What's with all these right-wing "alternate history" shows?

what's with all these right-wing "alternate history" shows?
are the liberals in hollywood finally showing their true colors?

Man in the high castle is old as shit mate.

and? how come there are no TV shows on "Utopia" or "Island"?

Don't they all have them be evil basically?
Also Man in the High Castle is a very shitty comparison

How is The Man in the High Castle "right-wing" alternate history? It's based on a 1962 novel by Philip K. Dick. Just because it features Nazis doesn't mean it's "right-wing", you complete dunce.

Are you retarded?

It's basically wheraboo porn. And yes, I've watched both seasons. The 'Nazi boomers' being a mirror of the OT hippie boomers was a nice touch.

The confederacy would have collapsed pretty quickly though. There was a reason why American abandoned the articles of confederation and opted for the federalist model.

Have you ever considered maybe if the Nazis did win, we'd see a world like this? Of course, that doesn't make it all right, but saying a show must be right wing because it's showing an alternate history as how it would accurately be is ridiculous. If Hitler won, the Germans were not going to be oppressed. Hitler didn't hate his own people, Stalin did

Nice nationalism you got there.

tell that to the millions of pure-blooded aryans who died in hitler's pointless war because he was still buttmad about art school.

Because they present the view that a different and better world is possible rather than TMITHT for example where the different world is a horrific Nazi hellhole.

This, nationalism would be a disaster if the people were ONLY racially pure - they need to be ideologically pure as well. "Traitors" are the biggest enemy to any ethno-nationalist.

Because entertainment and stories reflect struggles we feel in our own life. Showing a pretty picture about a futuristic world where everything is perfect gives us nothing to relate to.

Litterally what the fuck are you on. You must be an absolute moron to see this as "saying its positive".
It might be a shock to an american like you, but the nazi's weren't litteral demons to their own population. Not portraying nazis as baby eating devils doesn't make it apologetic, it makes it realistic.

I don't want a realistic portrayal of Nazis, humanizing the extreme right is the first step towards acceptance of their ideology in public discourse.

Meanwhile we get Bitter Harvest, where them evil commie sociopaths starved billions of Ukrainians for no reason at all.

Stauffenberg should have succeeded

I don't want a realistic portrayal of commies, humanizing the extreme left is the first step towards acceptance of their ideology in public discourse.

The word is relatable.
They show them relatable, not good.

It's just to make the show interesting. Who the fuck would watch it if it were just more 50's tier propaganda?
It just doesn't cut it


No, their scientific research has
Just like with capitalist or communist nations

But the entire message of TMITHC is that a better world is possible (in the book, anyway).

I would imagine that porky would have picked such nuances out from the tv adaptation though.

they probably would have a new federal government installed if they successfully seceded. The Confederacy was probably more of a temporary coalition.

It seems like that's what ends up happening, yeah. Porky picks out anything that isn't pro-liberal Best of All Possible Worlds bullshit

the man in the high castle. But nazbol

no.

It is to conceal the true nature of bourgeois society by showing how bad it "could" be, rather than showing how bad it currently is.

...

If that had happened, there's a good chance the Allies would have been happy to rearm Germany and set them against the USSR in 1945, so no

This, it's bread and circuses in swastikas, served up with a side order of smug liberalism.
I quit paying for most forms of what passes for "entertainment" about 15 years ago, and I don't regret the decision at all.

Considering that's precisely what they did with West Germany and the Wherma- oops, I meant the Bundeswher, I'd say that's a pretty good guess.

then fuck off

Wow. You're incredibly lame, I'm very happy you aren't in control if TV. Sincerely hope all your channels are replaced with incredibly factual history channel episodes.