Honestly, how do you respond criticism of Communism? This is a solid video (just wait past the introduction)...

youtube.com/watch?v=UJzBo-LUBAw

Honestly, how do you respond criticism of Communism? This is a solid video (just wait past the introduction). He seemed to cover everything in it.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/sxg3G-G1YLs
ricardo.ecn.wfu.edu/~cottrell/socialism_book/calculation_debate.pdf
eastsidemarxism.wordpress.com/economic-calculation-problem/
youtube.com/watch?v=jbsoNMo3f2E
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

Dear god one second in and I switched off already what it with ancaps and tween edginess it's Mr Dapperton all over again

yeah they're basically recreations of Coldsteel the Hedgeheg, but the guy who's talking in the video isn't the host channel, it's a guest video. Wait past the introduction.

please call an ambulance the edge has me severely bleeding

wtf I'm an ancap now

I blame anarchyball for this.

𝚋𝚊𝚜𝚒𝚌 𝚎𝚌𝚘𝚗𝚘𝚖𝚒𝚌𝚜

Birds of a feather flock together. If the channel is edgy sanic OC tier garbage, it's safe to say that the people they invite will likely be of similar quality. Unless you can summarize the claims in your own words and argue them on your own merits, you shouldn't expect anyone to actually watch it.

vid related, about the only thing I can think of that tops the edge of this video.

...

Hey, the dude isn't a total retard. He has some substance.

I don't mean this as an attack against you, btw OP, I mean most people aren't going to view beyond the first couple minutes unless you can summarize.

I really hate this idea of "You can't hold me accountable for what I say! Free speech!".

Then why didn't you post the original video but instead linked the channel of this moron?

I'm pretty sure it's a guest video, I checked his channel and that video wasn't there. He has a lot of scattered videos tho about Marxism.

youtu.be/sxg3G-G1YLs

Here is the original video. Guy isn't a retard, but he rides Mises' dick really hard and makes the same fallacies.

No it is I posted it

not the full video tho

The 2nd is about class theory which can also be found on the other ones channel.

However I find the video about the ECP more relevant for us because honestly it's not really hard to defend class theory, but to debunk the ECP requires some effort.

yea op imma click right away

yeah I doubt it. someone summarize his points

not all the points of course, but these stuck out:

Also the economic calculation problem

oh i'm laffing at the delusional self-importance

Shouldn't an economist be aware of the great railroad bubble?

Yeah, I forgot about that beacuse weirdly it was at the start of the video
response: read Cockshott ricardo.ecn.wfu.edu/~cottrell/socialism_book/calculation_debate.pdf

The person literally gets shit wrong 1:12 in, lmfao, is this the best they got?

rofl

so literally everything already said a million times by every other non marxist in the last century

I had to close the tab out of embarrassment, but if is true, then he vid from OP regurgitated same fucking argument that have been replied decades ago
(You)

How to debunk anti-communism according to leftypol:

I have no idea what this is supposed to mean
yes it fucking does jesus christ.
Are there any original ancap/libertarian arguments left? I think we've seen them all.

see

i didn't click on it though, i'm not debunking anything.

...

Dude, all the guy says is muh Economic Calculation Problem from that old Mises pamphlet which has been adressed a hundred times.

Basically read this:

eastsidemarxism.wordpress.com/economic-calculation-problem/

Or watch this video:

youtube.com/watch?v=jbsoNMo3f2E

Most arguments I've seen made by libertarians are only proof that they only do partial readings then drop the topic altogether to claim that he was wrong. Examples:


The value of labour itself is the value of the commodities necessary for his maintenance as a worker and for the continuation of the workers. You haven't really read Marx, I believe?

I am definitely not the most well red person on Holla Forums but even I can tell you that Marx explains in detail why labor is able to add value to a commodity in Capital Vol 1.
The LTV wasn't even invented by Marx to begin with, Classical liberals like Adam Smith also argued that labor has value and adds value to commodity production.
You would know that if you were literate.

...

Thumbed down and moved on

Yeah sorry I forgot I'm obligated to write a fifty page essay to debunk this edgelord's 30 minute vid, as if these points have been iterated over for the millionth time already. He literally just parrots Mises critiques of Marx, which has been discussed to heaven and back again