Why dont you guys just set up you own commune where you can operate society how you please instead of trying to tear...

Why dont you guys just set up you own commune where you can operate society how you please instead of trying to tear down the current one?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism_in_One_Country
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Because when it grows too large and powerful, capitalists and their goons (you) will destroy it.

But if you're living peacefully and doing your own thing why would I or other capitalists want to destroy it? Surely if your commie paradise is so great people would flock to it?

...

What?

Everyone knows what you did to Michelle, Patton.

I dunno, you tell me.

We still need outside resources, and how are we gonna get them? We will have to buy them. How will we get the money? We would have to exploit the workers, in which case we are no different from a petty social democracy. A communist society cannot exist within a global capitalist economy, which is part of the reason previous socialist attempts failed. (obviously there were other factors as well)

A communist society can not exist separate from historical progress either, it has to be reached through a transformation of capitalist society.

It's a spam bot.


Don't be so obtuse. We all know what would happen. Porky would tear it to bits.
You just have to look at Romani travellers to see what would happen. Even if they own their own land, they're denied use of it on some technicality.

Funny that you draw forward the Paris commune as an example, as it was destroyed by outside forces as soon as they had the chance.

Sorry broski, it's gotta be proletarian internationalism for everyone.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism_in_One_Country

Because proving communism works would actually be making progress. ACTUALLY doing anything to help destroy capitalism is what the communist hates most.

because doing things to help destroy capitalism is so easy, right? it's not like there's any resistance or anything. communists are just lazy, right?

you've never been homeless, lived with a bunch of NON-junkie punk kids in an abandoned squat have you
obtuse, as in a larger angle that takes in more area initially and focuses its into a single point?

I'm sorry people, the way you guys go about heatedly supporting political "Communism", of any sort or fashion, instead of Communalism is going to get you and a lot of other people destroyed in the end. It is you who is being acute, and narrowing your mentality to the words of an individual or individual group and focusing that down into one ridiculously sheepish point. I'm not against new ways of thought, but I believe you should begin to define these things for yourself. From what /leftpol/ and "full" (of dumbery) chan have shown me lately, you people are completely ignorant that allowing any of your current leaders to move your current regime to "Communism" is only giving in to Their PERSONAL agenda and Globalization of that agenda. You should watch where your mind is led.

They will argue that it is too small, only people who like the idea engage in that, once it grows big it will turn into hellish USSR 2.0 remember the six million who died in Holodomor

wow really made me think

...

The other side around. The fact of capitalist mode of production pushing the globalisation and tearing borders down is why left-wingers talk about world socialist revolution, as nothing else will be able to eliminate capitalism and claim permanent victory.

It will be much worse than Capitalism, considering there is a small chance you can actually make it work for you with Capitalsim. With most sorts of Communism, you are giving yourself blindly to individuals. Anarcho Communism may be a bit different, but Anarchism should remain a philosophy and not taken into a political realm. There is no philosophy or political "theory" that describes what I think you may feel…maybe you should work together to create one. A fresh idea would be nice

Things like Agragarian reform (which may be useful now even), those sorts of things will be GOVERNMENT controlled…not controlled by YOU.

...

Because it would threaten your profits, resources and power. It's why the US sperged out after Castro came to power. No more exploitation.

all things I hope you enjoy…primarily Sub Commandante Marcos' stint

I didn't say that…that was someone else. I'm not a chan user, but I'm starting to dig it.

Got any other brilliant suggestions?

eh, World Peace, yeah, I get it and that would be great. But don't be a try hard or you're going to start a revolution too soon and get millions nuked in the false flag of "war" (the truth is still depopulation, that's what "they" want).

enough of my rant, no one cares to retort negatively or positively, but this is the advice of an older Anarcho punk from years before. All these ideas are burnt out wastes, as are those of Holla Forums most of the time.