What if we make a /debateleftypol/ board so we aren't swimming in Holla Forums bait all the time?

What if we make a /debateleftypol/ board so we aren't swimming in Holla Forums bait all the time?

Other urls found in this thread:

reddit.com/r/DebateFascism/
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magical_thinking
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

can't debate fascists

but who would want to go there?

Nobody would go there, and this isn't reddit.

It's an excuse to move Holla Forums bait off the board without triggering FREEZE PEACH

no shit faggot

...

If you can't debate fascist, then why do you think you'd win a debate?

fuck off you know the mods get triggered at the thought of deleting literally anything

One could say you want to de-bait leftypol

They auto-sage threads all the time. Too much imo.

If you want your safe-space, go to reddit.

Just ban the Holla Forumsyps and delete their threads and posts.

It doesn't matter what you create.

You have the false idea that pol wants to reach a conclusion or learn or have a disscussion.

Pol doesn't want logic. Pol want to pass propaganda to as greater a crowd as possible. And since most people are here, why would they go to a "specialized" board?

Because the mods move the threads over there.

Ooooooh!
You mean the mods will actually care?
WOW! WHAT A UTOPIA!

...

Because we're just going to fuck that board up too.

'we' didn't have anything. The fist I heard of any of this was from today's constant masturbatory display by you bunch of chuclefucks vicariously finding your pathetic triumphs on random youtube chats.

Holla Forums thinks that we were trying to destroy their little civlization so i dont think they would leave us aloneso easily

It won't help. Holla Forums doesn't want debate. They think they're fighting a culture war to death by shitposting.

...

reddit.com/r/DebateFascism/

it's that easy, user.

Also half the people here are former Holla Forumstards in transition. They must have been convinced somehow.

'S simple. They had mainstream opinions. They found out about Holla Forums. They found underground opinions and took 'em. Then they found this board with even less known opinions that just scratch all of those "i wanna be special" itches. So they move here.

A designated thread would be better, as it would keep our posts per hour up while the flames rise hot there. Seriously, all this fleeing towards our respective sectarian circlejerks like /anarcho/ and /marx/ does nothing but divide us and keep us from reaching the top.
And if anyone doesn't want to participate, he could simply hide the thread.
Another dead board would be useless. Segregating content in different threads would be a better idea. It worked well for the elections.

You actually believe this? I have people post zizek on normie book, but nothing from Rushton or anything that would influence a more well read pollack. Tim Wise, the invicible knapsack, some faggoty zapatista fanboy page, some socialist qoute etc show up on my kikebook feed all the time. Can you even name a right-wing author?

Buchanan?
Evola?
Sowell?
Rothbard?
Rand?

You forgot Carlyle and Spengler.

read that as DoubleFascism

Well, we are. At least I am.


Do Holla Forumsyps even sympathize with Rand and Rothbard? Last time I brought her up, they called them jews. Even Sowell gets shit on.

Well.. yea. Thats what Im getting at though, insofar that we are in fact trying to destroy them, their nazi fantasies kind of get proven correct. Which has me worried, not too much but a little, I mean from my personal perspective I am seeing too many allies turn apathetic towards the cause and, again from what I am able to see with my own two eyes, it really does kind of seem like the numbers of people leaning towards these nazis are kind of swelling a lot lately.

Their whole movement is based on vague feelings, cultural assumptions and stereotypes. As culture changes, their ideology either adapts or dies out. And even adaptation will mean that the ideology can't be taken as seriously, as part of it has been proven wrong already in the past.
Their ideology will not last. Important to note that the feelings will last, which is what we need to direct at the right targets, aka educate people.

You pinkos realize we're kicking your ass right now don't you?

If you go to India and make an ideology out of shitting in the street, the fact that people are shitting in the street is not proof of your ideology's persuasiveness and wide reach.

You're not kicking anyone's ass. You are identifying with forces beyond your control and feeling proud when they do things that you had nothing to do with. You are fundamentally retarded.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magical_thinking

You seriously think they are gonna use it as intended?
They are too stupid for that.

You mean you can't win a debate with fascists, dumbass.

...

...

I see a lot of Hoppe fellating on BourgieBook in right-wing posts/

I see the utterly cringeworthy "Declasscucking memes for commie proles" page shared on Facebook constantly. Holla Forums beliefs are the kind of low-grade edgy you can safely espouse in public so you can get social credit for being edgy. The Uncanny Valley of cancer.

^^^^^^

thx for the advice, Holla Forums.

terrible idea
nobody would go and Holla Forums would come here anyway.

but then we could start using that as our real board and use this as our debate board.

great idea except that it would require Holla Forums mods to enforce it, and they get paid to let shills and trolls fuck up our board.

move to bunkerchan or create /leftyleftypol/

top fucking kek, who's funding this exactly? The FBI? The CIA? How far does this shit go?

>>>/leddit/ is that way, loser

Reddit-tier
Also cleaning this board out of any "bait" completely fucks up the userbase, see 8/pol/

Yes, if not for Holla Forums then there would be a unanimous consensus between the anarchists and Marxists and the Marxist-Leninists and leftcoms and Leninists and market socialists and libertarian Marxists and syndicalists and mutualists and egoists and post-leftists and nihilists and….

Yep, all these ideologies totally agree with each other all the time. Would be an echo chamber in no time without the daily "Africans aren't humans because of IQ xDDD" threads from our friends over at Holla Forums

idk, i think CIA is busy printing extremist jihad textbooks and giving arms to mujahideen.
NSA and GCHQ are known to shill but it might as well be some random nationalist organization backed by the porkies.
but they'd need some brains, for the agencies it's easier to do blackmailing and social engineering because they can just look up everything they need to know in xkeyscore.

I really need to know how many people on Holla Forums have actual autism, because the amount of people on this board who will respond seriously to the most ironic and condescending shit is just astounding.

But let me put it in as plain English as I can: It's utterly laughable to suggest that the fucking US government, with all the shit it has to deal with, is seriously going to waste any time or even be aware of an irrelevant board on an irrelevant imageboard that can't even manage to keep an online magazine going or start up a student union. But the fact that there are people on Holla Forums who actually think this is pretty funny.

heh, nice.
you should also look into en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
it's an important concept which sadly is not very well known yet.
people need a place where they can relax with friends and not be pestered by anyone.

there are plenty of boards where all kinds of people and shills are allowed, there should be one where we can be constructive without some outside cancerfags ruining everything.

There would be a consensus that the proletariat should rise up and seize the means of production, at least.

see

Which is pretty fucking meaningless considering the vast differences in how the aforementioned ideologies would go about accomplishing something like that.

And really, it would just mean that the board would be able to have a semblance of a sane conversation that is relevant to the topic of the board, instead of playing debate club day in and day out over topics that are almost universally disproven by science, and pretty much any other academic discipline you can name that has any relevance to the shit that Holla Forums never shuts up about.

Basically this tbh


Doesn't disprove my point. There is quite literally no reason whatsoever for the FBI to be concerned with this board. It isn't even slightly a threat to the powers that be.

and why do you think that is?

so enlighten me, who is spamming Holla Forums then and why do the mods allow it?

Because as stated previously, and as is the case with all imageboards, it's nigh impossible to organize anything on Holla Forums.

I would assume that Holla Forums is spamming Holla Forums, and that the mods aren't doing anything about it because the mods are either lazy or apathetic, or even more likely because they - like most of the people on Holla Forums - have fallen for the free speech meme and think that Holla Forums has a right to shitpost here. They probably also think that us debating with Holla Forums over whether or not Africans are humans will somehow be useful for leftism or will somehow "convert" people over to our side.

I mean it's not that fucking hard to comprehend if you drop your internalized Holla Forums memes about shills.

Because they are lazy shits who never delete the threads since nobody bothers to report them.

wrong. i regularly see Holla Forums posts disappear.
but shill threads remain.
unless it's an elaborate false flag and the trolls delete their own posts to give the impression that our mods are evil.

ah, more Holla Forums memes

Fucking cash out your statement, please. Because I have no idea what the fuck you're talking about and I post here pretty regularly.

memes are hell of a drug

hold on, i'll summon them

sorry, i think i just summoned a DDoS attack.

Hey, I don't disagree with you about banning Holla Forums b8, I was just being snarky. I'd be fine with people coming in here to debate the merits of fascism versus socialism or whatever if they had even the slightest bit of respect for empirical method or understood the positions they were arguing against.

As it stands, allowing Holla Forums garbage in will just result in us shouting stupid memes at each other because their ideas are not worth engaging with critically (I should know, I've done it countless times to no good effect). Also because they cannot survive in the critical arena, so Holla Forums pushes ideology by lowering discourse to the level of stupid memes, which are excellent containers for reactionary thought. When it's just memes going back and forth, reactionary messages about the idealized past and emotionally charged representations of demonized others flourish, whereas criticism of capitalism is reduced to a caricaturic form where it can be trivially refuted. Hence why so few of them are familiar with even the most basic tenets of socialism. In this way, like with newspeak, the medium of communication prevents dissent by making it impossible to clearly express a dissenting message. I mean, you could still make a reasoned long-form empirically-based post but it's likely to be saged and cuckspammed into oblivion for going against predominant groupthink.

In this way Holla Forums is similar to SJW cancer that took over the rest of the internet a while back, except with far more insidious method of suppressing politically incorrect positions.

On the other hand, outright banning an entire class of beliefs is going to result in them going underground and becoming subtle, so if your intent is to ban Holla Forums altogether that can easily result in a kulak hunt/purge with devastating consequences for the board's health. I think it would be far easier to simply mandate a certain standard of quality for posting and thus eliminate the worst excesses of Holla Forums influence.

Without strawmen, sweeping generalizations or unsourced assertions, they are entirely toothless.

thats what >>>/liberty/, >>>/turdpositionist/ and and i think >>>/politics/ were for

why can't we just debate here? in this comfy little designated thread? I can be yuor fasces, or yuor ancap