Is this one a socialism? Should WHITE farmers land be appropriated? After all,...

Noah Perry
Noah Perry

Is this one a socialism?

Should WHITE farmers land be appropriated? After all, a man's gotta eat.

Other urls found in this thread:

news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/live-malema-appears-in-newcastle-court-20161107

Leo Ortiz
Leo Ortiz

white farmers land

article says land has not been claimed

really made me scrach my noggin, /pol/

Matthew Hughes
Matthew Hughes

I guess the courts and Afriforum just imagined it then huh?

AS IT HAPPENED: 'No white person is the rightful owner of land in SA' - Malema

news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/live-malema-appears-in-newcastle-court-20161107

So I ask again. Should white farmers land be appropriated?

Ethan Murphy
Ethan Murphy

yes

Lucas Ward
Lucas Ward

If it was done for class reasons then yes. If it's done in the name of id pol, then no.

Christopher Phillips
Christopher Phillips

So should black farmers land be appropriated? And will taking the land from these white farmers not just create a new class that 'must have land'?

Jaxon Brown
Jaxon Brown

So should black farmers land be appropriated?
yes

Carter Jackson
Carter Jackson

Depends. If it was forcefully taken from them, then yes. If it was unoccupied then yes and not used, then yes.

Race doesn't matter. Class does. The bourgeoisie doesn't have a singular ethnicity.

Jason Bell
Jason Bell

Fair enough. Now do you think that Malema has socialistic ideals in mind here?

Camden Barnes
Camden Barnes

To me it seems more nationalistic. Claiming the land that was once ours etc.

It's not done for the working classes, but for certain ethnicities. A bit like how Hitler "reclaimed" the banks and buisnesses from DA JOOS.

Hudson Hughes
Hudson Hughes

So in your opinion it is fine when this guy 'reclaims' whit but was bad when Hitler did it?

Mason Cooper
Mason Cooper

And I said, if it was done in the name of class reasons then that's fine. If it was done in the name of idpol, which nationalism is, then no.

Mason Rogers
Mason Rogers

It's not about who is doing reclaiming but why. If private property stays private property but only change hands, it's pretty worthless.
If lands claimed by Blacks end up becoming Black Porky's property with Black proles under his heel, then it was all for nothing.

Jose Clark
Jose Clark

There is absolutely nothing to suggest any appropriated land was going to be given freely and without condition to the plebs.

Camden Roberts
Camden Roberts

EFF is trash level Maoist "muh ancestry" nationalism wrapped in left-wing rhetoric.

Carson Roberts
Carson Roberts

You're really begging for that tasty screenshot aren't you?

He said it was like Hitler, why do you even need to ask for clarity if it's OK when white people are the victims?

Jacob Murphy
Jacob Murphy

If people are occuplying the land, then it does not need to be "given" to them.

Xavier Jones
Xavier Jones

all land should be appropriated

James Rodriguez
James Rodriguez

private property is shit tbh

Brandon Reyes
Brandon Reyes

No this is not socialistic it's just nationalist populism justified with cold war rhetoric. If black SA farmers are allowed to own property and profit off of it then white farmers should be able to as well. Even if you buy that there is some case for cultural reclamation/preservation, the Voortrekkers in particular have been there for centuries at this point as independent settlers, not colonists. They were in violent competition with native africans but now they themselves have no identity seperate from africa.

Sebastian Reyes
Sebastian Reyes

Proles should claim land from porkies. That means white proles should take land from black porkies and black proles should take land from white porkies and white proles should take land from white porkies and black proles should take land from black porkies.

Class war 101.

Nathan Wood
Nathan Wood

Should farmers land be appropriated? After all, a man's gotta eat.
Yes. Seize the means of production and put them to use in service of the people.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Confirm your age

This website may contain content of an adult nature. If you are under the age of 18, if such content offends you or if it is illegal to view such content in your community, please EXIT.

Enter Exit

About Privacy

We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners.

Accept Exit