Alright Holla Forums I want a good game that can scare me, like actually scare me, not this bullshit jumpscare shit...

Try rainworld. The game itself isn't exactly a horror game but there's something really terrifying about the way the predators move and flop around and it's very scary once you're being chased.
There are also giant sea creatures but I don't even know if they're hostile or not. I never went in the water with them on screen

Explain what scares you the most first, lazyass. Body horror, splatterpunk, ghosts, skeletons?

Body horror.

What the fuck is the context of this pic anyway?

Some dudes having fun.

Ah fuck, that movie's messed up.

Make sure you use the Arx Libertatis source port, runs better than the original:
arx-libertatis.org/

wacky miner dawg

even though it doesn't really fit the game, I gotta say it's still incredibly well-done and terrifying as shit

Just go play Cry of Fear, it's free: store.steampowered.com/app/223710/Cry_of_Fear/