lie by omission than outright fabrication. In any case, it's an interesting look into an alternative world where the other side won and honestly, this documentary has more truth to it than what you'll see on history channel or wherever. It's worth a watch, but not following blindly.

wrong, the documentary lies about jews and denies the Holocaust.

Which never happened.

It actually says the truth about both things. The holocaust is a jewish lie.

isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic1350019.files/Shermer-how-we-know-holocaust.pdf

lol

lol

It's true though.

exactly, The Holocaust is a true event.

...

Shermer had a secular childhood, though he attended Sunday School. He became more devoutly Christian at the age of 17, and briefly became an evangelical. He originally wanted to become a theologian, but felt he couldn't learn the languages which the occupation required (Hebrew, Latin, Greek, and Aramaic). He later grew disillusioned with the absolutist morality that religion makes possible, but he still has a deep respect for the social aspect of religion.

thebestschools.org/features/michael-shermer-interview/

None of the above information is worth shit, though. A claim is proven or disproven on its own merits, not on its author. If Jews lie, you look at their lie and pick it apart.


Nice trips, keep going.

For starters, at the credits sequence, instead of stating where the footage and sound came from, all of it is blogspot posts where they got their "facts". They even stole a sample of a "Les Miserables" number to show off footage of a russian gulag, without mentioning it.

I'm surprised there isn't an ED article about how technically bad it is. If you genuinely want to show somebody the Holohoax, start of with researching Treblinka's camps.