Communism requires people to act like people will never act.
This is true of all communism.
Stalinism or northern Scandinavian socialist democracy is the best it will ever be.
These are worse than a propertarian or right leaning paternalist government.
I'm open to hear your arguments though.
I suggest looking into S trasserism
t. feudalists.
OMG thats pretty WOKE my man!!1!
never thought about HUMAN NATURE….damn!
Capitalism is a class system, just like feudalism was.
Strasserism is cute.
It's adherence to nation does help with the motivation problem of socialism and syndicalist (probably the most viable communard system) is more stable than others but it has clear problems.
Workers produce different amounts while both Asserism and syndicalism effectively treats them as spherical workers of a uniform density so to speak.
It also would with few exceptions devolve into a rule by the aged elite and families who engage in nepotism.
One might accuse modern day neo liberalism and neo conservativism of doing as such but at least they have a stronger meritocratic edge.
The final problem is that those who rise the top would not be innovators so much as arch conservatives due to the fact that the proliteriat class are often willing to listen to luddites both social and technological providing there's no risk to their livelihoods that they see involved in stagnation.
its human nature to roam the steppe like the noble stallions, morans… sedentism will never take off, every time it's been attempted the crops died in winter, tell me why that wasnt REAL agrarian society!!
...
are you trying to say class based on relations to the means of production is human nature?
If I was a steppe nomad I would question the validity of agriculture if everyone who attempted it seemed to kill a lot of people and/or converting back to a nomadic lifestyle within 100 years.
It would seem either mistaken or not worth the bother.
In general Marxism is both utopian (which if you look into the etymology you should know it's in part a pun based off one's inability to reach said state) and utilitarian.
These apart can function fine, but a perfect, unreachable society you'd do anything to reach is permission to do literally anything.
An ethical and moral carte Blanche.