Oh dear

Dylan Harris
Dylan Harris

DISCUSS

Caleb James
Caleb James

What am I looking at?

Jordan Watson
Jordan Watson

Uhura
Useless

Connor Gutierrez
Connor Gutierrez

A flowchart with no directional arrow.

So, essentially the product of a retard with too much time on his hand.

Luis Flores
Luis Flores

couldn't find an example for the "Strong Female Character"
Anyways, shit thread, not much point posting this shit, as most of the characters aren't even Holla Forums.

Lincoln Green
Lincoln Green

Two retards, actually. Look at the bottom-right corner.

Sage for shit thread.

Isaac Rivera
Isaac Rivera

Well, they completely fucked up on literally the first point. Not every good character can "carry their own story". To draw a male example: Hayt from Dune Messiah is an excellent character, but his nature inherently prevents him from carrying a story by himself.
So yeah, it's a dumb chart that falls flat in step one.

Jordan Bennett
Jordan Bennett

You can tell how flawed the chart is if you broaden the net, drop the "female" bit, and run any character through this.

Kevin Lewis
Kevin Lewis

I like how this faggots bitch about fictional characters and the roles they have in the story

Brody Bell
Brody Bell

What kind of personality is that? I've only read Dune. Is it the generic outspoken friendly MC that bounces off of supporting and secondary characters ?

Cooper Ross
Cooper Ross

What's the point of this chart anyway?

Justin Clark
Justin Clark

To create an ideological justification for hating any female character in any medium.

Jose Jones
Jose Jones

To be fair, there are directional arrows, they just don't make sense chronologically.

Ian Turner
Ian Turner

let's reduce the entire character to a single feature that we treat as a category

Christopher Bennett
Christopher Bennett

Googled both of them.
Both have twitter, (of fucking course) Shana doesn't really have anything informative to say just virtue signals all day any anti Trump shit they can find. Basically the average libtard.
The guy unironically has "Architect of Social Justice" as a title under his name and spams motivational lines that he probably just copy pasted from brainyquote.
I'm starting to be not even suprised that the people who preach this garbage always look and act the same like a bunch of cultists.

Easton Hughes
Easton Hughes

Uses a shitload of good female characters as examples of stereotypes
Whether or not a character is "strong" depends if they are alive by the third act
Implies people call characters Mary Sues because women like the, not because they are shit characters
>Implies Angelica of all people is a "voice of reason" rather than a manipulator
Guy misuses "architect" just virtue signal
The cunt has a kid that she is likely going to push social justice onto

Let me guess… Shana is a single mother and the guy is one of her fuck buddies?

Thomas Ross
Thomas Ross

Ripley
According to the chart she either: can't carry a story, is not three dimensional, represents an idea, or has no flaws
according to the chart she is not a part of a team
If you answer yes to "is she a leader", you can be taken to 'Catlady,' 'Happy Single Mom,' and 'Spoiled Rich Girl' among others
It's complete shit. Chart invents bunch of pointless categories into which almost every female character ever conceived can be pigeonholed into.

Girl Hitler
Picture of Azula instead of Girl Hitler
Couldn't even get that right.

Mlawski is also a New Yorker, went to Yale, and now works as a glorified SAT tutor. She wrote a kid's book too. It would be interesting to see where her characters place in that flowchart.

Jason Morris
Jason Morris

fuck buddy
probably not, she just keeps him around because he can be useful and he is so thirsty he will never grow a spine and do something else.

Luis Parker
Luis Parker

by Shana Mlawski
hm….

Nathaniel Green
Nathaniel Green

Twitter nobodies who have no talent analyzing works by people who do

There is nothing new or important about the information in this thread.

Wyatt Barnes
Wyatt Barnes

Showed this to my gf and she thinks that it's a parody. I could see it making fun of Sarkeesianesque analysis where literally any small thing can disqualify a character from being "good".

Tyler Evans
Tyler Evans

"Strong Female Character"
Flawed
Pick one

Carter Lee
Carter Lee

The problem I find with this is that it's…

Allow me to get my soapbox really quick. There we go.

The problem is that people have to pigeon hole everything.

Guess I didn't need the soapbox just to say that. So, yeah, it's just them wanting everything to fit into their little categorical system.

Henry Hughes
Henry Hughes

reddit spacing

please learn to not be a newfag.

Cooper Roberts
Cooper Roberts

To add to the user about your Reddit spacing issue, don't fucking LARP in text. Ever. Do not ever fucking type out an action, or narrate an action, or you're a filthy fucking redditor who can't figure out that over here, we don't care about your memes and don't upboat.

mods deleted other threads
left this shit one about
Nice.

Ian Flores
Ian Flores

which Uhura the old one or the reboot one?

Nolan Rogers
Nolan Rogers

The more complicated and accurate answer is that this image is bullshit for a multitude of reasons and should be disregarded entirely, but I think it would be much more effective and crush these people more to simply (and very obviously) cover over all the current images and titles and make a version with male characters to demonstrate they're full of shit.

Jaxon Gomez
Jaxon Gomez

spoiler
Wasn't there a version of this chart that had her as a "spoiled brat"? She's only a 3 year old.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page