I think you posted this believing it to be a good argument, but it really isn't. Barely moderated stations die fast, which might just be what happened to new, considering how people were complaining 2 threads ago about griefers on the station.
Comes with seeing this shit happen so many times. Hopefully you'll never have to reach that point.
Are you getting that from the low population numbers you guys get? It's a bit non-sensical though, no? And if people want old and new players alike, they have other alternatives for that that give them a much larger population.
So either you're wrong here or you'll wish you were wrong.
See, this is probably the only part that really makes me sad. You had people that have been playing since the time /tg/ was actually good. That saw Nel, Pizzastation and every iteraction between then and now.
And all of these people saw exactly what "let's start a new server!" does every single time. I'd very much like to tell you "Well this one time it worked out well, here's why:" but there's no such case in history. And there's plenty of cases where it flat out failed.
If you've been playing only since Hatestation time and you don't even remenber the previous ones, that's okay. It's not like everyone must always remenber history. But when people tell you "this is a bad idea, it was tried 4 times before and never worked", instead of thinking you know better than them, maybe trust the veterans a bit here.
You know why history repeats itself? Because people refuse to learn from the past.
Before the change to Ministation and the code revert to /tg/ base, we actually had decent numbers. Are you honestly surprised that people don't concern themselves as much with advertising when they already have great numbers?
Your "rival" server isn't special. It's just another in a long line of attemps to change things with the only result being in reduce players in both servers. Advertisizing and "this kind of talk" don't come as an answer to a "rival server" but rather to the crap that happens because of it.
It's always some perceived problem with the administration that starts the cycle with people demanding less or different moderation, than someone starts a new server because "this time things will be different!", finds it's too much work or doesn't post enough mods and grief kills it fast. Or people get tired of a split userbase and go back to Hippy. Then either the rival server either keels over and dies or merges so administration can have the new voices assisting the previous ones.
And then someone finds something to shitpost about again, and the cycle starts all over again and it never fucking ends because some people have more fun shitposting about the game than actually playing it. And this is expected in Holla Forums, because this is a shithole where nobody likes anything, but what's not supposed to happen is for some dumb nigger to consistently believe in everything the shitposters say or to start a thread for that kind of people and then wondering why they aren't playing in your server.
You get the community you deserve and pander to. You made a server for everyone shitposting about Hatestation, that's precisely that kind of players you'll get not playing on your server. Have fun, see you next cycle.