Is it wrong that I actually think a dark and gritty reboot of Sonic would be...

Dylan Moore
Dylan Moore

Is it wrong that I actually think a dark and gritty reboot of Sonic would be cool?

Jacob Morales
Jacob Morales

Yes

Daniel Fisher
Daniel Fisher

Yes.

Logan Harris
Logan Harris

It depends, would shadow be even darker and gritter than he is now?

Benjamin Lewis
Benjamin Lewis

promoting edgehoggery unironically

Surely this is shitposting or trolling.

Adrian Wilson
Adrian Wilson

They ALREADY tried it with the Shadow game, and it was a fucking msierable mess.
And by the way that Tails looks like someone wearing a fursuit.

Hunter Garcia
Hunter Garcia

Sonic SatAM fucker. That was dark and gritty. Sega doesn't make games like that, they're too busy pandering to Autism and ADHD because it makes them rich.

GOTTA GO FAST!

Dominic Bailey
Dominic Bailey

The less dark and edgy shit and more light hearted and fun the better.
Ken Penders should burn in hell for single handedly attracting autism to this game series.

Cooper Campbell
Cooper Campbell

It could work, but success is very unlikely, as previous attempts have shown.

I think it'd be easier to have a dark animated series than an actual game, but even that is unrealistic.

Easton Cox
Easton Cox

Someone needs to put Sonic on the DMC cover now.

Grayson Butler
Grayson Butler

Yes it is wrong.

Or rather I mean it could work if they made the game very good, the following would definitely appear - no doubt about that. They would also get a huge following if they made a literal furfag porn game though, so that means little

Still go fuck yourself with those pseudo-realistic graphics/designs in your OP. Current ones are fine.

Caleb Ramirez
Caleb Ramirez

They already tried it with Shadow the Hedgehog and 06, it flat-out doesn't work for this kind of series.

Aaron Perez
Aaron Perez

Better question: do you trust Sega to not fuck it up?

Xavier Turner
Xavier Turner

I think they just need another chance

Jaxson Thomas
Jaxson Thomas

Better question is, why do people want a game with a blue hedgehog that eats chili hot dogs and his wacky friends to be grim dark and edgy SO BAD.
Who are these people?

Ayden Bailey
Ayden Bailey

You know what really, REALLY would be cool?

A Sonic game with GOOD gameplay, GOOD camera work and GOOD controls.

Besides, why all has to be dark and gritty?

Daniel Martin
Daniel Martin

Sonic games aren't that good at all.
It's a character obsession you have, like pony people.

Jason Smith
Jason Smith

A
u
t
i
s
m

Charles Moore
Charles Moore

Who are these people?
They are insecure people who feel that the games that they enjoy(Sonic, Pokemon, Mario) are for children, but they(14-25+ year olds) can't be seen playing children's games. If the games become dark and edgy then they must(pro tip they won't) be mature as well. They are the people who want Pokemon games to deal with slavery, animal cruelty, have gore, drugs that you can use on yourself as well as on Pokemon and people who have sex with Pokemon.They are the I only play mature games for mature people such as myself crowd.

Liam Brown
Liam Brown

Nothing wrong with being 12 years old, OP.
Good thing it ends eventually

Austin Barnes
Austin Barnes

I can see something that's only a few shades darker like in the Sonic film. In fact, I think that would be a much better direction for the series. But a full RIP AND TEAR and QUE TE JODAN reboot would be fucking retarded.

Christopher Roberts
Christopher Roberts

penders-era comics fans

Ian Jenkins
Ian Jenkins

a dark and gritty reboot of Sonic

Charles Garcia
Charles Garcia

Can't we just have a game with good gameplay?

It can be as edgy as you want it to be, just don't fuck up the gameplay

Leo Richardson
Leo Richardson

They are insecure people who feel that the games that they enjoy(Sonic, Pokemon, Mario) are for children, but they(14-25+ year olds) can't be seen playing children's games. If the games become dark and edgy then they must(pro tip they won't) be mature as well.
I don't know, I think it works for some settings/story-lines but not for others. I'm looking at the Sailormoon and Digimon crowds, and the heavier introductions of "more mature" elements to fit their targeted demographics as time went on weren't really seen as bad things by anyone.

Ryder Perry
Ryder Perry

I just want a game with gameplay similar to the OVAs.

Ayden Collins
Ayden Collins

Okay lets start brainstorming ideas to make this ultra edgy sonic game.
Tails is acutally a teen aged boy wearing a fursuit.
Tails is very femenine and flirts with all the male charcters through the game.
Sonic is a hulking monster hedgehog created through an accident at a nuclear power plant.
Shadow is a black guy from compton who wears shadow hat and insists he's a hedgehog.
Shadow at multiple points attempts to rape other characters while screaming you went to the wrong hood nigger.
Sonic screams you gotta go fast while ripping the heads off of enemies.
Knuckles is a machine gun totting drunken lunatic.
Knuckles entire race is dead.
Playable scences where knuckles watches his entire race ripped into pieces.
Sonic gets tired of running fast mid game.
Sonic focuses on unarmed melee combat that you rip your oppnents apart in.
Doctor robotnick is a fierce animal trader who wanders the land completly nude.
Voiced by steven segal.
Him and sonic have long arguements about the duality of man
Game ends with sonic and robotnick kissing to anime style music.
Unlockable level where sonic fucks tails while what is love plays.
Player participation in this level is limited to what angle the camera stays at.

Can Holla Forums can anything else?

Jose Baker
Jose Baker

Maybe not "wrong", per se, but "autistic?" Absolutely.

Check em.

Carter Gomez
Carter Gomez

saging the best thread on Holla Forums right now.
Let me fix this for you, counter sage.

Mason Lopez
Mason Lopez

moar plz

Jaxon Green
Jaxon Green

Somebody summon the forbidden one and cleanse this cancer from the board.

John Stewart
John Stewart

OP here.

I'm not trolling. I actually think it could work as long as it was done right. As long as the gameplay is great, it being all badass and cool by being grimdark would be just icing on the cake.

I just thought it might be a good idea since a lot of Sonic fans are grown up now and some of them feel isolated by the way the new games are marketed.

It could be like the Michael Bay Transformers movies. I know some people think those movies suck, but you have to admit they are entertaining.

Nicholas Hughes
Nicholas Hughes

Can we just stop having sonic games?

Please?

The character hasn't had a good game in like 20 years. It's time to let it go.

Benjamin Reyes
Benjamin Reyes

Those pics look absolutely good awful.

Sonic racing transformed
not good
/reddit/ is that way.
I'm sure you'll get a lot of upvoats for that kind of post there.

Levi Perez
Levi Perez

It could be like the Michael Bay Transformers movies. I know some people think those movies suck, but you have to admit they are entertaining.

I hate to break it to you, but "entertaining" is not how I'd describe a cringefest.

Brody Myers
Brody Myers

I think a gritty sonic game would only work if they did it VERY well, or if the game just didn't take itself seriously.
Games like the latter are getting really old lately though.

They need to figure out how to make good games again, first, and how to write Sonic to make him not such a cliche fuck.

Connor Powell
Connor Powell

Here's the thing OP:
Even if it was perfect, the question of why was it necessary would still loom unanswered.

Angel Cook
Angel Cook

There already was a dark and gritty sonic reboot.

It was called "Sonic and the Black Knight".

Cooper Powell
Cooper Powell

I wanna see Sonic: Korean Civil War

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Confirm your age

This website may contain content of an adult nature. If you are under the age of 18, if such content offends you or if it is illegal to view such content in your community, please EXIT.

Enter Exit

About Privacy

We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners.

Accept Exit