Explain yourselves stalinists
Tankies will defend this
Other urls found in this thread:
workers.org
twitter.com
Based.
Moar?
Some Holla Forums tankies will defend it. Most twitter and reddit tankies will say it was one of Stalin's biggest fuck ups.
No thank you
Some of them were maybe reactionary or something, so it's all good.
Homosexuality is a SOCIAL ill, therefore it is incumbent on SOCIALISM to ban it. If you want to spread aids and fun and tank the fertility rate go move to a capitalist paradise like Somalia.
...
...
Wtfs wrong with you
Yeah, but everyone I don't like is a zionist CIA amerikkkan ultra-leftist anarcho-fascist Trotskyite and probably a stupid lazy worker as well. Gays are stupid, praise Stalin.
Why was this? Was female sexuality just not taken seriously?
Also yuri is shit.
...
>>>/cuteboys/359591
Seriously though I do disagree with Stalin on this.
Because hetero men find two women making out hot.
You'd think they'd stop falling for it.
...
It's all really obvious but also really sad. I blame the internet.
following the october revolution the laws of Tsarist russia were abolished, and except local laws a constitution was never drawn up until the 30's, with there being an official constitution in 1936. Homosexuality was still seen very much as a disease in the medical world at the time, and to state Lenin had different views on this would be fucking retarded, as it would be to say "lol Lenin freed the gays" only because he abolished all Tsarist laws. So I don't see this as surprising given the time of happening and the historical context.
banning homosexuality was one of the two things Stalin did wrong
the other is not killing more kulaks
Yes, I defend this
Stalin was a good christian man
He attended a priest school after all
Homosexuality is reactionary and imperialist
This. It's literally a meme (lenin freed the gays) followed by another meme (stalin banned the gays). It's entire purpose seems to be to make stalinism look bad so I assume it was started by trots.
Copypasting this from /marx/ ~
The immediate reason was based on the conflation of homosexuals with homosexual pedophiles in NKVD reports. See: workers.org
The restrictions on abortion could be considered consistent with original Bolshevik intentions:
"A matter which has raised considerable doubts in the minds of many protagonists of sex-equality in this country is the law, passed in 1936, making abortion illegal except in cases where it is justified by consideration for a woman's health or the danger of hereditary disease. This change in the law has been treated as an attack on sex-equality.
It is of the greatest importance in this connection, to refer back to the text of the original law which legalised abortion in Soviet Russia in 1921. It is important to note that in this law not a word was said about sex-equality, and the right to have an abortion was never put forward as a fundamental right of the Soviet woman. On the contrary, abortion was treated as a social evil, but an evil which was likely to be less harmful when practised legally than when carried out under conditions of secrecy. Here is part of the text of the original law permitting abortion:
'During the past decades the number of women resorting to artificial discontinuation of pregnancy has grown both in the West and in this country. The legislation of all countries combats this evil by punishing the woman who chooses to have an abortion and the doctor who performs it. Without leading to favourable results, this method of combating abortion has driven the operation underground and made the woman a victim of mercenary and often ignorant quacks who make a profession of secret operations. As a result, up to 50 per cent of such women are infected in the course of the operation, and up to 4 per cent of them die.
'The Workers' and Peasants' Government is conscious of this serious evil to the community. It combats this evil by propaganda against abortions among working women. By working for Socialism, and by introducing the protection of maternity and infancy on an extensive scale, it feels assured of achieving the gradual disappearance of this evil. But as moral survivals of the past and the difficult economic conditions of the present still compel many women to resort to this operation. . .' it is allowed in State hospitals.
The essential feature of this law is that it was based on 'difficult economic conditions,' and was of a temporary nature. The right to abortion was never introduced as one of the rights of Soviet women, to be enjoyed in all circumstances. It was considered an 'evil,' and was introduced as a makeshift to combat the serious mortality rate from illegal abortions carried out under unsatisfactory conditions. There is evidence that, at the present time, owing to the increased knowledge of contraceptives on the one hand and the growing sense of economic security on the other, women will not now practise abortion in this way, and that therefore the permissive law is no longer necessary in the interests of health. Abortion in Soviet legislation has always been regarded primarily as a question of health, not of equality. Since thousands of women have been neglecting the use of contraceptives because they could obtain an abortion, the legality of the less satisfactory method of discontinuing pregnancy has actually to some extent prevented more satisfactory methods from being used of avoiding pregnancy altogether."
(Sloan, Pat. Soviet Democracy. London: Victor Gollancz. 1937. pp. 125-126.)
Alexandra Kollontai, interviewed in 1936:
The arguments for restricting abortion weren't really couched in moral terms (e.g. nothing about "right to life"), but in terms of increasing the population. Abortion was legalized again in 1955, since it was considered erroneous to have prohibited it.
This, faggotry is bourgeois decadence
Twitter tankies truly are just edgier radlibs.
...
It wasn't a serious law, just some bantz with his friends. Everyone's got that one faggy friend that they'd write national laws to make fun of
Faggots are a Biohazard(kys m8.)
It was a great error, but similar laws were present around the world.
Also a reminder that the DDR was the first country to legalize homosexuality
tfw Poland of all countries was one of the few that has never outlawed homosexuality. I'm not sure what it really makes me think.
How is it a meme if he indeed banned them?
The first country to do that wasn't France?
...
Women under socialism do not resort to crude bisexuality in order to "express themselves" as they do under western Capitalism. Also lesbianism is pretty rare in the wild. Many believe the first "lesbian" was literally just a dude role playing.