Marxism power rankings

GOD TIER
Communization
Autonomism

GREAT TIER
Council communism
DeLeonism

GOOD TIER
Trotskyism
Classical Marxism

BAD TIER
Marxism-Leninism
Marxism-Leninism-Maoism

TRASH TIER
Maoism (Third Worldism)
Juche

Other urls found in this thread:

libcom.org/library/iii-petty-bourgeois-distortion-features-communist-society-syndicalist-enterprise-sociali
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

moaism isn't as bad as juche tho

What are you even doing my dude.

Juche is just Third Worldism with Korean characteristics.


I listed communization, autonomism, and council communism.

Left communism isn't a singular ideology. A few flavors of leftcom is already on the list. Though I would also like to add…

PACIFIER PROLETARIAN TIER
Bordigism

The majority of leftcoms aren't really these though. The majority of modern leftcom's are either "italian" leftcoms (bordigists basically) or synthesists of some sort (a hybrid of dutch/german and italian left communism).

Just because Bordiga offends your anarchist sensibilities doesn't mean you should leave us off the list.

This opportunist hack belongs in the trash with Juche.

Wtf is communization

In communist political theory, communization is the process of abolishing ownership of the means of production, which, in societies dominated by the capitalist mode of production, are owned by individual capitalists, states, or other collective bodies. In some versions of communist theory, communization is understood as the transfer of ownership from private capitalist hands to the collective hands of producers, whether in the form of co-operative enterprises or communes, or through the mediation of a state or federation of workers' councils on a local, national, or global scale. In other programs, such as those of some left communists (e.g. Gilles Dauvé, Jacques Camatte), autonomists (e.g., Mario Tronti), and libertarian communists (e.g. Peter Kropotkin), communization means the abolition of property itself along with any state-like institutions claiming to represent a given subset of humanity. In these accounts humanity as a whole, directly or indirectly, would take over the task of the production of goods for use (and not for exchange). People would then have free access to those goods rather than exchanging labor for money, and distribution would take place according to the maxim "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need."

Bordiga is a leninist.

Alright, so how is that different from any sort of anarcho/libertarian socialist/communist movement?

It's different because they like Garl Margs

In the sense of being a follower of lenin, certainly, but he was in no way a leninist in the sense of the modern sense of the term. He is also one of the most important left communist theorists. The two things aren't mutually exclusive as you seem to believe.

He was a state capitalism apologist.

1/10 - try harder next time.

You're a retard.

Great argument.

he was literally one of the first to identify the USSR as capitalist, and did some of the most interesting work on detailing exactly how the USSR was capitalist.

I was reffering to his support for Lenin's policies. See for example here:
libcom.org/library/iii-petty-bourgeois-distortion-features-communist-society-syndicalist-enterprise-sociali

There's a difference between Bordiga's support for NEP (an outspokenly capitalist policy), and his criticism of Russian capitalism post-NEP, which was supposed to be 'really existing socialism'. Bordiga and Dunyevskaya were the first to guide the anti-Stalinist left to identifying the USSR as functionally capitalist.

I never said there wasn't. I'm pointing out his support for state capitalism during Lenin's reign.

Everyone knows this though, and it doesn't distract from the main point at all.

OK put Bordigists in a tier between good and great.

Trotskyism (North)
M-L

Syndicalism

Mutualism
Democratic Confederalism

All other types of """""Trotskyism"""""
Stalinism
Maoism
Anarcho-Hyphenism
Utopian Socialism
Critical Theory
"""""Post"""""-left anything

Socdems

Why is the left so fractured, m8s?