Questions for "Real" Socialists.

Benjamin Roberts
Benjamin Roberts

America falls and Ancomtopia takes it's place
You're the head honcho of my local governance
I hire a guy called Jim to help me tend to my farm, and I pay in currency him.
What will you guys do?

All urls found in this thread:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fgq26e5HXKs&t=1m37s
Landon Sanders
Landon Sanders

the head honcho
So then it's not anarcho-communism. There are no """head honchos"""

Matthew King
Matthew King

counterfeit ur currency

nothing personel kiddo

Ian Jenkins
Ian Jenkins

your currency would be valueless and there'd be no head honcho to punish you

sage for retardation

Nathaniel Parker
Nathaniel Parker

Why would he want currency when everything he needs is already available free of charge?

Gavin Miller
Gavin Miller

There's no """head honcho""" in any forms of anarchism. Rules of communities are decided democratically by those who reside there. In addition to that, currency has no value in communism, because it's either pieces of paper or metal coins we're told are worth something when in reality they're not. Metal coins have little use outside of being paperweights and paper money has no effective use (you could try to write on them, I suppose)
If you "hire" jim to help you tend your farm, and you split the output evenly (I'm assuming it's only you and jim working it) between you and jim, there's no problem

Robert Flores
Robert Flores

Can someone ban mentally challenged, attention whoring namefags already

Andrew Lee
Andrew Lee

democracy
not inherently flawed

typical ancom showing his true authoritarian colors

Luke Ortiz
Luke Ortiz

Jim: d00d what am i supposed to do with money? u could've just asked for some help tbh fam, i'm sure someone would like to live on a farm with you.

Xavier Sullivan
Xavier Sullivan

America falls and Ancomtopia takes it's place
ok first of that would never happen
even of the U.S economy/gov completely collapsed it would become social-democracy/Market-Socialism/maybe state-socialism at most

now on to the hypothetical
AnCom society
paying him currency for work
Where would he spend the currency???
it would be worthless

Landon Cox
Landon Cox

you're the honcho of local governance
the honcho would be the majority of a given vote. It's trading police for mob rule and capital-driven labor for physically coerced labor. Truly a paradise.

Blake Gray
Blake Gray

way to cover the yellow in your flag

Ian Garcia
Ian Garcia

Ok, you're apart of the governance then.

Ayden Murphy
Ayden Murphy

non-compulsory labor = ancap

Wyatt Murphy
Wyatt Murphy

arrest you, shoot you, and sell your family as slaves to black people

Easton Wright
Easton Wright

well that's a given. everyone is part of governance

Ryder Scott
Ryder Scott

Commisar cleetus puts you in the cuckshed while a nigger uses your toothbrush.

Cameron Phillips
Cameron Phillips

So it will be illegal?
How very anarcho of you.

Owen Cox
Owen Cox

i mean gift, i forgot we dont have any monies now

Jaxon Brown
Jaxon Brown

"voluntary" labor isn't the hottest ancap meme
damn you're bad at this

Lucas Jones
Lucas Jones

my comrade

Liam Brooks
Liam Brooks

ancap admits he's not even an anarchist
LOL

Henry Hughes
Henry Hughes

So no one in america will try to follow old way?(I.E. try to bring back currency, like gold and stuff)

Landon Thompson
Landon Thompson

ur ancap bc i insist you are
sure thing. just keep your authoritarianism to your hard drive, faggot.

Levi Robinson
Levi Robinson

So you're house would be free of charge in an Ancomtopia?

Camden Ross
Camden Ross

aslong as there are non-compulsory property rights then

Christian Lewis
Christian Lewis

oh so just because i verbatim parrot ancap retardation that means i'm an ancap??
yeah user that's actually how it works

Oliver Gutierrez
Oliver Gutierrez

not being an illegalist

David Hill
David Hill

*Claps*
First smart commie in this thread.

Dylan Morgan
Dylan Morgan

I am not a communist???????????????

Chase Phillips
Chase Phillips

no problem fam

Jose Jenkins
Jose Jenkins

we good

Lucas Flores
Lucas Flores

Assumes everyone in Ancomtopia would agree that currency has no value
People for years have been using currency, you can't just get rid of that over night.

Connor Butler
Connor Butler

yes we can, let's just counterfeit it

Asher Bell
Asher Bell

kek

Jayden Diaz
Jayden Diaz

Everyone I don't like is X.

Juan Cooper
Juan Cooper

I'm a classical liberal you retard.

Jacob Lopez
Jacob Lopez

Oh, no wonder what you said was smart.

Hunter Hughes
Hunter Hughes

IE you're a pussy meme conservative

Julian James
Julian James

oh so everyone who's x is an x now????

Parker Wright
Parker Wright

So it will be illegal?
What a true anarchy this world would be.

Lucas Hall
Lucas Hall

do you know what counterfeit means?

John Cook
John Cook

It means that, that money is fake and is illegal to use as real money.

Joseph Rogers
Joseph Rogers

collectivism
dumb meme
communism is individualist

Caleb Clark
Caleb Clark

self-described classical liberal
calls post-left anarchist a collectivist
liberalism is truly the most terminal form of cancer

Hudson Robinson
Hudson Robinson

Everyone I don't like is X

Joseph Williams
Joseph Williams

Funny, I say the same thing about you commie scum.

Anthony Johnson
Anthony Johnson

all money is fake and in ancom the lack of a state to back and enforce the validity of currency would make counterfeiting invalidate any use for currency as a means of exchange.

Austin Bailey
Austin Bailey

im not an expert in AnCom but most AnComs reject the concept of currency outright
so if this hypothetical society still used money then it likely couldnt be considered full blown AnCom
you can't just get rid of that over night.
Labor vouchers/Mutal Aid/voluntary collectivism etc

Nicholas Moore
Nicholas Moore

let's cut to the chase famalam. give me all your toothbrushes.

Owen Jackson
Owen Jackson

See

Isaiah White
Isaiah White

Yes.

Jose Young
Jose Young

collectivism/individualism dichotomy as if choosing a faction

Thomas Smith
Thomas Smith

How is that relevant to counterfeiting rendering currency impossible to use for exchange thus sabotaging any attempts by people to revert t using currency?

Isaac Gomez
Isaac Gomez

Come get 'em.

Austin Fisher
Austin Fisher

post-left anarchy
communism
oh i get it, you just have no idea what you're talking about

Jace Garcia
Jace Garcia

Gold for example.

Adrian Turner
Adrian Turner

An-com = Anarchal Communism

Jaxson Perez
Jaxson Perez

post-left anarchy =/= anarcho-communism
it's literally a rejection of communism in anarchy. but you've proven you're the brainlet of all brainlests so I don't expect this to make sense to you

Carter Stewart
Carter Stewart

implying capitalism isn't incompatible with individualism

Joseph Foster
Joseph Foster

So the com part doesn't stand for communism? They what does the cap part of Ancap stand for?

Josiah Hernandez
Josiah Hernandez

ancom = anarcho-communism
ancap = anarcho-capitalism
post-left anarchy =/= either

Andrew White
Andrew White

I like the top one. The small black theft is about to be shoot.

Noah Jenkins
Noah Jenkins

socialism should be everyone's hand in everyone's back pocket

Henry Ortiz
Henry Ortiz

That guy represents the capitalist m80.

Easton Wright
Easton Wright

REVOLUTIONARY D00D

Landon Barnes
Landon Barnes

elaborate

Josiah Perry
Josiah Perry

communism is taxation

Oliver Miller
Oliver Miller

OP asked a simple question.
The question is easily found by lurking a bit
OP is retarded
Retards reply to OP with equally retarded shit.
Thread is retarded
sage and abandon
answer is here

Austin Rivera
Austin Rivera

We would put a bullet in you and give the farm to Jim.

Dylan Ward
Dylan Ward

Isn't that just retardese for "economic conservative"?

Leo Morales
Leo Morales

Well it is the way of allah so of course they will
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fgq26e5HXKs&t=1m37s

John Gutierrez
John Gutierrez

Like the Commies of old and the kulaks, during kulak genocide.

Evan Barnes
Evan Barnes

see

Jack Powell
Jack Powell

'Classical liberal' needs to be filtered to closet fascist

Asher Rogers
Asher Rogers

Why would anyone accept shiny rocks or pieces of paper when they have no value in this society? There is no decentralized production. You can get what you need/want from society.

There's nothing stopping me from going out into a field, declaring myself king, and demanding everyone submit to me, but no one is going to listen to me and most likely I'll just be laughed at or ignored.

Hudson Evans
Hudson Evans

Because some people would put value of them. Kings gain power through might, and the power gained by their for fathers.

Disable AdBlock to view this page

Disable AdBlock to view this page