Some hot opinions coming in.
8/10
It may feel slow now, but it didn't back then. Great shit overall, graphics and scary atmosphere hold up today perfectly fine.
9/10
Still the king. Could be more scary though.
(I haven't played it without LoD though)
7/10
Very solid, true open world, shitton of content.
Didn't play the expansion.
8/10
I know you faggots like to hate it, and it was nearly unplayable on launch, but it's pretty solid with all patches, expansion and community patch. Also true open world and unique setting made it my most played game of them all.
8/10
Great shit, super atmospheric, intense and offers god-tier customization. I made Alchemist into berserker necromancer hybrid and finished the game. Could be harder though
6/10
Passable but disappointing. Shallow, atmosphere and flexibility of TL1 gone, huge empty areas, tries to be D2 too hard.
Didn't play Synergies mod, people say it fixes most of that.
4/10
Slow and boring. Could play longer than 2 hours. Cross-class system looked interesting, but I almost fell asleep from it.
But has cool setting and supposedly the most content of all these games to date.
7/10
Basically fixed TQ. Needs more polish and content. And armor variety. Yes needs more variety in general. Very solid shit right there.
6/10
Another cross-class game. Good variety but pretty bland areas and combat. Terribly slow start, but not as slow as TQ holy fuck.
2/10
Piece of shit. Has nice graphics hence 2 instead of 1. Fuck it.
5/10
Better than I expected but it ain't no diablo. More like edgier Torchlight 2. Trial didn't warrant a purchase, so I can't comment on full game or expansion. Hopefully it's better.
6/10
Diablo 2 HD marred by being free to play online game. Could be really strong if made into proper video game.
7/10
Ugly and clunky but it just werks somehow. Also shitton of content and cool animoo setting.
4/10
It doesn't werk anymore, they broke it. But at least it looks nicer and still somehow has shitton of content.
Forgettable piece of generic shit. How could they made it so with such setting and ambition is beyond me.
4/10
Great fucking setting and visuals. Turboshit gameplay and overall bugfest.
Still finished it for setting and visuals, we need more cyberpunk ARPGs.
8/10
Not MMO one.
Basically Devil May Cry on diablo 2 engine. Not even sure if it's relevant to this thread, but it's great fucking game.
2/10
Still not MMO.
They broke it. It still uses the same beautiful sprites so it's 2 instead of 1.
Game only me played/10.
Solid basis and cool visuals but no content. Buyable packs just reuse base assets for higher levels. Huge disappointment.
Really like Ys, Shining and Phantasy Star after Universe series, but those aren't really relevant, they went full on action games with hitbox combat, manual dodging and shit.
Phantasy Star Online
Phantasy Star Universe
Shadow Flare
Lodoss something on Dreamcast, but I didn't play it.