Group of Progressives Write Letter To Democrats Demanding They Take Trump's Amnesty

Jose Perry
Jose Perry

Democrats should quickly grab President Donald Trump’s amnesty-and-immigration offer before the next election, says a group of progressives cited in a New York Times op-ed article.

Columnist Thomas Edsall quoted emails from his various progressive friends, most of which tacitly recognize that Trump has public opinion on his side in the overall immigration debate.

Nolan McCarty, a political scientist at Princeton, explained: "Blocking it would allow the Trump Administration to suggest that the Democrats were willing to trade Dreamers for “lottery” and “chain” migration, as well as position them as soft on border security."

Robert L. Borosage, president of the left-liberal Institute for America’s Future, argued that Democrats should make every effort to get the immigration issue off center stage. “In my view,” Borosage said in an email, “Trump wins as long as we’re arguing about this. So it would be good to get this done soon.”

McCarty recommended accepting the deal for temporary advantage, and then immediately violating the deal when they recover the White House. Democrats could chop enforcement funding and raise the annual inflow when they get back in power.

Edsall also noted that the amnesty proposal in Trump’s four-part amnesty-and-immigration framework offer may be very unpopular with the GOP base that provided Trump’s presidential victory in 2016.

archive.is/YPOBI

Tyler Lewis
Tyler Lewis

Shills will say otherwise, but it's a good deal. I trust Trump, he wouldn't have offered it if he didn't think so.

Henry Cruz
Henry Cruz

immediately violating the deal when they recover the White House
That’s why Trump wants the border funding put in a trust, he knows these kikes lie about everything and they’ll re-open the floodgates for the beaners the microsecond the have the power to do so. It’s sickening how the Democrats jerk off so hard over brown people.

Julian Wright
Julian Wright

Anyone who doesn't want 1.8m spics to become US citizens is a shill.
I hope you burn in hell.

Jace Moore
Jace Moore

After the 2030 we will be able to end chain migration and that's 600,000 people a year. By 2033 we'll offset all 1.8 million of the dreamers and everything afterwards will be a net gain.

Liam Williams
Liam Williams

NO AMNESTY
Kill yourself

Justin Richardson
Justin Richardson

1.8m
no more than 5% would last long enough to actually get in, there are a lot of hoops to jump through

Jaxon Torres
Jaxon Torres

The federal government DOES NOT deport illegals even though the laws tells them to. They haven't done so in decades. MORE LAWS ON THE BOOKS SAYING THE SAME THING WON'T CHANGE ANYTHING! Get it through your thick skull you fucking simpleton.

Robert Adams
Robert Adams

WAHHHH I'M NOT A SHILL I JUST POST INSULTS AND CAN'T FORM AN ARGUMENT.
Brock is a cheapskate so I know he's not paying you overtime. Do you do it for free?

Josiah Moore
Josiah Moore

Assuming the next poz prez won't just rescind and you're stuck with that 1.8mil
gg no re

Isaiah Ortiz
Isaiah Ortiz

no more than 5%
Even assuming that the federal government would try and deport every single dreamer spic that violates their term of stay (they won't), over 25% of them are in California, which will shield them in every way possible. The democrats, liberals and kikes who control most of this countries bureaucracy are more determined to keep these spics than conservatives are to get them out of America.

In short, ICE would really have their work cut out for them, even disregarding the possibility that the (((9th circuit))) would hogtie this law in the courts for years.

Asher Rogers
Asher Rogers

Why don't you take them into your house if you love them so much, yid-boy,

William Brooks
William Brooks

HAHA Trump is a stable genius Democraps will never accept this deal!
BREAKING: "This just in, Democrats have accepted Trump's amnesty deal."
4…4D c..chess?

Andrew Nelson
Andrew Nelson

we've got a month to see. They've got until March 5th, and will likely bring it down to the wire before making an official decision.

Easton Nguyen
Easton Nguyen

Of course they'll accept it. It's a great deal for them. They're just holding out for a better deal, but this one will do just fine.

Alexander Campbell
Alexander Campbell

No, it's a terrible deal for White America. It is an absolute kill shot and this is all theater to sucker in Whites before the hammer drops on them. The Democrats kick up the biggest stink in the world, oh it's awful, it's horrible, we can never accept it! Trump gets portrayed as super reasonable and the Democrats give in and accept it.

The end result is millions of amnestied spics on top of the already completely destroyed demographics of White America. There is no possible way to fix the demographic avalanche coming without active removal of all illegals and retroactive revocation of citizenship from anchor babies and their descendants. That is only thing that can fix the demographics.

What is being set up is a giant make work program for the wall which in 10-15 years time will act as a Berlin Wall moment for the brown inheriting population.

Michael Fisher
Michael Fisher

He offered it because he knew they would never take it.

Now the Kikes are faced with a choice on this:
A) Tell the Dems to accept the deal, satisfy their current base, but lose access to unlimited spics via Chain Migration for an estimated 1.8 million spics, 12 years from now.

B) Tell Dems not to accept the deal so they can keep Chain Migration and continue to get unlimited spics, but piss off their base and lose Amnesty for DACA recipients.

Either way the Kikes lose one way or another.

Even if they don't agree to the deal, we'll still get the wall, and end to the visa lottery, and chain migration another way. DACA is expiring in a few days, too. This puts Dems and their kike masters in a tough spot, where literally every option fucks them over.

And shills here will stomp their feet and scream that "DRUMPF IS CUCKING OUT ON AMNESTY!!!!! DON'T VOTE FOR HIM AGAIN!!!!!!" like they think we're as stupid as they are.

Nathaniel Adams
Nathaniel Adams

You seem completely oblivious as to how bad the demographics ALREADY ARE. We need to physically remove people, not just slow it down.

Chase Scott
Chase Scott

They absolutely will take it. Feel free to screen cap your post and this one together.

Jeremiah Perry
Jeremiah Perry

He offered it because he knew they would never take it.
Prepare to be disappointed.

Nathan Robinson
Nathan Robinson

You're missing the real takeaway here. A professive group wants to take the deal before the next election. This means that the progressives are scared of the midterms. The opposing party almost always sees gains during the midterms. It's basically a meme at this point. One that the MSM would normally be shilling by now, trying to get everyone to expect that outcome so it becomes more likely. But they're not doing this, they're in damage control mode already and it hasn't even happened yet.

This is good.

Isaac Smith
Isaac Smith

The deal on the table makes them citizens, supposedly, after 12 years. Now, that will never stick in the courts and neither will any of the other restrictions, but it will most certainly not grant them citizenship in time for the midterm elections.

They want the deal because they already know the real demographics. They have all the time in the world and want the amnesty. They will undo everything else he's done in a few years and knock down his wall if they don't manage to hold it up until he's out.

Jason Anderson
Jason Anderson

Regardless of what Trump or the libshits may have in mind with this deal. It's almost an absolute certainty that without a physical wall / e-verify / immediate deportations Democrats will absolutely flake on their end of the deal.

There is no way they will hold up their end of any bargain once they are back in any form of power

Jeremiah Lee
Jeremiah Lee

There is no way they will hold up their end of any bargain once they are back in any form of power
Correct. Once you understand the two-party theater and the long-term goals of zionist capital, Trump's positions and proposals make a ton of sense. White America is basically used up after the last 20 years. Half-nigged, doped up, marrying with Asiatics and happily working for the kikes, and everybody who isn't is getting anti-israel and getting their fast.

Trump wants to make sure there is a domestic latino force of zio-murderers who can soak up defense contracts hunting down Whites in America while his jew family watches it on TV in Trump tower.

Chase Brooks
Chase Brooks

They didn't see how FURIOUS the Dems got when he spoke about ending chain migration in to SOTU
Not surprised, y'all were likely boycotting it like the rest of you mindless drones.

They were silent all night but that was the one thing they could not control themselves over.

Oh but they're just magically going to come around because "DRUNPF IS A CUCK AND IS ACTUALLY EXPECTING THEM TO ACCEPT THE DEAL"

Stupid kike drones.

Levi Ramirez
Levi Ramirez

Yes, booing sells it. They will take the deal.
DRUMPF IS A CUCK
He is the exact opposite. He is moving in on White America for another killshot just like Reagan delivered.
Stupid kike drones.
The kikes are all in Trump's administration and his family. He even let a special kike out of prison.

Kevin Adams
Kevin Adams

Trump makes shitty amnesty deal that's generous to Democrats to make Democrats look like they prefer Dreamers over a strong border
Democrats refuse because they don't want to fund the wall, close chain migration etc
Progressives tell Democrats to take the deal
Democrats eventually come around to take the deal
Trump pulls a trick and says "You know, I think I've reconsidered the deal, my base doesn't really want this one, but here's what I can do…"
Suggest less generous deal with even more restrictions on immigration and fewer DACA recipients allowed
Democrats are desperate for something and don't want to shut the government down again before the midterms so they take the deal
Trump rescinds DACA in 2 years anyway because fuck Democrats

Colton Parker
Colton Parker

For the retarded among us, they're not going to take the deal because if they tried to Trump would load the thing up with a ton of legal guarantees and so on, he'd give them a piece of legislation to sign with all the loopholes blocked and no way to wriggle out of anything later. They won't take it for that reason alone, Trump still has latitude to sabotage the process however he likes even if they were to try accepting.

Luis Brooks
Luis Brooks

Them verbally hating the deal confirms that they will accept it

Are you retarded, a non-white, or a leftist? Either way, you do not belong here.

Hudson Jenkins
Hudson Jenkins

Watch the shills rage at this

Chase Butler
Chase Butler

They are selling you. You are being sold on their resistance. It's to make YOU feel good, like you got a good deal, like you put one over on them. You're a mark.

Easton Miller
Easton Miller

So what you are saying is that Trump is one of the greatest masterminds of our time. Or is it that the entire system is at his beck and call? Mind fucking blown, my fellow user.

Landon Taylor
Landon Taylor

Are you retarded, a non-white, or a leftist?
I'll go with Option D: All of the above.

Anthony Campbell
Anthony Campbell

Trump has been the steam valve in waiting for a long time. He's been owned by the Rothschilds for a long time. He's just the salesman here to make you feel good about getting your head on the block. He even apes campaign slogans from Reagan.

Mason Cruz
Mason Cruz

Don't forget to post TrumpYidWall.jpg too.

Connor Edwards
Connor Edwards

ShareBlue has literally resorted to "we're merely pretending!"

Aaron Bell
Aaron Bell

Trump wants to make sure there is a domestic latino force of zio-murderers who can soak up defense contracts hunting down Whites in America while his jew family watches it on TV in Trump tower.
Kek. You're an idiot.

Gabriel Gonzalez
Gabriel Gonzalez

Hot damn it's finally back, i thought you niggers would never post trumptoucheswall.jpg again after choking too much on your tears. What made you reconsider? Mayne an user from /baph/ should dox your personal home addresses again for this special occasion.

Jackson Bell
Jackson Bell

I can only think of one man who could possibly get us out of this mess. I'm sure he will make his move soon.

Andrew Martinez
Andrew Martinez

Would you prefer Trump's address to the UN in which he threatened global war against "revisionist powers"?

Juan Russell
Juan Russell

Rand is fully on board with Trump's amnesty. I'm not really sure what you're trying to say here except mine some old meme territory.

Wyatt Price
Wyatt Price

He's just playing politics.

Christopher Diaz
Christopher Diaz

What made you reconsider?
I've seen a bunch of comments on even NYT saying they were hoping this would be the thing to break Trump's base, I imagine Shareblue had a momentary pang of something resembling hope and had an involuntary twitch in their shilling muscles.

Jeremiah Perry
Jeremiah Perry

I get the feeling that shitlibs are still gonna pitch a massive fit, even if they get some form of amnesty.
Gonna rub the fact that burgers are getting a wall in the faces of the shitlibs I know.

Ryan Smith
Ryan Smith

Dems should take the deal because we just shut it down later.
I love Liberals who shoot themselves in the foot. I love all the Liberals. Do they think the President is like them and never reads opposition literature?

Joshua Rogers
Joshua Rogers

The dems have been fucking up pretty constantly for the past year+, they'll find a way to screw a themselves.

John Turner
John Turner

Why don't you explain to everyone exactly how he would stop them from undoing it all later when he is no longer in the White House?

Alexander Watson
Alexander Watson

It's a shit deal, and I hope the dems are retarded enough not to take it. DACA just expiring would be the best scenario for us.

Cameron Torres
Cameron Torres

Holla Forums needs to play both sides via sock accounts:
post as a moderate shitlib demanding this deal be accepted, because muh incremental gains
post as hard left shitcunts demanding total dissolution of all borders.

this is a wedge point that can fracture the left and weaken them. hop to it lads.

Nathan Young
Nathan Young

some random libtard professor is all democrats
The base will eat them alive if they compromise.

Kevin Harris
Kevin Harris

Tell the Dems to accept the deal, satisfy their current base, but lose access to unlimited spics via Chain Migration for an estimated 1.8 million spics, 12 years from now
If they honor the deal and dont just recind it once trump is gone.
Tell Dems not to accept the deal so they can keep Chain Migration and continue to get unlimited spics, but piss off their base and lose Amnesty for DACA recipients.
Who despite pissed will still vote at least 3/4 democrat and the 1 being a mix repub, green or abstain.
physically remove them
Big talk, what have YOU done to make that a reality? And no, calling ICE is not YOU doing anything to make it a reality, its you using an external group, a group vulnerable to kike subversion all the same, to do what YOU have not done YOURSELF. Rely on your own hands, mind and heart to shape the world, others may follow, but if you refuse to be the one to march forward, you can revel in the shit like everyone else.
While nice, trump seems to keep to his word, at least more than dems, and I would not count on repubs to scrap daca, rather they scrap the wall.

Luke Green
Luke Green

Yet still vote for them, the only way to keep a lib voting dem and its not even foolproof is them to attempt to kill but fail with only injuring a normalfag liberal, and even then that would not convince many as they will rationalize the attempted murder with shit logic.

Daniel Sanchez
Daniel Sanchez

Yet still vote for them
Who gives a shit.
The only important ones are the independents. And those by far favored Trump' speech.
Trump is STILL in full election mode for 2018.

Jonathan Scott
Jonathan Scott

I think Trump wants to "look reasonable" to the fence sitters and his cuckservative party members, and wants his supporters to loudly disapprove of any amnesty so he can say "oh well, I tried but the American people don't want it, and I was elected to serve the will of the people :^)".

In other words, realize this is a just a game here, and loudly disagree with any amnesty in the normiesphere. Tell Trump what he wants to hear: amnesty = no more support for the Republican party = no votes or support in the midterms. And of course, the cherry on the top: The left will get really asshurt over the Dems not quickly accepting the deal while it was still on the table, and will not go out to vote during the midterms.

Jacob Torres
Jacob Torres

THIS
Democrats need Spics for future votes since Liberals don't produce kids and niggers reproduce as much as they kill each other, so Trumps plan is to burden relationships between Spics, Libs and Democrats and have them swing at each other with this DACA deal fuckery while getting fence sitters on his side by appearing reasonable.

James Harris
James Harris

I didn't read OP to the end

Tyler Baker
Tyler Baker

This is the biggest problem with the deal, rags like the NYT are already advocating for it on the premise that all the stuff the Dems are giving up can be walked back after they regain power but its much harder to "undeport" someone.

Dylan Cruz
Dylan Cruz

McCarty recommended accepting the deal for temporary advantage
and then immediately violating the deal when they recover the White House
Democrats could chop enforcement funding and raise the annual inflow when they get back in power.
This is exactly what posters here said they would do if dems ever accepted an amnesty bargain. Democucks are predictable as fuck. Trump should not offer amnesty at all, even as a fake deal with many things attached to keep dems from accepting it. Because on the very slim chance that they DID accept it, that would be an instant demographic suicide.

On the upside, granting amnesty to criminal border crossers would likely accelerate rope day as the people will learn there are no peaceful solutions to white genocide.

Joseph Lewis
Joseph Lewis

It's interesting that this particular group of leftists has finally figured out what Holla Forums has known about the immigration debate for the past decade. I've got to wonder whether any of them will start to question whether the side that's consistently lied, cheated, and subverted the will of the people over more than half a century might not be on the right side of history.

At any rate, Trump's come out and said that the 'deal' he offered was just put forward to get congressional Democrats to admit that they care more about fucking over White people than protecting the poor innocent brown chilluns. He has no intention of seeing it pass, and neither does the House of Representatives. By all means, put pressure on him from the right, but believing despair shills who have, over the past 3 years, gone from insisting he was throwing the election to insisting he was going to take out Assad to insisting that amnesty was definitely going to happen is just idiotic, especially considering the fact that none of their canned lines includes a suggestion for action that doesn't glow in the fucking dark.

One faggot iterating through the talking points as mechanically as possible

I'm curious as to whether you think you're accomplishing something.

Zachary Ross
Zachary Ross

Thank you

Cooper Hill
Cooper Hill

wasn't rand also on the open borders train before trump?

Christian Ross
Christian Ross

He still is. Rand is pure lolbergtardian down to his mitochondria. He doesn't care if we have to take infinity beaners/mudslimes/KANGZ or if Jews control every lever of power as long as nobody has to pay taxes and you can smoke weed in public while playing with remote-control recreational nukes.

Juan Sullivan
Juan Sullivan

I've got to wonder whether any of them will start to question whether the side that's consistently lied, cheated, and subverted the will of the people over more than half a century might not be on the right side of history.
Their controllers make sure to insulate them from the truth and condition them to act irrationally when they encounter it. You can peel them away, but it takes a couple years. The fear of being ostracized keeps most of them in line.

Luis Cook
Luis Cook

Agreed.

Owen Young
Owen Young

Twitching corpses should be put to rest.

Nicholas Nelson
Nicholas Nelson

Trips of Truth confirm this train has no brakes.

Josiah Rivera
Josiah Rivera

giving 1.8 million spics citizenship
in exchange for anything

No. 1.8 million spics will turn into 5 million the way they reproduce. Here’s a reality check not every spic breaks the law or at least gets caught doing it so don’t act like they’re all going to get deported because they fucking won’t. You know what works even better than a wall? Not incentivizing spics to come over here by handing out gibs, making companies afraid of hiring them, and making them afraid to be here in the first place. Don’t get me wrong I want the wall too but it’s a moot point if means keeping nearly 2 million spics here. Let DACA expire and let’s get these spics out.

Ayden Edwards
Ayden Edwards

fuck off kike. those are not illegals they are spic invaders.

Jaxon Watson
Jaxon Watson

It's funny to watch the last remaining white boomers on the left try to appeal to logic that only works in a world where whites are still in control of the left. I wonder how long it will take for these lost souls to realize the impotence of their political position, I honestly think they may keep making appeals to white reasoning all the way to the grave at this point.

All I want is to someday be there in person to witness the lightbulb come on in one of these boomer's decaying minds. The look on their face when they realize they have been completely marginalized by the brown hordes they once defended is going to be priceless. Nothing is more inflated than a lefty boomer's ego and the realization that they no longer hold any power will burst an egotistical bubble that they'd been inflating for their entire lives.

James King
James King

Here’s a reality check not every spic breaks the law or at least gets caught doing it
No user, every single last one of them is a gangbanger and every single one of them will get deported by the BASED federal government. And there's no possible way the courts and bureaucracy will hamstring such efforts.
Not incentivizing spics to come over
Didn't e-verify get slashed from the amnesty deal? And it'll be a cold day in hell before anyone on Capitol Hill so much as touches the gibs train.

Blake Price
Blake Price

The fact is we don't need a deal to get all that shit done. Always say no to amnesty.