TOR:Allow Tor relays to be configured to block selected hidden services, including racist hate sites

trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/23270

Other urls found in this thread:

blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-project-defends-human-rights-racists-oppose
trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/23270?action=diff&version=13
twitter.com/torproject/status/898256109789687808
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

What? Isn't the whole point that it circumvents censorship?

Cool but
> #23270 closed enhancement (invalid)
Its dead who cares

why did they make the empty tweet saying they dont like daily stormer if they wont do anything about it?

lel soon (((major))) tor relays will be configured with a blacklist, defeating it's own purpose in the name of anti-fascism

And of course these golem are going for other service as well, but ipfs is still technically unpozzed.

I just saw there's already a Tor thread and the issue was already posted there
Nvm then.

the problem with IPFS is it's like torents, the swarm can see your IP. Have fun hosting all content you ever access.

we already have a tor thread where this was posted. delete this


it is called virtue signalling

There are chemical weapons like agent orange, biological weapons like ebola, mass destruction weapons like atomic bomb and there's social destruction weapon social justice/marxism/politically correct.

Yeah, I hate when someone says the word "knife" and I get cut. We have no capacity of judging an idea, as soon we hear someone saying to kill person or group A we have to go and do exactly that. Also, "literally", they love this word.

And you are the only one capable of saying what is good, right?

It's not censorship to refuse to publish hate.
Isn't that hate? It's like saying "I hate this content because it spreads hate and I hate hate".

Because they got hundreds of emails from the media asking for a comment about Daily Stormer moving to a .onion.

In the full blog post, they defending their stance of not controlling/censoring who uses their software.

blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-project-defends-human-rights-racists-oppose

OP of that ticket looks like a concern troll

The OP uses the term 'virtue signaling' in another comment, so it's likely a concern troll. He probably just wanted a discussion to see what Tor Project would say.

'virtue signaling' is originally a lefty term.

So was 'social justice warrior', initially.

Reminder that Racism is now officially a bigger crime than child fuckers.

It's true though, what is really going on is companies kicking people for hyped up mass hysteria, we should be mad at those companies instead for censoring since that website has been online for a hell lot longer and nobody seemed to care but until recently mass hysteria is taking over the web and trying to take down lots of stuff.

why did tor project tweet against DS, then do absolutely nothing about it?

shouldn't the tolerant left criticize tor for this?

because that is censorship and not possible

...

On the Tor network yes, The Tor project can't censor hidden services.
There is also no way to block a hidden service even if they wanted it would destroy the project reputation.

Reminds me of the Gnusocial blacklist.
Tor will kill itself by doing this.
I just love the shit excuse.
NO tor is a Tool and if you begin to act like all those DRM fuckers then you are no better than proprietary software.
So now you're going to censor pedo/drug/assassins/bad shit ?
==WEW== totally not biased opinion
The problem with this genre of sentence is when they can't differentiate good from bad or compromise.
Holla Forums on the list when ?

Anyway this wouldn't have happened with gnunet.

of course it can, just make every node refuse to publish help people reach the ds .onion address.
it's not a 100% solution because a small number of nodes might hack it to not block DS. but it makes it much much harder for anyone to access that site through tor.

You can't outright block a service on Tor. What you can do is DDoS it, which means you'll be attacking every node in the circuit as well (everyone between the attacker and the victim). Of course they could modify Tor to allow blocking White pride, but doing so would result in a fork, divide the community in two and many people would move to Freenet/i2p/etc. So even if they want to they won't.

Yeah, that's why the devs have repeatably said they won't be adding a way to censor or control who uses their software.

Again you can't get everyone on that which a dev states in the ticket somewhere.

There is onionbalance to balance the website and you can still fight ddos attacks.
It is usually shitty services hosted on vps that go down.

Yeah I know

Why do you dumb niggers never bother to read shit? This isn't happening and the comments on that page explain exactly why it can't happen. Kill yourself.

TOR is really going to shit really quickly.

The newest update on orfox (tor for android) auto-completes stuff in the search bar - this with search suggestions turned off in the settings.

The type of people who say shit like that amaze me. You have to be one self righteous ignorant fuck to tread out an argument like "my speech should be more free than yours because I think my speech is better."

bait has fuck

I think meant that surgical censorship of particular Tor sites is impossible, and your only other option is to attempt to block the whole Tor network.

See? This is how jews overtake all projects. SJWs are tool used by jews to achieve their jewish goals. They overtook Mozilla/Firefox long time ago too.

We won't solve the problem by starting a new project or a fork, because the jews will overtake it again.
We need solution to solve basic problem - the jews. We need The Final Solution.

t. crazy guy

I also hate Jews. If only there were places that we could send them in order to keep them from corrupting everything. Perhaps we could even let them work and even give them showers after they work for cleansing purposes.

Just make sure that we have proper sanitation and quarantine measures. The last thing we need is an outbreak of Typhus.

Aaaand here's how you kill a cool project. Somehow that reminds me of how PC became video game consoles, consoles became PCs, phones became PDAs, and your standard printer can now toast and fold your shirt.


It's like that stupid question: "should one tolerate intolerance?" Disregard the whole ideas that laws are the most intolerant things possible. All in all, tolerance is nothing more than "letting it happen"; Semantic apart, it's not their duty to be the arbiters of what is acceptable and what is not, I despise every fucking company going that direction, even if it's in agreement with what I currently hold for true.


This. And checked too.

Back to Holla Forums, dumb niggers. it is impossible to block hidden services in network by design.

Then shut it down

The tweet, which has been misinterpreted by hordes of idiots who can't read, can be read as, "We find the speech reprehensible, but we can't and we won't censor it."

Then the design needs to be changed.

Please include this url as blocked in the default configuration so that routers will not broadcast it.
Thank you now add this porn site i dont like
HEY I HEARD YOU WERE BLOCKING BAD WEBSITES!! Here is my list of illegal download sites. best wishes Sony
Well if you ban those here are a few that sell gun parts. >oh wait that already happened
Hey this guy said faggot once here is his sight ban it immediately please!
This website sells stuffed animals and their best seller is a frog please ban this hate symbol.

Hey guys this tor shit is gay there are literally no websites to even visit. OMG SMH FAM

That doesn't make TOR go away. It will just be forked. Are you fucking retarded?

Oy vey! You aren't going to run a relay running the NAZI version, are you goy? There's literal NAZIS using it to spread hate speech! Surely you wouldn't want to help them do that and have your host and domain registrar drop your ass do you, goy? I mean, are you a NAZI?

They are not

probably because its been government (alphabet agencies) controlled for at least the last five years, or more.

#23270 closed enhancement (invalid) Opened 3 days ago Closed 3 days ago Last modified 6 hours agoAllow Tor relays to be configured to block selected hidden services, including racist hate sitesReported by: cypherpunks Owned by: Priority: Medium Milestone: Tor: unspecifiedComponent: Core Tor/Tor Version: Severity: Normal Keywords: racism, hate, anti-fascism, probably-bad-idea, slippery-slope,Cc: Actual Points: Parent ID: Points: Reviewer: Sponsor:

You're a fucking idiot that doesn't know how anything works. Go back to Holla Forums you tech illiterate faggot.

not a thing at all.

trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/23270?action=diff&version=13

why did he censor the DS link?

so shouldn't tor project retract that tweet if they completely refuse to actually DO ANYTHING about the daily stormer?

Not even newsworthy

>It's not censorship to refuse to publish hate. Tor project opposes the daily stormer, please see here >​twitter.com/torproject/status/898256109789687808
what an insufferable faggot. he might be trolling, but i've come across people who are seriously like this a few times long before "SJW" was a thing, and ohhh boyy. it's basically an autistic nerd combined with some "muh racism".

some shitty website full of dynamic content or on some "web engine" will fall over long before anything in the tor circuit. all this discussion on this board about DDoS is retarded really; most sites can be DoS'd through a single connection. it's been like that for over 15 years and it's not going to change any time soon.

Probably not trolling. People get high on being holier than thou and it's so easy to get a fix these days.

user, SJW was a thing since at least chairman Mao. It's only the term that has been popularized recently, the faggotry described by it has been spreading much longer.

As I understand it, Tor isn't capable of implementing this feature.

??????

...

so, the 20th century? Got an example?

they could make a builtin list of blacklisted sites that exit nodes block by default. or better yet go full firecox and make exit nodes fetch some list from Google every 24 hours for (((security))) purposes such as blocking malware/phishing sites. they could, like firecox, just keep adding new bullshit features until it's too much of a pain in the ass to strip down into something useful and not obviously backdoored

and yes I was referring to just the term "SJW"