What is your opinion of these kinds of people who you classify as one of these hipster types, who in large part might be neoliberal, but not necessarily ain't so?
I am asking this because as someone who is into the arts field, I have been in contact with much of these kinds of people. It's quite easy at your part to dismiss them as neoliberal right-wing bourgeois whatever but when I really listen to them, they have complained about capitaist alienation, and student loans, and how they can't really study what they personally would like, because they have to think about rather learning what makes them employable.
Don't get me wrong, I have met hipster types who's arrogance knows no boundaries, but there still is something about them, this little thing where they would give everything they've got to live in a truly left-wing economy.
In that light, what do you think about those kinds of creatives/hipsters? Are they hopeless bourgeois who belong in gulag or can they be salvaged?
I like the pink hair but I wish people naturally had pink hair, same with blue and green.
Brody Clark
How did you get a picture from the Ron Paul timeline?
Matthew Flores
You shouldn't put people in the same bag just because they follow a trend.
Joseph Hill
This, but hipster culture as a whole is liberal and bourgeois. Nothing wrong with artsy people but they better have other skills than making art.
Jordan Gutierrez
Theyre cool unless theyre cunts.
Alexander Gutierrez
The cake looks delicious.,
That's all.
Isaac Wood
Complaining about hipsters like it's 2008 is, by itself, pathetic, but trying to make "Marxist" interpretations of immaterial social trends like that makes it even worse. You need to grow up.
Ayden Martin
The cake is a lie. The cake is a spook.
Brody Gutierrez
Artfag here, I've practiced lots of different medium but I've never met many hipsters because I'm self taught. The problem are not the hipster per se but the conditions that we live in, postmodernism rewards people for being all about Feelz > Realz and for not doing anything that actually biulds towards their emancipation. People is never the problem.
Jason Ramirez
the modern working class isn't like the proletariat of the industrial revolution. most workers in the post industrial world are precarious service workers. 'creatives' are pretty proletarianised by this point, ie. zero job security, tons of debt, alienation. communism isn't identity politics for industrial workers, but the real movement towards the abolition of the capitalist system.The fetishisation of working class authenticity in Stalinist parties was probably the original form of modern identity politics. We shouldn't encourage artsy types to pursue industrial jobs in spite of their actual interests or inclinations because it's somehow more 'authentic' or something.
Jordan Barnes
Does she have a dick?
Brody Taylor
OP here, I needed this reply, thanks.
Caleb Harris
They will be useful when repopulating Siberia.
Ayden Hill
Some are salvageable. I live with a gay one, though, and straight up fits your OP to a T.
Wouldn't trust him in a revolution at all. Actively avoid talking politics with him because he has "SNITCH" written all over him.
All I'm saying is BEWARE of these types. I would posit most of them are right wing bourgeois trash that love joking about gentrification and being useful idiots for the Democrats. They unironically will shill neoliberalism when you get down to the nitty gritty of true communist ideals. They love private property and bourgeois speech and will never let go of these things.
Logan Johnson
The worst part is, they often identify as "oppressed" per leftist idpol ideology and constantly use this to appeal to leftists that naively try to 'convert' them to their ideological tendency. This is nothing more than a way to get you to out yourself as a communist so they can later snitch on you. It's just a slower and more cunning alternative to the alt-righters actively putting you on a list.
Carter Robinson
In many ways I would say they're worse than right wingers because of this. They pay symbolic deference to leftism by claiming to have "read Chomsky" or some other meaningless BS and will stab you in the back at a moment's notice when it's ideologically convenient for them to.
The whole Bernie killed Rosa meme is real is all I'm saying. DONT SAY I DIDNT WARN YOU FUCKERS
John Smith
You can't be a marxist if you fall for capitalist traps
What are you on? This is basic human talk, what does this have to do with anything? Fascists talk like this, Libruls talk like this, Conservashits talk like this, everyone does.
Owen Morris
Is this her? Or is she some 4chan girl?
Evan Evans
The truth that nobody wants to acknowledge is that ideology (as in political/economic theory) is nowhere near as important because their ideology is probably never going to be implemented in his lifetime. What really is important is your personal philosophy and how you live your life, these people are either void of it or have the most disgusting philosophies possible and bourgeoisie benefit from this kind of obedient slaves the most.
Hunter Thomas
Completely fucking counter- revolutionary.
Bentley Jones
Reminder that Gavin McInnes is part of the alt-light.
Parker Campbell
But they are so insufferable. Hipsters strike me as hyper cause consumers. I don't think any of them are artists, simply fetishize artisanship because it take more labor, then any real appreciation of it or because it's superior.
Jaxson Martin
This, feel for this trap personally and lost a job over it.
Nicholas Phillips
alt-light is the alt-right
Jayden Robinson
for all the bright colours and self-proclaimed "queerness", they are usually remarkably boring people once you get to know them
Isaac Wilson
Is this surprising for you? I mean, what did you even expect?
Nicholas Bell
I guess at one point I kinda expected what it says on the tin you know, for the personality to be as colourful as the hair. For them to actually be into some obscure and interesting music or philosophy or authors something like their facebook posts hint at. for their """queer""" gender and sexuality to actually be something beyond being a straight cis girl with a pixie haircut who kissed a girl once in high school or a skinny straight boy who wears eyeliner and tight jeans and now they're both oppressed sexual minorities telling you to check muh privilege somehow.
it's just disappointing you know? until you really get to know this kind of person there's this mystique around them that they're on the cutting edge of """new culture""" or are at least genuinely weird, but they're nearly always as flat as extras from an Apple ad.
one of the big social lessons I learned in my 20s was that if you want to meet an interesting person at a party or something, you find the person in the corner wearing really unremarkable clothes, with a 10 buck haircut, staring at their shoes and they'll be really passionate about something you've never heard of, or have strong opinions on early medieval philosophical schools, or will blow your mind in bed while the showy fashionista hipsters (if that's what we're still calling them?) will disappoint you every time.
Adrian Roberts
I know examples where this is not always true, like some girl vaguely related to me by extended family who dresses average but she is criticized by other family members and cousins for being one of the most boring and conservative-minded people they can think of.
Then again I can bring example of two art school girls, where one of them was into cosplaying stuff and the other was pretty regular-looking, and I wouldn't say anything remarkable about that first girl's personality, while the other one was the perfect "manic pixie dream girl" in real life, and I mean it in the good way, like real innocent, friendly, transparent and had all these fun little quirks that she seemed to enjoy on their own rather than wanting to appear a certain way for others.
I've always found that good way to find genuinely interesting people is to ask why they are doing something, wearing something, or going somewhere, and listen to how they speak. There is a combination of good sense of humor, being consistently eccentric, being absent-minded and using a large, varied vocabulary in speech that makes person genuinely interesting and not just pretentious.
Chase Bailey
What the fuck is that picture.
James Gonzalez
Judging from the reflections, pixellation and font choices, it looks fake. I usually assume all this too nonsensical stuff to be fake unless someone posts picture several pictures from different angles.
Matthew Diaz
No such thing, people who speak IRL like it's Holla Forums or some philosophical forum are usually complete egocentric morons with very low self-esteem Using uncommon words in speech is a sin unless you really can't find a simple alternative for your words. If you unironically use "Duning-Kruger effect instead of Illusory superiority", "bourgeoisie instead of capitalist", buzzwords like dialectic, or even worse, words that nobody other than those that have a read a particular book have heard of then you are completely oblivious to how dumb the impression you give is. You're completely alienated
Joseph Miller
fags need to be purged tbh.
Evan Ramirez
Fucked up the quotation marks.
It's a photoshop of course, but cosplayers are indeed prostitutes that can be hired after their regular duty, but that's not a surprise to anyone.
Adrian Adams
true, but that's only half of the truth. for instance, I'm an alienated egocentric moron with low self esteem, and I generally don't speak my mind in public, at best I speak in vague allusions that fly over everyone's head, and I only sperg out when I'm drunk to the point of almost losing consciousness.
Landon Nguyen
You have a good point, I haven't really thought about it like that. I personally don't really do that thing, I like to explain complex concepts using metaphors, not buzzwords. I use metaphors really often to explain almost everything, because it just works with normies, but it gets me in trouble sometimes, because some of the dumber ones have tendency to take my metaphors too literally or start to correct my metaphor example instead of arguing with the point I was trying to make.
I can't stand social drinking that much anymore. Sometimes I drink alone in purpose so I don't have a chance to do as much stupid shit. When I am drunk, I usually stay peaceful/respectful but become overly hyped about certain topics and overwhelmed quite a lot of people with these
drivel rants.
Benjamin Butler
Is that girl a hipster? I think she looks more like a punky teenager who probably considers her self artistic or creative. I'd see her as a possible comrade, both punk and the arts have long traditions with the left wing. As for hipsters, they are obsessed with the authentic and artisan-ship to the point of being almost reactionary, but still have progressive social values. They are way to obsessed with small business, individualism and entrepreneurship to go for M-L, but I think there is enough contempt for big business that mutualism could have a real chance of catching hold among muh barbershop and micro breweries hipsters.
That cake looks like crap, bland tasting sugar bread dipped in food-color to look interesting. If you look close enough you can see the girl asking herself "is this what I would taste like?"
Jayden Scott
I said "hipster" due lack of a better word for the "alternative-dressing young creative types", I think the actual "hipster" subculture itself with beards, glasses, v-necks is just a fashion movement. What you described as start-up individualist artisan-ship obsessed types falls well under what most young creatives are into as well, but there are some young creatives who don't fall into hipster subculture, for example these deviantart/tumblr browsing types who are into vaporwave, pastelgoth, healthgoth or some kind of anime cosplay stuff. Maybe I am wrong and these people are just female version of hipster.
Mason Watson
Nothing wrong with them, creatives are as important to society as the worker. Both have their work exploited and have a lot more in common than they think. Without culture to consume, society withers and dies and these people are the ones who will make that culture.
Christian Garcia
t. porky
Still pretentious Try something like "stupid people unproportionally often think that they are smart"
Andrew Scott
jump off a bridge, "comrade"
Dylan Butler
How did this happen comr8?
Levi Long
You sure of that bruv?
Daniel White
I call then semen demons 😏
Owen Jackson
I dont mind hippies and other liberal people but i consider myself more traditional working class. I work in construction and dress and look like a normal person.
William Butler
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Charles Mitchell
"Creatives" are neither creative not innovative
Ryan Green
No, the girl op posted is just some russian qt
Carson Powell
Its shopped
Eli Gomez
...
Adam Flores
if all those empty gestures were just to out yourself as an idiot, you could've saved everyone the time and said so at the beginning. Instead you choose to make me read a paragraph of some insecure, overtly self-conscious loser's rant.
Christopher Murphy
...
Hunter Watson
Tell me: why live like this?
Michael Jackson
I know saying this on Holla Forums will get me called a bunch of buzzwords, but I am unironically one of the types working in graphic design and probably looking to at one point get in the business side of this field, but I don't really mind manual labor people either. I am the only one of those in my entire extended family, as most of my extended family are involved with various traditional jobs too, so I can get along with people unlike me if I have to.
If revolution comes and there is a real threat of getting killed for being a petit bourgeois, I will find one way or another to save my skin. Again, not a threat, just stating a fact. That all being said, I have more than just sympathy for everything left wing. Hell, I even dislike the SJW's.
end of blogpost :)
qt is a qt alright, no matter what nationality, which is a spook anyway
Justin Thompson
This man gets it and probably has friends irl.
Lucas Murphy
Fuck das a good reply right here
Jayden Perry
What's up with this girl? Why is /g/ obsessed with her?
Jaxon Thompson
I'm sure that's a trap+camwhore, so take a guess.
Cooper Reyes
I don't know, these girls I have posted ITT are just ones saved from cuckchan from back when I was browsing it. Can't too it anymore, Holla Forums has infested the entire 4chan now.
Angel Kelly
conservative hipsters are more hot.
Brayden Hill
I get what you're saying, but I disagree with hipsters just being a fashion movement, or perhaps more the implied statement that fashion movements can be unpolitical. The movement is highly consumerist in the weight it puts on buying habits and outward appearances as a form of self expression, and this is similar to a lot of "young creatives", but because of this shared focus on outward appearances, the visual differences become significant. The bearded hipster becomes a reactionary figure, even when mimicking left wing radicals like Hemingway or Jack London, they end up idealizing a distorted vision of the past, and especially mid century Americas ideals of masculinity and individualism.
Hudson Lopez
user, I…
Jack Roberts
This is probably the lamest meme ever made. Just stop, it isn't funny in the least.
Bentley Clark
Stay in denial You don't know how to influence others at all
Jackson Evans
nice spook Holla Forumsyp
see
Easton Baker
Good thing I don't care about appealing to others. You can play your sad little games though.
Kayden Moore
Stop fighting g-guise… ;_;
Nicholas Perez
Art fags will be gulag'd. They produce little to nothing of value for society. In many ways they are like the bourgeois or even worse.
Caleb Watson
ML morons like yourself will never be in a position of power, or anywhere remotely near one in your lives. Your dumb asses will likely be murdered off before your beautiful vanguard ever takes hold.
Carson Lopez
Would like to know as well
Matthew White
People like you have probably seen a handful of SJW's, lumbersexuals or tumblr thots and now you suddenly think these people are all there is to creatives. You probably have no idea how to differentiate between people who sport certain fashion styles in light-hearted, somewhat ironic manner, and people to whom appearance is everything.
Besides not knowing absolutely anything about creatives, you yourself with romanticizing 19th century factory workers are not much different from conservatives romanticizing 50's america or alt-righters romanticizing 30's germany.
People like you are cancer to the left wing movement. This guy said it, fuck off.
Parker Evans
We live in capitalism, the latter are all that exists.
Henry Parker
it's not about people caring about appareances, it's more about if there is anything beyond mere appearance, and some substance to it
Aiden Jones
I don't know what is with you anarkiddies who have this same Holla Forums-tier understanding of ML.
Lincoln Baker
Literally how? Porky hates creatives because they don't work the factory and make them money. Are you mentally handicapped?
Zachary Howard
...
Parker Bennett
on the contrary, to understand the present it is necessary to undertake an archeological study of the recent past. Every past has its own unfulfilled promises. 'Pop culture' is the dream of humanity slumbering under the weight of capital. as an upper middle class teenager growing up in the periphery during the late 00s and early 10s, I was into american 'indie' music, pitchfork, shitposting on /mu/ and many other things that seem downright quaint nowadays. blogger Carles.Buzz from hipster runoff was the Mexican Guy Debord, a witness to the hypercommodification of the 'indie' scene and the erasure of the distinction between indie and mainstream. Trends in music criticism can be traced back to the material base and the development of new media (ie. thequietus.com/articles/22389-rockism-poptimism).
We can go even further into the past: bush era, the 90s slacker ethos, the punks, the 60s counterculture and the abortive world revolution of 68-69. here's the CCRU's Mark Fisher and Robin McKay on Cobain (ccru.net/swarm1/1_pomo.htm). The relationship between hipsterdom and the alt right is also worth exploring: you can trace a line from Jim Goad in the 90s to Vice's Gavin McIness and the american apparel guys in the 00s, to Sam Hyde in the 10s.
Samuel Gomez
Porky loves "creatives". The art world in it's current form exists solely for their benefit, money defines the value of art under capitalism, and porky has the money. There is also a reason they call it the music industry. To quote Jay Z
the other part of your post was way worse. The reduction of culture to a consumable product, and the idea that society would crumble with out this specialized "creative" class. Are you even serious?
Xavier Green
i don't like it but i hate these "middle class" instagram consumerists so fucking much.
Mason Thomas
ML's are not even leftists but merely people who fetishise, tanks, Lenin, third world guerrillas, and burly industrial workers in socialist realist propaganda statues. Most of them, I imagine are petite bourgeois LARPers obsessed with laying claim to this idea of reified proletarian authenticity, just like Ho, Castro and Lenin himself. The vanguard is not the proletariat, the vanguard claims to represent the true, authentic will of the proletariat while blocking true revolutionary consciousness from emerging. Didn'tthe bolsheviks shoot the sailors at Kronstadt? Didn't Mao repress the Shanghai commune?
Gavin Lopez
as someone who does like fashion and style do you expect that fat cracker to get a fashion sense acording to his tastes and not his environment?
almost everyone dresses for the environment. the dude is trying to make it seem he is frat but he is obviously not. Anyway generalizing based on style is retarded. if you're trying to say that guy is a hipster no he is not. he is a regular boring dadcore fuck.
Elijah Baker
FYI there's more art then what plays on the pop radio statipns. Sounds like you've bought into porkys mindset yourself.
Robert Johnson
Bourgeois is a very specific kind of capitalist though. We have to use the word bourgeois because the bourgeois constantly try to obfuscate the fact that they are rich because of stolen surplus value by coming into the office and working along side proles like Musk.
Adam Hall
t. butthurt art student
Brandon Butler
I know we all have.
Samuel Cooper
wow this is so true. in my experience these types are easily the most vapid consumerist shills, so much that even conservatives find them toxic.
Austin Rivera
...
Angel Flores
holy fuck, this. is it any surprise that the people they try to look like are the white supremacists of yesteryear? the 1950's style dress, the pseuod-masculinity that says "hey dont fuck with me i have a beard!!" while not actually putting in real time in manual labor job… or lifting weights for that matter?
i've always found this incredibly suspect, the way they pine for the days where blacks and whites were 'seperate but equal' and they more or less pretend that shit was grand.
man, i fucking HATE hipsters
Angel Brooks
Lefting weights is vain porky faggotry. Your body should reflect the real work you do.
Bentley Walker
No it isn't. Most work nowadays isn't manual labor, as someone pointed out in another thread. Show me 'manual labor' in the US and i'll show you a job with shit pay and conditions that offers to chance for advancement whatsoever. that's the truth.
people in first world countries need exercise because of the way life is structured now.
these hipsters try to look like lumberjacks without doing the work and make aesthetic appeals to the very conservative notions of what is 'masculine' and its fucking nauseating.
if you think being in shape is 'vain porky faggotry' i can only assume you are a fat fuck attempting to make excuses for your lazy fat fuck self.
Gavin Baker
...
Parker Lewis
This thread reminded me I should read Boltanski's New Spirit of Capitalism". According to what I have heard, it is about this new trend in capitalism of celebrating creativity and project and self-entrepreneurship so the wage-slaves feel free.
Michael Gomez
I guess if she's hot and has the personality of a wet napkin.
Blake Flores
Literally So stupid considering wage labor makes all that shit Comic related as well
Adam Bailey
nice meme The thing is that additionally there are many that voluntarily go to places like librul arts schools, which is one of the, if not the biggest bourgeois money laundring scheme out there. They are the best consumers out there, even the ones who didn't work a day in their lifes since they can masterfully consume the money of their parents
Grayson Diaz
It all makes sense now why she panders to Holla Forumsyps.
Jaxson Walker
Name one relevant capitalist who isn't bourgeois
Sounds like a waste of time, you'll probably learn nothing new.
Iphones would not exist outside of capitalism though There would be unified model phone with no upgrades for years (and that's a good thing) Also the comic is retarded, the criticism is really valid since owning a smartphone shows that you're a stupid consumerist that feeds porkies who does nothing but slacktivism, also the analogies are all false equivalence.
Camden Mitchell
So what type of phone do you have, user?
Colton Butler
the only possible choice for real revolutionaries. All other phones are bourgeois slacktivism.
Hunter Stewart
so this is the praxis of ML huh? No one here talks about gulaging those who disagree with them, or even shit as benign as artistry other than you raging losers. Everyone knows you fucking faggots are ML's solely for the power trips it gives you, red aesthetic appropriation is about as far as your praxis goes, friend.
Lenin would have called Stalin's ideology an abomination of Marxism, and rightly so.
Joshua Bennett
Anyone can be salvaged. Imo, it's not who you are but who you fight for. If one of these so called "creatives" picked up a rifle to defend the revolution, they fine by me. If they don't fight but still support the revolution, fine by me. Support the counterrevolutionaries? Fuck them.
Elijah Wilson
A button Nokia
Gabriel Turner
...
Alexander Ross
This is a shit little thread btw
Grayson Rodriguez
Proofs?
Ian Murphy
...
Owen Nguyen
wtf same here I thought nobody uses Nokia anymore
Lincoln Evans
Nothing particular about hipster culture to any of the numerous subcultures under capitalism
Liam Turner
"Hipsters" are a reaction to late-capitalist, both in a cultural and economic sense. Culturally first, because it begins with young people that aren't workers and are even alienated from the wage system; they sense a degradation of life and the weight of the hegemonic capitalist "culture" and they try to find something in contradiction to it, something that is unlike their parents, obscure things they can secretly value without the obscenties of the advertising industry. Of course because all of this happens under capitalism, media and businesses quickly catch on and try to take these organic trends and force them into fashions and forced fads, reduce the cultural / political motives into vacuous statements: the original truthful reaction to capitalist alienation is replaced by the spectacle. This of course brings the subculture gradually into the mainstream to the horror of the originators, who scramble out to seek something else or decide to give up and cash in.
In the economic sense these people, older, feel the oppression of capitalist wage-slavery firsthand or tried to dodge it from the start, and react by attempting their small artsy businesses in some poor neighborhood because that's all they can afford to do without a corporate job, trying to live as much outside the system as they can while being inevitably submerged in it (being urban). They therefore naturally gravitate to libertarian-liberal concepts but also socialistic thoughts (though hard to put in practice in the above conditions). This alters the neighborhood culture and slowly begins to attract more of such people, but eventually the appropriators and pretenders invade in a flash of porky greed trying to profit from everything, destroying the little community with surface cultural consumers, new "sanitized" construction to rent/sell to the cultural consumers at ever-higher prices and "counter-culture" lifestylist idpol products made by big porky. This of course leads to the original inhabitants of the neighborhood being economically crushed and physically displaced along with the original hipsters.
The problem is largely that these people (the genuine ones) haven't read Debord and don't understand how capital takes over *everything*, or perhaps they understand but are powerless to stop it. Their perpetual search for an anti-capitalist existence is doomed to co-optation and failure without the large scale destruction of capitalism itself.
Grayson Morgan
if they have social media, just walk away.
Leo Lewis
For the most part yes…i believe they can. These type of peopel don't strike me as corrupted. I do believe for the most part this people could become useful members of society and rehabilitaed through labour. Like working on farms or cleaning and protecting florests. I think that's what they are needing the most…working! they have too much free time.
Bentley Carter
they look like fucking aliens
i'd clock her in the face tbh
Asher Wilson
I'm sort of one of these "hipster types."
Just consider that in the coming decades, in America there'll be previously unheard of populations of people (that are college-educated and often come from middle class/bourgeois backgrounds and are thus used to a higher standard of living, more "freedom," and a propensity to lean left even if they end up succdem or whatever) that will be underemployed and have no worth to society beyond their labor.
Basically, in the near future, a big chunk of the US' millennial generation will be these hipster types, who will be aimless and restless, better organized because of the internet, will possess better access to theory because of the internet, will have more context regarding global porky/liberal imperialism, and will just be bitter in general.
That being said, in my opinion the rampant consumerism and media consumption among these types is a huge obstacle.
I don't know if I'm being vague at all
Jordan Gutierrez
If only they didn't have the attention span that comes with only being familiar with texts that are no more than 140 characters large…