While I appreciate the long response, your conclusions don't really match up. The huge amount of defense of the Faith is a reaction to consistent attacks rather than a fracture point generally. There are definite shills trying to play both sides but I argue that the Christian posters are almost always responding to debunked attacks. The last paragraph you wrote is basically asking us not to defend a position that actual Christians hold very dear and that's just not going to happen, we're not a hive mind. Consensus cracking works simply because people like you are claiming that a partisan issue is non partisan, the paganposts around here are mostly driveby baiting or trolling, there's been no real definitive idea of what anyone even really means by "pagan" aside from a few nebulous concepts (honor and so forth). Frankly speaking, Holla Forums is not about religion (muslims and jews are basically weaponized cultures, hit them where it hurts: they have no real religion as westerners define it), it's about our people. Many of those people are Christian.
If a lot of what you said is true, that you're not against Christianity and instead just here for the cause then you should acknowledge and use the arguments that will actually change peoples minds within context, fake Christians are just new age types trying to push egalitarianism, as has been posted and brought up a thousand and one times, that's not the case in the Bible.
You're still in the mindset that Christianity is somehow completely at odds with our goal. That mindset has been carefully cultivated, along with the idea that church institutions are somehow completely immune to corruption, perfectly representative of Scripture, and haven't been infiltrated or subverted as well. Paganism is attractive as a rallying cry only because it is an abstraction, we're all rightfully suspicious of institutions at this juncture.
Read through some of the Christian posts explaining in depth why certain annoying new age type 'Jesus was just a nice guy' memes are wrong and regardless of whether you are Christian or not, it's a way more effective method of teaching Christians why Holla Forums is right rather than just yelling 'le kike on stick XDDDD' if you want to see a real change or court any of the large amounts of Christians in the west.
Way I see it, pagan stuff is yet another method of pushing racially aware whites to the fringe, but that is not relevant to this thread. Given that our whole culture was organized around Christian dogma until it went to shit, it presents an interesting strategic advantage as well. Anyone pushing the 'Christianity evolved postmodernism' doesn't know about WW1 and doesn't realize the exact same argument can be used to say 'pagans evolved into Christians'
Holla Forums is better than anywhere else because we arm ourselves with far more knowledge than our enemies, we fight with a massive advantage. So if you go into a religious brawl it's far better to know more than an opponent, regardless of what you're arguing. The same idea applies to pagans who are passionate about their polytheism, always know more than the people trying to water you down or force you into a postmodernist corner.